"Comic book" movies seem to be the new trend in Hollywood. And we all know that a lot of them are awful (The Hulk, League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Daredevil). And going to see Sin City that was my biggest concern.
However, Frank Miller and Robert Rodriguez kept control of Sin City and were able to bring it to life in all of its uncompromising brutal glory.
Sin City is based on three stories- "The Hard Goodbye," "That Yellow Bastard," and "The Big Fat Kill." "The Hard Goodbye" is almost verbatim with the other two being slightly abridged and amended.
Generally speaking, the actors pulled their weight- for the most part. Clive Owen lived up to many a high expectation as Dwight. Mickey Rourke is unrecognizable as the relentless juggernaut Marv. Bruce Willis is, as always, an older guy who cannot relate to women- a role he has played since Die Hard, but it is spot on for his Hartigan in Sin City. Without speaking a single word, Elijah Wood delivers one of his most powerful performances. Nick Stahl brings to life the ominous Yellow Bastard. I would say that the most disappointing thing about the film is Jessica Alba's performance. She simply wasn't the dancer that Nancy is in the comics.
This film is amazingly true to its source. For those who were familiar with Frank Miller's Sin City, they knew every twist before it happened, knew lines of dialogue as they were spoken, and recognized each shot as the black and white pages of the comics.
However, it is important to know what it is you are getting yourself into before you see the film. If you are simply expecting some fluff comic book movie, be warned now. The first gunshot is fired before the opening credits. There are scenes of mutilation. Be prepared for the use of rubber tubing.
Sin City is very funny, very sexy, very violent.
Published by Erin McMaster
I am a freelance filmmaker who likes to share my opinions on pop culture when given the time. View profile
Comic Book Movies-The Second PartThere are many comic book movies that have come out this year. These are a few.
Guide to 2007 Comic Book MoviesAt least six comic book movies are slated for release in 2007, making the year appear to be a good one for comic book fans.- Iron Man Has the Mettle to Be a Great Comic Book Movie FranchiseRobert Downey, Jr. is excellent, in fact, all of the performances of "Iron Man" are excellent. Joh Favreau proves himself and excellent director and a new comic book movie franchise is born.
- Green Lantern: The Next Comic Book Superhero MovieThere are many comic book superhero movies coming to the big screen in the coming months and years. The new superhero coming to you is Green Lantern. If you don't know much about him, don't worry; this article will he...
- Comic Book Movie Adaptations That Have Gotten the Greenlight Many upcoming comic book adaptations are still a long way off. These are some of the comic book adaptations that are in the works but won't be out for a while.
- Sin City is Cinematically Gritty
- Sin City Comes to DVD
- Sin City 2: Another Unnecessary Sequel
- Movie Review: Sin City Blu-ray Edition
- The Inspiration to Frank Miller's Newest Film: 300
- Successful Comic Book Movie Sequels and Their Less Accomplished Followups
- Top 10 Comic Book Movies that Should Have Been Stopped Before Created!

