Soldier Suicide: Social Stigma

J. Ellen Fedder
On Memorial Day, cemeteries honor brave men and women who served their country faithfully. Crowds gather for local services in honor of veterans who served in various wars and in times of peace, many of whom gave lives for country. But for a few who gather on that day, there will be a deep sense of grief, one that goes beyond the loss of a loved one. Let me explain.

When a soldier takes his or her own life (often in the home) the solder's whole service record becomes overshadowed by one final act. Moreover, his or her family is left with unanswered questions--enduring shock, grief, and embarrassment over the soldier's choice of death. Soldier suicide is a sad condition of war and made even sadder by the social stigma attached to suicidal death.

I know a mother who lost her son a year or two ago. He was serving in the National Guard and was called up for his third overseas tour. He had only been home from Iraq for a year, and it was a difficult year for him. The soldier suffered from Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and a brain injury resulting from close proximity to a roadside bomb. Though he survived the initial trauma, he continued to suffer a personal and daily battle in his mind. The brain injury left him permanently wounded. That return call to Iraq was more than he could endure. There seemed only one way out of his pain and he took it.

On Memorial Day, the mother attended a memorial service at her local cemetery to honor veterans. Her son served honorably and was a very decorated soldier. But the societal stigma of suicide meant she felt she couldn't share her son's military achievements with others in attendance. Her pride in his accomplishments was something that took a backseat to the way in which he died. Her loss was more than the loss of her son; it was the loss of ability to speak of her loss. Sadly, the honor due her soldier son was clouded by his type of death.

How many soldiers return from war broken in mind? It's not a wound that shows; nonetheless, it's a wound. And that brings up another question. Why would a soldier with a diagnosed neurological disorder be called upon to return to war? Something is not right with that. If a soldier is receiving treatment and is considered a suicide threat, there must be more effective safeguards in place to prevent soldier suicide. Moreover, sending the soldier back for a repeat performance seems ludicrous, as well as risky for comrades.

This Memorial Day, when we see flags at the graves of soldiers who served country faithfully, we would do well to remember and honor service records, first and foremost. The service record of a brave soldier is that which should leave its mark in memory and history--not merely the manner in which a soldier died.

Furthermore, we would do well to press beyond social stigmas and those uncomfortable feelings of not knowing what to say to an individual who lost a soldier to suicide. We should approach such a person and tell the person how proud we are of their soldier's service to country. Then we should thank him or her for their great sacrifice. Finally, before we leave the cemetery, we should also pay respect at the gave of that soldier, expressing our thanks for his or her honorable service.

Published by J. Ellen Fedder

J. Ellen Fedder is an AC writer known for her conversational writing style. Freelance writer and one of AC's "Top 1000" for 2008, 2009, 2010, and 2011, she offers a fresh perspective on family living and ed...  View profile

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Bill4/2/2010

    Psychs invented the stigma associated with psych terminology, and psychodiagnoses in order to justify, and get fees for a field that is unaccountable and unreliable. Psych "diagnoses" cannot be quantified; therefore, they are not scientific or even medical. Please consider the abuses of patients by staff in American mental health facilities. The 1999 GAO inestigative report on patient abuse found that their results were only "the tip of an iceberg". Staff tried to cover up by such methods as "falsifying death records." In 1999 the U.S. Congress investigated these issues due to Senator liberman's request; however, the public has not been informed of the results. Secondly the American media, and its publishers have failed completely to inform the public regarding the documented killings of patients by staff (even little children) on America's psychowards. Its high time for reform. Thirdly American physicians who also have a high suicide rate like veterans and even physicians tend t

  • J. Ellen Fedder12/16/2009

    Good guestion.

  • Sgt Bob12/16/2009

    In the Uniited States our physicians also have a high rate of suicide. Yet the facts show that physicians prefer suicide to receiving any "mental health" treatment whatsoever. Research shows that even physicians believe that psych services are career limiting, stigmatizing, and cause additional social, and family problems. Now if even physicians refuse psych treatment, shouldn't we carefully examine whether "mental health" treatment, is indeed really healthy???

  • Jeanne Gibson4/16/2009

    Good article. It addresess a subject that most of us give little thought to. My thoughts are with your friend who should never stop being proud of her son. Suicide is usually entered into when a person feels completely overwhelmed by by the circumstances of his or her life. I do not think less of that person, but rather feel great sorrow that they were placed in a position where they could not see another way out.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.