Comparison and contrasts can be seen between the two films, not the least of which is the presence and portrayal of the outlaw figure. In The Wild Bunch (TWB), there are several outlaws who are bound together by a code. The code can be described as professionals maintaining their professionalism in a world that no longer cares about their profession. The head of the gang is played by William Holden, who bears the weight of his character with dogged aplomb. These men kill for money but somehow we care for them. This is the beauty of great westerns, such as The Searchers, who can evoke sympathy toward malicious men. In Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (PGBK), the protagonist isn't so clear. Pat Garrett, played beautifully by James Coburn, is the sheriff hunting down Billy and turns out to be more of an outlaw than Billy, played by Kris Kristofferson. Garrett boozes and womanizes like a pro that's been doing so for years. He is as criminal as the ruffians he chases, yet they respect Garrett. It is explained that Garrett used to be in the same gang as Billy. The two men have a complex relationship in that they are friends and enemies. A mutual respect is present and Peckinpah loves this sort of male-bonding.
Both films contain world-weary men staring off into the distance pondering deep and meaningful ideas and perhaps, regrets. That said, PGBK is a more thoughtful film with a deeper soul. Maybe the most introspective of all westerns. Perhaps the soul of PGBK is the impish, quiet Bob Dylan. Dylan also provides a moving soundtrack.
The Wild Bunch is a straightforward blood-and-guts western. It was pioneering for its use of blood packs to simulate gunshot wounds. Blood had never flowed like it did in these two movies and no western before had done it so graphically. Although, to a modern viewer, the blood looks fake. To be sure, significant improvements in blood effects technology have been made! Also, we see dramatic use of slow-motion film during gun fights. The slow-motion is almost overdone. Peckinpah broke the mold for film violence and set the brutal stage for his successors such as Scorsese, Tarantino and John Woo. Peckinpah's violence has been described as operatic, where bloody deaths appear like macabre wastes of humanity. This description is no more evident than in TWB.
Both films offer insight into a tumultuous mind in Sam Peckinpah and pay tribute to a dying West, a West that John Ford had practically built with his canon of films in the preceding decades. Peckinpah's Westerns were the logical successors to Ford's in the violent Vietnam era. Peckinpah is perhaps the last maverick of modern American film and certainly the last great western filmmaker of the twentieth century.
Published by Jonathan Hiott
I have worked in the IT industry for the past 7 years. I am also a freelance writer. I also play the bass guitar in a jazz band. View profile
- Classic Film Review: Sam Peckinpah's The GetawayFilm review of The Getaway.
- How to Win at CharadesThis WILL help you to win at charades. Trust me. Unless you are playing against big fans of Sam Peckinpah.
- Major DundeeA review of the Sam Peckinpah film "Major Dundee" starring Charlton Heston.
- 300 is a Magnificent Ballet of Violence and BloodshedThere is a new King among Comic Book Movies.
- Looking at WeatherPeople in this part of the country love to whine and complain about the winter weather. I am here to say I am not one of them and I don't understand why everyone else is.
- Sam Peckinpah - Hollywood's Last Rebel Director
- Lucien Ballard: Legendary Cinematographer
- The Pat Garrett and John S. Chisum Conspiracy
- The Real Billy the Kid: Was it Brushy Bill Roberts?
- The Billy the Kid DNA Investigation
- Sam Peckinpah's Last Classic: Bring Me the Head of Alfredo Garcia
- A Review of Ultraviolent Movies: From Sam Peckinpah to Quentin Tarantino
