Cambridge, Mass. police Sgt. Crowley responded to the call. The 911 caller didn't mention a black man, but, it was reported that Sgt. Crowley made the assumption that the prowlers were two black men wearing backpacks. By the time Sgt. Crowley arrived Professor Gates was already inside the house. At some point Gates showed Crowley his identification and established that he lived in the house. For some reason an altercation broke out between the two men. No one knows exactly what happened or what caused the confusion. Gates was just getting home; he was probably tired and already a little tense because he had trouble getting into his home. He probably didn't control his anger as well as he should have.
Sgt Crowley was probably annoyed with Professor Gates for something he said. Regardless, Sgt Crowley didn't control his anger as well as he should have, either. Once it was established that this was the man's house, it should have ended there. Sgt Crowley was not in any danger, he was not threatened by Professor Gates, he was probably angry at things Gates said; however, it is not a crime to disagree with a police officer. A man should not be arrested in his own home because he said something a police office did not like; if this was the case.
I'm not sure that race played a part in this arrest. I don't want to believe that it did. Some police officers may get a feeling of power and authority and the need to be in full control once they are in uniform with their guns and other weapons in place. Was this, probably, more of a power thing; where a police officer didn't like the way a citizen was talking back to him; so he arrested that citizen for disorderly conduct? Police officers should not put themselves so high above everyone else and think nobody should get angry or express their anger. When a person get angry at a police officer or anyone, they need to conrtol their anger. However, there should not have been an arrest; all charges were later dropped against Professor Gates.
Many people takes this as a racist situation, some believe that racism played a big part in this incident. However, I'm still not satisfied that this was a racist situation. It did become a big racial drama.
President Obama admitted he may have used the wrong choice of words when he said the police acted stupidly. It is a good idea that the president, the arresting police officer and the Harvard professor are getting together on Thursday for beer in the Rose Garden Patio at the white house. It could help to defuse the racial tension that has flared up from the incident. Maybe, the police officer and the professor can learn a lesson and see where they both could have handled the situation differently.
I love it that the president is such a down to earth man. He is commander in chief; yet he is one of us. Most of us can relate to him as a man as well as a president. I really appreciate the way he can say, ok, I made a mistake, I'm sorry, now let's move on. He doesn't say it in those exact words; but, I appreciate the way he can admit to a mistake and move on to more important issues.
Racism will probably always be with us; but, we have to learn how to deal with it, we need to talk about it in a positive way. We shouldn't be afraid to admit that racism is still with us; but, we shouldn't think that everything between a white police officer and a minority person is racist. On the other hand, we cannot be blinded to the fact that there are still a lot of problems between police officers and the minority communities.
In a lot of cases, some police officers over react when a minority is involved. They are too quick to use excessive force or to shoot or make an arrest. Sometimes they need to communicate, let a citizen ask questions about why are they being detained or why are you here? Treat all citizens alike. Have you ever noticed that when a minority is stopped, sometime for just a traffic ticket or jay walking, they are sitting on the ground while other citizens that are stopped for the same reasons get to stand or sit in the car. This happens a lot. There are, also, a lot of very decent and good police officers out there and I give them credit and appreciate them.
President Obama said we can use this as a learning experience, one lesson that can be learned is, there's a great need for more trust and communication between the minority communities and police officers. Even though racism still exists, every incident between a white police officer and a minority should not be labeled as racist. Police officers and minorities should listen to each others. Police officers should not be the enemy; nor should they treat minorities in a way that they or looked upon as the enemy.
Another thing to be learned is racism should not be covered up. We need to admit that it still exists. We shouldn't be afraid to talk about it in a positive way. When things get out in the open, it has a way of disappearing. Racism may never disappear altogether, but it may help to stop sweeping it under the rugs. We need to admit that it is still with us; but, we cannot say that every time there are problems between white police officers and minorities; that it is racist.
A few years ago, a family member passed out in my home. I called 911 three times without a response; I'm glad this don't happen very often. Actually, it was the first and last time for me. While I was on the phone the children were screaming and crying in the back ground. Finally, the family member that had passed out, came around. We decided to rush him to the hospital in the family car. WOW! when we stepped outside the door, there were police officers all over the place, some with guns drawn.
