Renting Vs. Owning When You Are Poor

Amber S.
One of the most important questions to ask yourself when considering where you want to live is whether you will rent or buy your home, apartment, or condo. Some places even have lease-to-own options so you should consider that as well.

When poor, it is almost always a good idea to rent rather than attempt to own. There are several reasons for this. For one, if you have poor credit, you will be unlikely to get a good interest rate on your mortgage. You will end up paying more per month than you can afford.

Another benefit to renting is the cost of upkeep and repairs. If your home's air conditioner or heater goes out, you may have to spend thousands of dollars on a new one. If you have no way to get that money, you may never be able to afford to replace it. Being unable to afford the constant repairs that a home needs can mean that you will lose your investment in the home and it will not be worth as much as you paid for it if it comes time to sell. If you rent, however, your landlord is responsible for replacing the item.

Owning a home also comes with a lot of other costs. You will need to spend more money on water bills for yard care. You are responsible for repairing any damage or wear to the home. Plumbing emergencies can become expensive. You also have to buy insurance and pay taxes at the end of each year. These things can sneak up on someone who is trying living paycheck to paycheck.

Owning a home makes relocation extremely difficult. If you need to switch jobs, you may be forced to try to find something in the area. Selling a home is difficult and tedious and very much a gamble. If you are unable to put a lot into it, you are unlikely to get even as much as you paid for it.

Renting, on the other hand, means that you can relocate easily at a moment's notice. If you need to switch jobs, move to be near family, or escape a natural disaster, you can move to a new place without worrying about paying for your old one.

So, if you are living on a tight budget, avoid buying your home. It could end up costing you a lot more than you bargained for and could cause years of trouble for your family. Renting carries a lot of perks, namely the fact that you hold no monetary responsibility for the property.

Published by Amber S.

I am a young work-at-home-mom living in Hawaii. I am a wife, professional writer, photographer, web designer, and artist. I also create handmade jewelry. Check out my work at amberskyfire.etsy.com.  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • lola9/19/2009

    Thank you so much for writing this. My hubby and I have long ago decided never to buy a home. People think we are crazy, but these are the practical reasons why.

    We live in a slum but when our plumbing or heating goes out, we just call the landlord.

    There also spiritual and political reasons. It wouldn't make sense for an anarcho-communist to own property. Besides the fact that home owners are never happy, always remodeling or complaining about yard work.

  • Bianca4/24/2009

    Thanks for posting this. I have been contemplating this issue for a while now, because we are in our one year of living with my parents to prepare for moving to where my husband will need to go to grad school. When we move, we will be there for at least 5 yrs, and I would like to have children and be a WAHM at that point so it was kind of making sense for us to invest in a home. However, I think about the potential for emergency repairs. I think back to being a renter and the things we got fixed, although there have been cases where the landlord did not act in a timely fashion, in the end we did not foot the bill, just the inconvenience. I guess my main worry is getting caught in a trap with always having rent payments and never being able to save up enough of a down payment for a home. I see that around me with some of my relatives. What do you think about that?

    I guess the key would be to rent minimally though. One cousin of mine, for example, has three children (2 in elementary,

  • Lori Voth (Revezbelle)4/21/2009

    Renting in my opinion is way smarter than owning until you are well on your feet financially.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.