Seven Problems with Arguments Made by Occupy Wall Street:
The group Occupy Wall Street has been on many people's minds lately; particularly if you're living in the New York-metro area. You may work downtown, you may be inconvenienced by traffic tie ups or other demonstrations, you may not be able to get where you're headed south of Houston Street; whatever. The big problem as I see it with Occupy Wall Street are several things. With all the conflated ideas floating around downtown the message is getting muddled. OccupyWallStreet .org has put out a list of "demands" that they see as necessary for their Utopian reality to take effect. But there are problems with many of these demands.
Guaranteed living Wage: Why would Occupy Wall Street want to create a "guaranteed living wage" of $20 an hour? Where do they think this money is going to come from? And what do they think is going to happen to costs when this wage is increased? If all employers have to pay dishwashers and counter clerks $20 an hour, get ready for the $50 Big Mac and the $35 tube of toothpaste. Because that's what things will cost!
Universal Health care: The United States is too big and people like to go to the doctor for no reason too much to make universal health care the law of the land. And again, who would pay for this?
Open Borders: I don't know what would happen if we let lax on our open borders; people seem to come and go anyway. But if people knew they could just come and get free health care and $20 an hour guaranteed; they would come in droves. If you think finding an average job is tough now...
Free College Education: This free college education would be great; but then why would anyone ever leave college? If they were let take class ad nausea we'd be left with a bunch of over educated, under-employed populous. Who knows? They may even begin a big protest because they're so much smarter than the society which has educated them.
Debt Forgiveness: "Immediate across the board debt forgiveness for all." Do I even need to analyze why that's a problem? If there are no consequences for incurring debt and no motivation to work to pay off debt then we'd all just do nothing.
Allow all workers to sign a ballot: Like the debt forgiveness, if everyone can just declare union status then the gravitas behind the union endorsement is lost. Besides, who's working anyway if they can just stay in school and get free health care?
Lack of Organization: There are some things that the Occupy Wall Street group propose which are worthwhile ideas; infrastructure, fossil fuels, ecological restoration, and bringing American election processes up to international standards are all great ideas. But their message is lost because of all the other zealous demands this group is making.
Occupy Wall Street has a lot of smart people doing a great American protest. But at the end of the day Occupy Wall Street has to turn this anger around and work with the system we have and work to change it in substantive ways.
Guaranteed living Wage: Why would Occupy Wall Street want to create a "guaranteed living wage" of $20 an hour? Where do they think this money is going to come from? And what do they think is going to happen to costs when this wage is increased? If all employers have to pay dishwashers and counter clerks $20 an hour, get ready for the $50 Big Mac and the $35 tube of toothpaste. Because that's what things will cost!
Universal Health care: The United States is too big and people like to go to the doctor for no reason too much to make universal health care the law of the land. And again, who would pay for this?
Open Borders: I don't know what would happen if we let lax on our open borders; people seem to come and go anyway. But if people knew they could just come and get free health care and $20 an hour guaranteed; they would come in droves. If you think finding an average job is tough now...
Free College Education: This free college education would be great; but then why would anyone ever leave college? If they were let take class ad nausea we'd be left with a bunch of over educated, under-employed populous. Who knows? They may even begin a big protest because they're so much smarter than the society which has educated them.
Debt Forgiveness: "Immediate across the board debt forgiveness for all." Do I even need to analyze why that's a problem? If there are no consequences for incurring debt and no motivation to work to pay off debt then we'd all just do nothing.
Allow all workers to sign a ballot: Like the debt forgiveness, if everyone can just declare union status then the gravitas behind the union endorsement is lost. Besides, who's working anyway if they can just stay in school and get free health care?
Lack of Organization: There are some things that the Occupy Wall Street group propose which are worthwhile ideas; infrastructure, fossil fuels, ecological restoration, and bringing American election processes up to international standards are all great ideas. But their message is lost because of all the other zealous demands this group is making.
Occupy Wall Street has a lot of smart people doing a great American protest. But at the end of the day Occupy Wall Street has to turn this anger around and work with the system we have and work to change it in substantive ways.
DISCLOSURE OF MATERIAL CONNECTION:
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.
The Contributor has no connection to nor was paid by the brand or product described in this content.
Published by Jesse Schmitt
Back in New York. Still searching. View profile
'Why is Life a Bitch? Cause We Don't Tax the Rich!' Shout Heard 'Round t...Tired of your taxpayer money going to fat cats on Wall Street? Tired of the country being dominated and gamed by the super-rich? Tired of losing benefits and paying more in taxe...- Insider Interview: Occupy Wall Street Will Never WorkA Senior Financial Consultant on Wall Street explains the reasons that protesters do not have a chance.
Occupy Wall Street Movement Gains Steam in the Wake of Weekend ArrestsOccupy Wall Street is gaining traction in the quest for accountability from Wall Street executives.- The Real Housewives of New York City - Sagittarians on AdderallThe Real Housewives of New York City had it all tonight. Something sweet, something bitter, something smelly, and then there was Kelly.
- Some Suggested Demands for the Occupy Wall Street Protest Based on the American Sc...The Occupy Wall Street protest has been criticized for not having specific demands. Here are some suggestions based on the American School of economics.
- Occupy Wall Street 10/5/11 March on City Hall
- How Do You Feel About the Occupy Wall Street Movement?
- What Do the Occupy Wall Street Protesters Want?
- Even for Occupy Wall Street Money Makes the World Go Round
- Hermain Cain Deluded About Job Loss, Occupy Wall Street
- 7 Things Occupy Wall Street Has Shown Me
- Occupy Wall Street Has No Idea What It's Protesting For
1 Comments
Post a CommentAgain, taking an ad-hoc post and calling it an official is is misleading. But looking at the demands listed, many are worthy. We are not to "big" for universal health care, just too misinformed. Allowing signing for union representation only means it's easier to set up an election. And if there were more unions, we would see movement toward a living wage. "Free college" worked just fine in California until Reagan, and even better examples exist in other places, like Northern Europe. Students can take internships, apprenticeships, or go to college. They have a very educated populace - and funny, the garbage still gets collected, roads get built, food gets served.