Should Teachers Be Restricted in Electronic Communication with Their Students?
Is it a Freedom of Speech Violation?
The state of Missouri is about to start policing teachers and their use of electronic contact with students. The law is aimed at reducing the possibility of teachers having sexual abuse with their students. It prohibits teachers from having students as friends on Facebook. It also sets strict rules on electronic messaging and texting. The law is called the Amy Hestir Student Protection Act.
The State is making school districts establish and enforcing the law. Districts are establishing limitations on what teachers can and can't do with electronic communication. Some districts have already done this.
Some teachers want to know how broad the law is? Can they respond to homework assignments by students. Can they answer other questions that might come up? Does this apply to telephone conversations, too? Can coaches text players about game time and travel changes?
Some teachers feel that this type of discrimination gives them a tag as possible sex predators. In their attempt to reduce sexual abuse by a few, the State is going after all teachers. Teachers feel that this makes their field look too suspect.
The law also applies to former students 19 and under. The law wants to stop all private contact between teachers and students. The law also goes on to say that any type of communication between the two should be viewable by parents and school administration. School districts are now required by law, to report any type of sexual abusive employee.
Some individuals go so far as to say that this is an infringement on their freedom of speech.
The idea behind the law is a good one. However, the shadow that it casts on teachers is another issue in a growing list across the nation. Many states are changing laws regarding teaching, unions, retirement, standards, testing and accountability.
Being a former teacher and still involved in education, I think most teachers would draw a line at what is and isn't acceptable when it comes to social media and electronic communication.
Text messaging has become a new form of communication. It might soon even pass up direct communication as a way of communicating with others. It appears that education might never catch up.
The State is making school districts establish and enforcing the law. Districts are establishing limitations on what teachers can and can't do with electronic communication. Some districts have already done this.
Some teachers want to know how broad the law is? Can they respond to homework assignments by students. Can they answer other questions that might come up? Does this apply to telephone conversations, too? Can coaches text players about game time and travel changes?
Some teachers feel that this type of discrimination gives them a tag as possible sex predators. In their attempt to reduce sexual abuse by a few, the State is going after all teachers. Teachers feel that this makes their field look too suspect.
The law also applies to former students 19 and under. The law wants to stop all private contact between teachers and students. The law also goes on to say that any type of communication between the two should be viewable by parents and school administration. School districts are now required by law, to report any type of sexual abusive employee.
Some individuals go so far as to say that this is an infringement on their freedom of speech.
The idea behind the law is a good one. However, the shadow that it casts on teachers is another issue in a growing list across the nation. Many states are changing laws regarding teaching, unions, retirement, standards, testing and accountability.
Being a former teacher and still involved in education, I think most teachers would draw a line at what is and isn't acceptable when it comes to social media and electronic communication.
Text messaging has become a new form of communication. It might soon even pass up direct communication as a way of communicating with others. It appears that education might never catch up.
Published by Bill Hanks
Just an average Joe living in the Midwest. I am a retired High School teacher/coach. I work part time for a small college. I am president of our local Kiwanis club. I am also a city alderman. But, most of... View profile
- Freedom of Speech - Your Basic Civil Rights Are Being ThreatenedWhat happened to freedom of speech and how can we preserve what our forefathers saw for our future.
What is Free About Freedom of Speech?Freedom of Speech
The Real Cost of Freedom of SpeechThe cost of freedom of speech and when we carry it to far. - Freedom of Speech or Moderated Content on Community Sites?A simple article, discussing about freedom of speech related to the internet and whether it should exist or not.
- Don Imus' Firing, the First Amendment and Freedom of SpeechThe loss of Mr. Imus' job has nothing to do with Freedom of Speech or the First Amendment. The firing is an example of what happens when the Boss finds it economically advantageous to sack an employee.
- Communication: Key to Human Interaction
- Modern Communication Devices Breed a Non-Confrontational Society
- Freedom of Speech? What's That?
- Freedom of Speech and Respect
- Freedom of Speech: What it Really Means to Tim Hardaway
- Freedom of Speech: Fully, Limited and Unprotected Speech
- Freedom of Speech, Do We Still Believe in It?




11 Comments
Post a CommentI don't think they should be able to have electronic communication with students. Students should not look at teachers as friends. There needs to be some higher respect involved.
I would err on the side of caution here since today it is not good, in my opinion, to communicate to students once the teacher is out of the classroom or off the school campus. Unless it is by phone to their parents.
excellent article - thanks for the great writing.
It's a shame that society has reached the point where this is potentially necessary. Good piece.
Nolan and Sheri are both right. Teachers should not be allowed to contact the students away from school and if they need to than it should be to the parents.
Why stop with teachers? Let's prohibit bus drivers from being facebook friends with minors, and little league coaches, Sunday School instructors, karate school owners, soccer moms, tutors, ski lift operators, mall business owners, door-to-door salespersons, realtors, rock stars, the pool guy, fast food vendors, anyone who owns a Snuggie!
Restricted? As to content, yes. IN the same way that curriculum guides what a teacher talks about in a class, so there need be guidelines regarding appropriate communications between teachers and students whatever the media... At least that's my opinion.
Yeah I think there needs to be some set guidelines for teachers, though most can use common sense with this issue. Teachers and students should not be FB friends or MySpace friends, etc.
Thanks Bill for this... :o)
Wow! I understand the intent but Ihave some friends that are teachers and this seems just wrong.