Roth IRA vs. 401k
The Roth IRA provides a tax free retirement vehicle funded by after-tax dollars. In other words, contributions to Roth IRA's are not tax deductible, but when withdrawn during your golden years you owe no taxes on those withdrawals. On the other hand, 401k accounts grow tax deferred, meaning contributions are deducted from your income in the year you make contributions, but taxes are assessed upon withdrawal. So which strategy is best? Honestly, a combination of the two probably makes the most sense. Many employers match 401k contributions, and turning down free money doesn't make much sense. If you are fortunate enough to work for a company that matches contributions then I recommend funding a 401k through that matching percentage. If your company matches the first 4% then you should fund 4% of your salary towards a 401k. Any additional retirement funding should be directed towards a Roth IRA to take advantage of the tax free growth.
Taxes on the Seed or the Harvest?
One of the best analogies I've ever heard regarding the comparison between a Roth IRA and a 401k in terms of taxation is "would you rather pay taxes on the seed or the harvest?" In other words, would you rather pay taxes on your contributions early in your career, or on the eventual hundreds of thousands of dollars you may amass in a tax-deferred account such as a 401k. Common sense tells us to pay taxes on the "seed," or on the after-tax contributions made to a Roth while your income is relatively low. Sure, you won't get a tax break now, but the tax free withdrawals in retirement are well worth the sacrifice.
Limitations
Currently, individuals may contribute up to $4,000 of earned income in a tax year (this amount increases to $5,000 in 2008. If you are over 50 years old you may make an additional $1,000 contribution referred to as "catch-up" contributions. Our government regulations continue to punish the most successful wage earners in our society, so married couples making over $166,000 do not qualify ($114,000 for single filers). Married couples filing joint returns that make between $156,000 and $165,999 may qualify to make a partial contribution (see IRS publication 590 for details).
Published by Tyler Foster
I am a 30 year old husband and father of two working in software development for money, but writing for fulfillment. View profile
- �Cuáles Son Las Ventajas Tributarias De Una Cuenta IRA Roth?La principal ventaja tributaria de una IRA Roth es que, aunque sus aportes no son deducibles, sus ganancias pueden acumularse libre de impuestos y los retiros calificados generalmente no son tributables y se puede hac...
- ROTH 401k Permanent, Take Advantage Now!Congress has made the ROTH 401k a permanent part of US tax code, and many employers are now implementing these types of accounts. ROTH 401k accounts offer additional tax advantages over traditional 401ks and should be...
- How to Save Money If You Don't Have IRA or 401k Options at WorkWhat about those of us who work for companies that don't include such luxuries as IRA, 401k's in their employment packages?
- How to Set Up a Roth IRAHow to set up a Roth IRA account, including choices of administrator, research, and fees.
- Financial Tips: Roth IRA 101A description and overview of Roth IRA accounts, how to qualify for them and the benefits of investing in one.
- Individual Retirement Account: Roth IRA
- Roth IRA: Important Tool for Retirement Savings
- What Everyone Should Know About Roth IRA's
- Investing with a ROTH IRA
- Top 10 Roth IRA Tips
- Choosing an IRA: Roth vs Traditional
- IRA Conversions and What They Mean for You





2 Comments
Post a CommentGreat article. Thanks for the advice.
some sound financial advice, especially for people my age.