The majority of the votes (68 to 31) in favor of confirming 55-year-old Sotomayor were from Democrats who took little issue with her liberal stance on important issues of the day. Many of the votes in opposition to the justice were from Republicans who felt that Sotomayor's ideals were much too liberal and far too biased. Opposing Republicans were quick to her former speeches, which they claim indicate that Sotomayor is likely to interject her own personal flavor and bias in the Court that is intended to be neutral.
Justice Mayor came under fire because of her liberal stance on a wide range of issues and because of perceived personal biases. Former speeches from the Justice that were widely publicized during the Senate hearings were thought to suggest that she will utilize her personal experience as a Hispanic woman to rule in cases brought before the Court. She is noted as saying at various events that she is a "wise Latina" because of her experiences as a Hispanic woman. Republicans and the conservative media latched onto such quotes by Sotomayor, fueling claims of personal biases and. During that media firestorm, it was easy to ask oneself how wise it was for the judge to use such rhetoric in light of her position as judge, which is largely considered a position that leaves personal biases at home. Clearly, the concerns of the Republicans regarding the justice's professional integrity kicked up a great deal of media scrutiny, but stopped short of preventing her from adding US Supreme Court Justice as her new title.
In spite of all concerns regarding Sonia Sotomayor's qualifications to serve as the 111th Supreme Court Justice, she prevailed and received the honor of serving in this important role.
Sources:
ABC News. Sotomayor: Wise Latina Joke "Fell Flat". July 14, 2009. http://abcnews.go.com/video/playerIndex?id=8083295
Juie Hirschfield Davis. Associated Press. Sotomayor OK'd for Supreme Court in historic vote. August 6, 2009. http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_sotomayor_senate.
Published by H. Kris Thomas
So Cal resident writing poetry and other things...but mostly poetry. View profile
- Judge Sonia Sotomayor's First Day of Senate Confirmation HearingsA review of the first day of Senate Confirmation hearings for Judge Sonia Sotomayor to the Supreme Court
- Sonia Sotomayor Pegged as New Supreme Court Justice FavoriteThe speculation has already gone into overdrive over who will replace David Souter on the Supreme Court. Sonia Sotomayor, a 16-year veteran of the bench, and a minority female, is pulling ahead as the pundits pick on...
- Ms. Sonia Sotomayor Becomes the First Hispanic Justice and the Third Woman on the...Justice Sonia Sotomayor has been sworn in!
- Supreme Court History and TraditionsThe United States Supreme Court is an institution with many traditions, and there are some aspects of the Justice selection process and the operation of the Court that will likely hold true this go-round, and for year...
- Judge Sonia Sotomayor Obama Supreme Court Nominee, as ExpectedThe retirement of Justice David Souter from the Supreme Court made Judge Sonia Sotomayor the favorite to take his place. Today, President Obama made it official, as the first prospective Hispanic Justice now prepares...
- Wise Latina Sotomayor Sworn in as First Hispanic Supreme Court Justice
- First Day of Sonia Sotomayor Confirmation Hearings
- Judge Sonia Sotomayor Nominated for Supreme Court
- Sonia Sotomayor Confirmed by Senate Judiciary Committee
- U.S. Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas
- The Politics of Gender in Appointing the Next Supreme Court Justice
- Public Opinion and the Supreme Court


2 Comments
Post a CommentNice story! It's funny how each side make claims; when the other is about to get ahead. Every human is bias; it's in our nature to want to go with our personal thoughts and feelings and hard to separate from what we know to what needs to be done.
White judges are never bias right; ask anyone who has ever been missed treated because of their race and then ask what happened to being bias.
I hope we continue to grow as a country and make the right choice; not because that person is white, African American, male, female, etc. That we consider what is best for our country as a whole and the world around us! Love your writing and keep up the quality work; that is so rare now a days!
I wish her the best of luck in her new position. It's not a job that I would want! Great coverage on this.