Self Publish or Search for an Agent?

That is the Question!

Susan Cross
Everybody wants to see their manuscript in book form. But how do you take the magical step from printing it out and getting it bound? Self-publishing has become a popular alternative to the standard route of finding an agent and having them try to sell your work to a publishing house. Consider self-publishing the equivalent of using an independent film or recording studio; your work gets produced into a marketable product, which can be very self gratifying; but like independent films and recordings, self-publishing is only the beginning of the process of becoming successful.

There are advantages and disadvantages to self-publishing a completed manuscript. Knowing your ultimate goal will help facilitate the decision whether or not to self-publish. Consider the following issues before deciding:

1. Is your goal to become a recognized author or just to publish a book? If you have written a memoir or family history that would be valuable to a small market, self-publishing is a great way to get your story into a professional looking product that will be a keepsake and possibly an heirloom to be passed down through generations. This applies to a person who has been involved in some historic event and would like to leave behind written documentation of his personal experiences.

2. Before considering self-publishing, have an editor read your manuscript to correct any grammatical and spelling errors. An editor can also ensure that the content is not ambiguous and clearly conveys your meaning. When working with an agent and a traditional publishing house, all manuscripts are read by editors; but even if your plan is to submit a manuscript to an agent, having an editor review your work first will ensure that the manuscript is well polished.

3. Choosing self-publishing can get your book in print and ready for distribution in a relatively short period of time. Going the traditional route requires a boatload of patience. Did you know that even if an agent selects your manuscript and choose to represent you, it can take two years before the book will actually be in print?

4. Many traditional publishing houses are on the lookout for self-published books that attract attention and interest in the marketplace. Then they may approach the author for the rights to the book so that they can share the wealth. Publishing is a business; the large companies are looking at the bottom line. If your self published book is selling well, a publisher may want to "discover" the author.

5. It is important to ask yourself this question: Am I willing to market my book once it has been self-published? There are a number of ways to market books; many self-publishing companies offer marketing packages - for an additional fee. If you are ambitious and passionate about your work, there are many resources available to help bring your book to the attention of your target market. Marketing budgets for new writers are small in traditional publishing houses. Self-publishing requires a motivated writer, or one who can afford to hire a publicist to market the product.

6. Self-publishing can seem inexpensive at first glance To be successful, it is essential that you can afford not only the base price for the contract, but also have the resources to purchase enough copies to do some promotion. Sending your book to newspapers, radio talk shows, television shows that feature local authors, book reviewers, and members of your target market is just a start at getting name recognition and reviews that will help to get your book noticed.

7. Know the market. Currently, the major publishing companies are looking for books on specific topics that are considered "hot." Unfortunately, these topics don't necessarily reflect what the general population in your area considers to be of particular interest. If you have written a manuscript on a hot topic, it may be worthwhile to try to find an agent. This information is available in the "2007 Writer's Market" by looking at each agent's specialties. If your work is not going to be widely marketable, self-publishing may be the way to go, but keep in mind you may not make money.

8. If you choose to take the route of self-publishing, spend the time necessary to compare different companies. Prices can vary widely along with the type of services offered. Be prepared to do some work after the finished product is in your hand. Writing the book is only the first step!

Writing a book is a labor of love; something you do because you can't help yourself. If your goal is to get rich, I'd suggest you have a backup plan. There's a reason they call us "starving artists" and it has nothing to do with anorexia.

Published by Susan Cross

I am a professional writer for 4 magazines. Many of my feature articles are about major professional musicians, usually interviews. I am the Music Columnist for Orlando Home & Leisure Magazine, as well as a...  View profile

Self-publishing is becoming more and more popular for unknown authors. Some self-publishing companies are very selective about the manuscripts they select; others will publish anything, regardless of quality, as long as they get paid.

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Derek Odom5/29/2008

    Loved the article - I learned some stuff too! Very well thought out and written in a way even an idiot like me can understand! Thanks, good job! :)

  • Jacob Malewitz11/13/2007

    Well thought out article. I am probably going to self publish myself, and feel your advice is sound. Marketing is big, and could fill an entire article. Thanks for all the advice.

  • Shamontiel7/7/2007

    Candace, I don't feel like I sold my soul to the devil. Not once. I smell a literary snob in the air. But anyway, one thing I learned from working with a literary agent before is that she annoyed the hell out of me. I did a ghostwriting project and I was dead tired of her nagging me about deadlines and exactly what to write. I realized very quickly from working with a publishing company that I sincerely need to work on my own. Control freaks and publishing companies tend to butt heads. That was my main reason for self-publishing. I don't like people telling me what to do and would rather work on my own schedule and my own topics. I like this article.

  • Dreamweaverr4/9/2007

    Well written and informative. This is one avenue I am considering too.

  • Susan Cross4/4/2007

    I work for an author who self-published. After his book got some attention, a major publisher picked him up and now his book has been translated into 17 languages and is an international best seller. That's what prompted this article.

  • Candace Morehouse4/4/2007

    Sorry, but self publishing to me seems like selling your soul to the Devil. I finally found an e-publisher that will put my book in print if I sell enough copies online and even that isn't my preference, but I'll take it! Keep trying!

  • Donna Porter3/29/2007

    Excellent information - I am considering self-publishing, but undecided.

  • Question Everything3/10/2007

    Great article - very useful information.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.