Should Michigan Lottery winners remain anonymous?

Most lotto winners in metro Detroit opt to keep their names secret

Michael Thompson
Nearly 90 percent of big-money Michigan Lottery winners in metro Detroit and across the state opt to remain anonymous, says spokeswoman Andi Brancato.

The anonymous option applies to the in-state games of Classic Lotto 47, Fantasy 5, Keno, Club Keno and the new Lucky Lines, she notes.

Names and hometowns of Mega Millions and Powerball winners are automatically released.

"Because Mega Millions and Powerball are both multistate games, it is important for us and for the other states to see what is going on with those," Brancato explains.

Michigan Lottery officials will shield the identities of winners of in-state games, she says, but they are grateful to the rare few who are willing to step into the limelight.

"We do hear people say, 'I never hear of people who are winners. Where are the winners?'" Brancato notes.

"We certainly prefer it if a player wants to give out their name. We want people to know that there indeed are, in fact, winners, that there are names behind winners, and there are hometowns behind winners."

The Michigan Lottery last year took in $2.45 billion in revenues and paid $1.41 billion in prizes.

Publicity in recent months has focused on the murder of Florida lottery winner Abraham Shakespeare, who authorities say was a victim of a woman who gained access to a chunk of his $31-million prize.

However, most Michigan Lottery winners through the years say their main reason for remaining anonymous is to guard against money requests from relatives and friends, or in some cases from fundraising groups.

"I have customers, even if they only win $500, they will say, 'Don't tell my wife,'" says Mike Sawa, owner of Oak Park Liquor and Wine in suburban Detroit, with a chuckle.

"Each person has his own preference. Most winners want to keep a secret because they feel like if everybody else knows, then everyone else will want to be their cousin."

At Inkster's Cherry Belt Party Store, owner Heidi Habba says the biggest prize ever won by a customer was $300,000 in the Cash Five game. The winning couple urged her to keep a secret.

"I don't blame them," Habba says. "A lot of people say that if they ever were to win and if people found out, they would have to move out of the state."

Micky Yaldo, owner of Parkway Foods in Detroit, says he gets mixed reactions from prize winners.

"The older people, the senior citizens, are scared for people to know that they won, because they are afraid that someone will rob them," Yaldo says. "At the same time, there are other customers who want everybody to know they won, because they are proud of it."

John Yelda, owner of Five Star Liquor in Dearborn, goes against the grain. He says the state legislature should pass a law requiring all prize winners to be identified. If somebody doesn't want his or her name to be released, says Yelda, then that person shouldn't play the lottery.

"The state should let all of us know who won the money, so that people can see that the lottery is honest," Yelda says. "Not just their names; the state should also show their pictures."

Mike "Tiger" Price is a longtime Detroit-area media personality who says he sees things both ways.

"We need to understand that today, identities are being stolen, and people are being targeted and robbed. In this day and age, privacy is an important factor in just staying alive," Price says.

"Still, I believe that as much as I participate in Publishers Clearing House contests and lotteries, that if I won, that I should come forward publicly to accept a prize."

Published by Michael Thompson

Michael Thompson is a retired newspaper reporter who lives in Saginaw, Michigan. Main topics are political and social justice issues, with occasional escapism into sports and so forth.  View profile

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Doug Donald12/23/2010

    Anonymous is the way to go. A friend of mine from high school won $4,000,000 in the Michigan lottery over twenty-five years ago. He was barraged with pleas for money from strangers and "long lost" relatives. He was only 23 years old at the time. He took his father's advice and disappeared...took a 6-month vacation to Europe. By the time he returned...there had been new winners and he was forgotten and could go on about his business in relative peace.

  • Phillip8/30/2010

    I think it is perfectly reasonable for winners to remain anonymous. Why would you want to subject winners to all those money grabbers and such that would constantly barrage the winner with requests for money. I think it would deter people from playing if they thought their name would be published to the public.

  • Larry8/27/2010

    If a winning Lottery player does not want their name made public, it should not be made public. People have many logical reasons to keep their privacy.

  • J. Alec West6/10/2010

    Brief PS - I'd like to ask if Andi Brancato has contacted winners who DID release their names - to ask them, "Are you glad you did it?" Personally, I think the overwhelming majority of winners would say "NO!"

  • J. Alec West6/10/2010

    Jamie - you CAN remain anonymous regardless of the lottery game you play and regardless of the state in which you live. My article on Associated Content tells people how to do it. The methods are discussed on pages 3 and 4. The article is here:
    http://www.associatedcontent.com/article/5466988/you_lucky_devil_you.html

  • Dr. Jamie Y. Marable6/6/2010

    I always joke that if I ever won the lottery, I would have to change my name and leave the state or even the country. There are numerous reasons why a lottery winner might not want their identity revealed. However, if I had to choose between winning and not remaining anonymous and being broke, I think I'd go ahead and deal with the publicity...

  • Lyn Lomasi6/4/2010

    Excellent writeup! I can see both sides to it, but even though I am a pretty private person, I lean toward the publicity side. I can see wanting to be anonymous for protection, but if you win a substantial amount, you should be able to afford decent security. Plus, whether you've gained that money through the lottery or not, if you have a great deal of money, it's going to be obvious to criminals anyhow just by the way someone's living.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.