COMMENTARY | The Tea Party faction of the Republican Party has a new darling candidate, and it's not Michele Bachman or the non-declared Sarah Palin. While the Republican debate Wednesday was largely void of substance, there were clear winners and losers.
Winners - Rick Perry and Mitt Romney
The belle of the ball was definitely Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who came out determined to cement himself into the frontrunner status he vaulted into when he entered the race. He likely accomplished that task but at the same time lessened any chances he might have had in the general election against President Barack Obama.
Instead of backing away from his fringe statement calling Social Security a "Ponzi Scheme," Perry doubled down, according to the Washington Post. Perry can't take the position and win with it in a general election. He will still garner votes from Tea Party seniors and workers who can be counted on to vote against their own interests, but that won't be enough.
Romney, along with Jon Huntsman, won simply by refusing to run to the fringe even more. The debate was held in the Reagan Library, but most current Republican voters would boo Reagan off the stage for being too liberal. Romney was able to keep enough distance between himself and those guaranteed to lose, like Perry.
Losers - Michele Bachmann and the Tea Party
Bachmann saw her 15 minutes effectively come to an end. The exit door for her opened when Perry entered the race, and the Texas two-stepper escorted her all the way out last night. His Social Security comments thankfully injure his chances of winning the general election; some of his other positions are equally troubling. Whether meaning to or not, Perry put himself at the same level as those who for centuries denied the science Galileo showed the world with his simple telescope.
"Galileo got outvoted for a spell," Perry said in the same type of down-home Texas speak we thought left the national stage with George W. Bush.
That's the part of the debate that made headlines in the foreign press. The Guardian UK declares "The world needs to prepare for a climate sceptic [sic] defeating Obama."
Perry may hope that accepted climate science gets outvoted for a spell that's long enough to get him elected, but the world will pay the price if that happens. It's not that surprising Perry's Texas is on fire while he left to join the GOP debate. That in itself isn't a big deal, but the fact that he is staying in California a few more days for fundraisers is likely to raise eyebrows.
Bachmann, who at one point didn't say a word for 20 minutes, discovered there is only room for one engineer on the Republican crazy train. She was the one who kicked Sarah Palin to the caboose, and now finds herself a bunk mate to the half-term former governor.
Winners - Rick Perry and Mitt Romney
The belle of the ball was definitely Texas Gov. Rick Perry, who came out determined to cement himself into the frontrunner status he vaulted into when he entered the race. He likely accomplished that task but at the same time lessened any chances he might have had in the general election against President Barack Obama.
Instead of backing away from his fringe statement calling Social Security a "Ponzi Scheme," Perry doubled down, according to the Washington Post. Perry can't take the position and win with it in a general election. He will still garner votes from Tea Party seniors and workers who can be counted on to vote against their own interests, but that won't be enough.
Romney, along with Jon Huntsman, won simply by refusing to run to the fringe even more. The debate was held in the Reagan Library, but most current Republican voters would boo Reagan off the stage for being too liberal. Romney was able to keep enough distance between himself and those guaranteed to lose, like Perry.
Losers - Michele Bachmann and the Tea Party
Bachmann saw her 15 minutes effectively come to an end. The exit door for her opened when Perry entered the race, and the Texas two-stepper escorted her all the way out last night. His Social Security comments thankfully injure his chances of winning the general election; some of his other positions are equally troubling. Whether meaning to or not, Perry put himself at the same level as those who for centuries denied the science Galileo showed the world with his simple telescope.
"Galileo got outvoted for a spell," Perry said in the same type of down-home Texas speak we thought left the national stage with George W. Bush.
That's the part of the debate that made headlines in the foreign press. The Guardian UK declares "The world needs to prepare for a climate sceptic [sic] defeating Obama."
Perry may hope that accepted climate science gets outvoted for a spell that's long enough to get him elected, but the world will pay the price if that happens. It's not that surprising Perry's Texas is on fire while he left to join the GOP debate. That in itself isn't a big deal, but the fact that he is staying in California a few more days for fundraisers is likely to raise eyebrows.
Bachmann, who at one point didn't say a word for 20 minutes, discovered there is only room for one engineer on the Republican crazy train. She was the one who kicked Sarah Palin to the caboose, and now finds herself a bunk mate to the half-term former governor.
Published by Jeff Musall
Jeff Musall has a passion for writing, a knack for frank and informed expression, and a desire to engage the minds of readers. He is an avid sports fan across the board and loves good competitions. His work... View profile
- You Thought Michele Bachmann Had a Credibility Problem Before?In politics, as with most things in life, one should choose one's associates well. Call it the "company you keep" maxim. Rep. Michele Bachmann might want to refresh her memory on what everyone's parents have told the...
Host a Tea Party No One Will Forget! A tea party is a perfect way to invite others into your home for a time of fellowship and refreshment.- How to Host a Little Girl Tea Party Tea Parties are the perfect way for little girls to socialize with their friends while making memories that will last a lifetime. Hosting a tea party is inexpensive, and you don't even need a special occasion such as...
- Top Five Tea Party Kids' GamesEveryone enjoys a good tea part; here are some games to make your tea party a success!
- Tea Party Protest Not Political Party RallyTea Party protests are for the people to speak and must not be a platform for politicians to campaign. Politicians need to stay home and listen.
- Michele Bachmann for President: Says She is "In" At Iowa Rally
- Working While Applying for Social Security Disability Benefits - a Person Has to Live
- Tea Party Themes for Your Child's Birthday
- Michele Bachmann, President? Scary Thought or Bold Prediction?
- Michele Bachmann - Right Wing Obama?
- Michele Bachmann, Sarah Palin: Shame Women with "Winks" and "Blinks"
- Michele Bachmann: No Division of Party Lines on Getting Hair like Her's




5 Comments
Post a Commentlove the punchy style of this piece
Anybody who thinks Perry and Romney have already dispatched all challengers have a short memory. Only three years ago Rusy Guiliani and Fred Thompson had opened daylight on John McCain.
At the same time, anybody who thinks Palin is hopeless out of it, doesn't comprehend how social networking has changed the game. Without spending a nickel in New Hampshire she outdrew Romney when they both spoke on the same afternoon.
Finally, anybody who thinks Palin is motivated solely by financial gain or a need to be center stage doesn't understand the woman. She is driven by conviction, not money, but most of all she is driven by a need for payback. By any reasonable standard, she was the victim of some of the most merciless personal attacks I have witnessed by political enemies since Nixon was being investigated during Watergate and Clinton was fighting to avoid impeachment.
She will run if for no other reason than she will have the opportunity to thumb her nose at those
who have maligned her.
Hey Michael, I catch myself using the alternates from time-to-time as well..
The stupider the Republican and the more he will hurt the middle class or working class, the more they will vote for him.
By the way, "sceptic" is the standard spelling on the other side of the Atlantic.
...yeah but it's early yet Jeff. We can't count anyone in or out just yet. (But R's do seem to love Texas governors don't they?)