Should the Texas Hardship Drivers License Program Be Abolished?

Tfurby
In Texas under the Texas Administrative Code a minor between the ages of 15 and 18 may obtain a Texas hardship drivers license as long as the minor has completed a driver training course that has been approved by the Texas Department of Public Safety. Potential drivers as young as 14 may take an early enrollment in a drivers education class, so that when they reach the age of 15 the minor can be issued his/her hardship license.

The parents of the minor must also prove that the family is experiencing a hardship to the extent that it is causing the family to be denied the basic necessities of life. There are other criteria that the minor must meet before the hardship license will be issued, but that is neither here nor there to my concerns.

My concern is the fact that these young under age drivers, that have been issued a Texas Hardship Drivers license are not mature enough to handle the responsibility of getting behind the wheel of a motor vehicle and all that this entails. They are still children and therefore think as a child would think. If placed in the midst of a crisis while driving, will the 15 year old know how to react, in order to avert said crisis? I believe not.

I have been a witness to one accident in which involved a 15 year old driver who had her hardship license, she had her 12 year old sister riding in the car with her. The 15 year old driver remembered to fasten her seat belt, but did not think to make sure that her sister had fastened hers.

As she was turning on to the road that led to her home she failed to see the other car coming directly at her in the other lane, and as she turned, that car which was traveling at 70 miles per hour hit her car almost head on.

The driver that was wearing her seat belt received major injuries, but not nearly as severe as her sister who was ejected from the car, through the windshield as she was not wearing her seat belt.

Miraculously, both the driver and the passenger lived, as did the driver of the other car, but the 12 year old passenger suffered severe head trauma along with a broken back, arm, ribs and both legs. She had to learn to talk again, as there was some brain damage. She was also told that she would never walk again, but on this diagnosis, she proved them wrong. I can't help to think that if this driver had been older and more mature, this accident might have been avoided.

I just recently heard a few days ago that 15 year old boy, who had just received his Texas hardship license a few short days ago, had gone to the store to purchase a gallon of milk for his mom. On the way home from the store, a young man ran out into the street in front of his car. He tried to swerve but was not quick enough in his response to avoid hitting the young man. He was killed. If this boy had been older and more mature might this accident be avoided?

I feel that the Texas hardship license program should be reviewed and revised. A 15 year old has no business behind the wheel of any vehicle, no matter the circumstances. They are putting their life in danger as well as each and every person who comes into contact with them while they are behind that wheel.

I know that many families find themselves going through troubling times but, can't another solution be found to help these families? Rather than endangering the lives of their children and others?

Published by Tfurby

Tommie Sandlin enjoys family life, the outdoors, and writing. She has been writing articles via the internet for almost four years.  View profile

13 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Amanda12/10/2010

    I am 14 almost 15 and I am going to apply for my hardship. It depends on the situation you're in I believe. Farmers in Texas need it and I agree to some of these comments 15 year olds are mature these days! If they are old enought to be 16 and pregnent I think they can drive. People "forget" to buckle up all the time I bet you have forgotten atleast a time or two. In Arkansas you can legally get your hardship at the age of 14. Both of my parents are disabled veterans and they cannot drive for a legth of time. The restrictions are reasonable too! You can only drive in day time 12 hours per day. You are not allowed ANYONE other then your family in the car while you driving. I beleive it is a need in this generation. Some people get it for the wrong reasons, but people make mistakes. I'm sure you were a reackless teenager once, but its different in this generation! You dont understand what kids have to face in a daily bases!

  • Baj4/3/2010

    Oh please. Stop meddling in others lives (I get that it may effect you as do thousands of other things). Hardship license are for young adult who have adverse family conditions. Crippled family members they take care of, sick, dying people. So its okay to put that burden on them but heaven forbid you let them drive down the road to get medicine or a soda. You also seem to think that some marvelous thing happens between 15 and 16(the age most everyone gets a license). A 15 can be more or less mature than a 20 year old. I'm betting the ones the have the responsibility of a hard ship are more mature than you are Tommie. As for the one person you saw not buckling up their passenger, I see thousands of parents on a daily basis letting their kids hop around cars and throw things, all while on their cell phone. Stop trying to make mountains out of mole hills.

  • Heather W9/17/2009

    I disagree. If you were a family in hardship you might understand better. My daughter is 14 and we are applying for a hardship license. She has had driving lessons with me, taken a defensive driving course online, given specific rules and instructions. We have prepped her by allowing her to drive a golf cart in our community (which is allowed). It is how you raise your children and the maturity level of the child. I know plenty of adults that shouldn't have a license and I can tell you I would trust my daughter to drive my vehicle before I would alot of other people.

  • Lisa Curcio1/24/2009

    =)

  • Hylain Wright11/17/2008

    15 yrs old driving...yeah I'm thinking that's a big no no. I still can't get used to the whole 17yrs and driving thing...I guess I'm still too European (UK, FA, BE, NL: 18 yrs till you can get a driving licence)

  • Shanika11/13/2008

    Interesting. In Oklahoma, they also have this. A couple of things - these 15 yr olds are usually only free to drive in rural areas and there are plenty of restrictions. Also there's just no way of telling that these kids wouldn't be equally poor drivers or exhibit bad judgment even at 18. Third, when I was 12 years old I used to sneak my mom's car out and drive all over town. Bob makes an excellent point as well. Typically kids who are required to work at a younger age are more mature. Still.... a complicated issue. Great piece.

  • 3lilangels11/13/2008

    good points hmmmmmm!

  • Sherry W11/12/2008

    I'd not heard of a hardship license before so I don't have an established opinion. However, I can say that I've seen horrible drivers of ALL ages, so I don't know that being 15 in and of itself is enough of a reason to say someone shouldn't be on the road. The worst offenders I've ever seen have been middle aged folks on cell phones.

  • S. A.11/12/2008

    Hmm...it's hard. Some young people are more responsible than others. You can't get a permit back at home until your 16, which I think is a pretty reasonable age.

  • R. Elizabeth C. Kitchen11/12/2008

    I was 17 when I got mine and my parents were freaking out then. I think 15 is just too young.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.