I immediately explained that we had a seriously ill person that had passed out and we were taking this person to the emergency room. I explained that we called 911 three times but it didn't go through. The officers were ordered to put away their guns.
Turned out my 911 calls did go through, there were so much screaming and crying from the children in the back ground; the people who listened to the 911 calls, on the other end, thought it was a hostage situation. All along, I thought my calls had not gone through and we had no idea as to why so many police officers were around the house when we stepped outside.
When my family walked out of our front door; it was a dangerous situation for everyone involved; for my family and for the police officers. They didn't know who were coming out that door, they didn't know if weapons were involved; they were treating it like a hostage situation. And we didn't expect to see all these officers because I didn't even realize that my calls to 911 had gone through.
This was not a racist situation, the police officers were at the scene with their guns drawn because they thought it was a hostage situation despite the fact that it was a black family living here. We understood that the officers didn't have their guns drawn because we were black; they had guns drawn because they thought something very dangerous was going down.
Sometimes, everybody need to breath and calm down and communicate. In this case tensions were running high on both ends, but, we all handled the situation with cool heads. The officers even offered to escort the family to the hospital. If either side had blown things out of proportion, this could have turned out differently. In this case the police officers weren't trigger happy, they waited to see what was going on. When my family walked out into the mist of all those police officers, we kept our cool. In a case like this, you obey the police orders, because they assume they are in a dangerous situation. The police officers in this case handled things in a very professional manner.
Even though there are still a lot of racism in the United States, we shouldn't look at every situation between white police officers and minorities as a racist situation.
In the Crowley arrested Gates situation, I believe both men should have handled things more responsibly and there should not have been an arrest. Gates had a right to get angry in his own home. Crowley had a right to get angry at things Gates said to him. It was gates home, Crowley should have walked away. However, I wouldn't go as far as to say it was a racist situation. It was a case where both men should have handled things more responsibly.
Published by Mary E. Coe
I write articles, songs, poetry, short stories and stageplays. Some of my writings are fictitious and some are fact based. In the Spring of 1993, some of my poems were published in the library at Citrus Col... View profile
The President, the Professor and the Police SergeantThe arrest of Harvard Professor Henry Gates by the Cambridge Police Department set off a firestorm recently, and the President of the United States added fuel to the fire.
United States to Play for Gold Medal in Women's Soccer with Win Over Japan By defeating Japan by a score of 4-2, the United States advances to the Gold Medal Game of Women's Soccer against Brazil.- An Evolving Democracy: The United StatesAt no other time in the 200-year history of the United States has there been a greater opportunity for people to be involved in the evolution of democracy.
- Female Circumcision in the United StatesFemale circumcision is currently performed in the United States to enhanse sexuals sesation and for cosmetic reasons. In the past extreme forms of female circumcision were practiced in the United States.
- Cambridge Police Releases Gates Arrest 911 TapesThe Cambridge Police Department has released the 911 tape of a woman reporting a possible break in at the residence of Henry Louis Gates, the African American Harvard Professor whose subsequent arrest has caused a nat...
- Professor Gates, Sgt Crowley and Obama the Divider
- Sgt. Crowley, Professor Gates and the Silliness of Race
- Cambridge Police Sergeant James Crowley Cuffs Elite Harvard Professor, Henry Louis...
- An Overview of the Non Profit Sector in the United States
- Working as a Background Talent on Showtime's The United States of Tara
- Great Inventions Courtesy of the United States Government
- An Analysis of the United States Oil Policy and OPEC




6 Comments
Post a Commentfunny, once you start getting to know each other you realize not all whites are racists, you know? Have to judge on a case-by-case basis. Great piece of article!
I had an incident when a State Trooper threatened to arrest me for disturbing the peace. I was in the shower when he started knocking. Blah, blah, blah. He was off duty and doing a favor for his lady friend who broke into her former apt. next door. Bottom line, I lost my temper, answered door wrapped in a towel. I did not know if he could arrest me for disturbing the peace (what Gates was arrested for) but since son was due home from kindergarten I did not test him. I do think Gate's case was racist.
very well done.
Very well written piece Mary..thank you.
Thank you for your balanced and sensible assessment. You are right... there is a lot of unresolved tension around the issue, and communication breaks down easily.
You took a sensible look at the situation.