Should California Make Spanking Illegal?

Rico P
Can you believe that this country is trying to make spanking illegal? California is trying to pass a law that spanking your child is a criminal act. Are they serious? I guess so because on every news channel this is a hot topic. Whose business is it to interfere with how parents discipline their children? How does a good parent defend themselves against a charge of that nature? Well let's talk about this for a minute. There are many areas that should be considered before such a law should even be bought before legislation.

My mother is a wonderful woman. As a kid I was what you would consider a serious pain in the butt. I was always getting into trouble. Getting into trouble and touching things I wasn't supposed to, got me spanked. I would get spanked where ever I decided to act like a fool at. If the school called and said I was acting up, she my "mother" would come to the school and spank me in front of the whole class. The teachers would thank her and then inform me that I better not make them call her again. Well it happened every now and then but the fact that she disciplined me like that in front of my friends and peers, it made me so mad and eventually I stopped showing my butt in school and in my neighborhood and the spankings stopped.

My dad on the other hand didn't spank me. He had the ability to be able to connect with my chest with a nicely placed blow. I wasn't allowed to cry and I had to stand there with my hand to my side. He never spanked my sister at all. He would just tell her he will spank her and she listens. My mother mainly deals with her. But me, and my brothers had to learn the manly way. And the best and most effective way that I learned was the only thing that made me listen. Not out of fear, but out of embarrassment, was the jab to the chest. Spanking didn't work for me as much as the punch in the chest from my dad did. It's not a hard punch but it's the fact that I got punched in public and had to stand there with my hands at my side and suck it up.

I grew up in a close neighborhood. If you did something you weren't supposed to do, you got spanked and sent home by whichever parent was around at the time. Things sure do change. Now days most parents don't discipline their kids because of fear of child abuse. Having 3 kids of my own, I am known to spank my kids where ever they decide to act up at just like I was disciplined. And you know what? It works. Now like my mother all I have to do is give them the look. All parents know what the look is and it's a great tool to use but it only works if you disciplined your kids early, like the terrible 2 and up stage.

We see young kids on the news or in real life that needed, and still needs to be spanked. The government wants to interfere with parents spanking kids but what about their own local and state personnel that we see either in person or on the news or maybe even just something you read or hear about abusing young kids. Kids being abused by juvenile officers, probation officers, police, foster parents and detention staff are everyday occurrences in America. Abuse of children is a serious issue, but it has nothing to do with parental discipline. Where are the laws that prohibit police brutality? Or some strong punishment laws to protect our kids from sexual predators? Have you ever seen how the police ruff the kids up? I just wonder and imagine in my mind what I would do if I saw this happening to my kids.

It's scary to think what life will be like and what laws we will live by 20 years from now. What will my kids and their kids have to deal with? Things have definitely changed. Kids don't even play any more like it was when I was young. As a kid there was about 15-25 of us playing football, kickball, games like "it" tag, hide and go seek, cops n robbers, knock and run. These games were so fun and now I don't see kids playing anything like that. Now kids can't play knock n run because they might get shot. Back in the early 80's all we had to worry about were getting caught and the people telling our parents?

As a kid I was not as scared of the police or anybody else as much as I was scared of my parents. Now the parents have something to worry about if they want to discipline their kids in California.

What do you think? Should this law be passed? This is something to think about because if it's passed in California then it might be your state next.

Thanks for reading.

Published by Rico P

I'm a proud father.  View profile

17 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Wise Lady1/27/2008

    Great story. You know I live here in Cali, and I can't believe some of our rights as parents that have been turned around and or taken from us. I for one never really spanked or hit my kids, but a long time ago, I have to admit I believe now looking back I verbally abused my daughter at times. I have since she was a child apologized to her for it, but I don't think I can modify her feelings of what inpact it made on her. That being said, I believe there are limits. Spanking is one thing, but as Alicia says: a little spanking is okay, but beating is another. It is unfortunate that some parents have taken it to another level. Good writing.

  • Rebecca Livermore1/16/2008

    You make some excellent points here. I agree the government needs to stay out of it.

  • Marissa Reale1/16/2008

    Good article, the government needs to get out of everyone's business!

  • Erin Morris1/15/2008

    great article and great topic for debate. I come from a family of seven, like you, my parents chose to discipline us with spankings and personally i think it worked well for them. The didn't overuse this method, they used it to get their point across, and we learned quick. My four brothers and sisters and I are all very well rounded individuals, none of us have abusive tendancies and all 5 of us have a fantastic relationship with our parents. We also learned a lot about 'crime and punishment', we knew what would happen if we got in trouble and it helped us to stay out of trouble. I think the gov't has no business interferring with parental discipline, honestly, they have much more important issues they should be dealing with. Its the parents choice, if it becomes abuse, then the gov't can get involved.

  • Alicia Bodine1/14/2008

    I don't think kids should get a beating, but a little spanking here and there does the trick.

  • Lucida Stevens1/13/2008

    it's tragic that this even has to be an issue, and yet so many parents are abusive these days. it's getting more difficult to see where that line blurs.

  • Sherry W1/13/2008

    I think that the government would be overstepping its boundaries if it were to outlaw spanking. Good parents who legitimately spank (as opposed to beat) their children as punishment would be caught and punished, while those who actually DO beat their children would get away with it. Beatings won't stop just because the government says no spanking allowed.

  • Victor T. Chambers1/4/2008

    I don't think spanking is necessary. However I also don't think it is abuse unless it is hard enough to leave a mark. Psychological and emotional abuse can be far more lasting in my opinion. I'm not an expert though.

  • Scribepal12/19/2007

    A great article for debate and something to really consider! Thanks.

  • Sparkle77212/17/2007

    It is the parents choice, not the government. When this turns into abuse, then there is a problem. Good article. Well written.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.