SportsCenter: Da-Da-Da, Da-da-huh?

When Did ESPN's Flagship Show Became a Nightly Frat-party?

Dan Borrello
Where have you gone Lee Leonard, Bill Patrick and Tim Brando? Stuart Scott and his station should turn his lonely eye to you.

America's gathering place for sports seems to fit better on MTV than ESPN.

The cornerstone show from the network that revolutionized the way we follow sports has turned into an hour-long (if we're lucky), mistake-infested, frat-fest anchored by two clowns tripping over each other trying to become the next Craig Kilborn.

Yeah. Remember him?

Even Dan Patrick has removed himself from further lampooning on the network that was once led by respectable names such as Bob Ley and Greg Gumbel. SportsCenter eventually morphed ("evolved" would be complimentary) into the "jockocracy" Howard Cosell warned us Monday Night Football could someday become.

It's ironic how ABC/ESPN even ruined that, too.

Just watch an hour and listen to Stuart Scott and Scott Van Pelt trade hip-hop rhymes for recycled one-liners from movies they assume everyone has seen (assuming everyone is under 30).

Scott once referred to Jay-Z as "Jigga" while introducing the world premiere of the rapper's music video during a MNF halftime show and feels the need to "pound" the athletes he interviews and call them his "dogg." (Meanwhile, Don Imus remains unemployed for uttering "Nappy Headed Hos".) Van Pelt super-saturates his scripts with lines from Borat, Flight of the Conchords, and South Park like a giddy frosh trying to impress a sorority gal while struggling to keep his bifocals out of his beer.

Sports are a great thing. But they aren't all things to all people. Somehow, ESPN has taken the opposite approach thus, feeling the need to infotain everybody, shooing away viewers to ESPNEWS if they only want news and highlights.

Wasn't that SportsCenter's original purpose?

Keith Olberman may have been a pompous jackass to work with, but when the cameras were on, the guy's lines were crisp, sly and clever. Dan Patrick didn't need to create nicknames for each athlete so people would like him. The days of Mike Tirico and John Saunders are only relived on Outside the Lines with Bob Ley, or the 6 pm SportsCenter through Jay Harris and Brian Kinney.

We rarely see Trey Wingo, Linda Cohn, or Karl Ravech on SportsCenter anymore because they have too much credibility. Imagine that.

Even Mike Greenberg has been transformed from a serious anchor and radio show personality to a metrosexual caricature for Mike Golic to feed off in-between Nutri-System snacks. ESPN does recognize radio is strictly entertainment and has enough (dare say) savvy to keep Greenberg off SportsCenter while focusing his efforts toward the Mike and Mike simulcast on ESPN2, thus avoiding burnout.

They should take the same approach with Scott, Van Pelt, Neil Everett and John Anderson so they don't burn-out the audience. But when you rotate several anchors who all weave similar lines into a sportscast, nobody realizes there's supposed to be a difference because there really isn't one.

The network occasionally breaks the cycle when Kenny Mayne makes a cameo in the air-chair. That's only because his humor comes in small doses. However, when he fills-in on Sunday nights, he can't utter two sentences without sandwiching-in sarcasm.

Then there's this new "Who's Now?" segment, the ridiculous ESPY Awards and those overdone SportsCenter commercials. These are ESPN's way of rubbing elbows with the athletes and keeping them happy enough to do appearances with the network, while making shows like NFL Live and Baseball Tonight play the heavy, investigating Michael Vick's kennel club and Barry Bonds' (alleged) steroid use.

"Who's Now?" is a segment hosted by Scott and discusses two athletes each day pit against each other by fans voting in a mock-tournament to see who the most popular athlete is in America. His panel: Jessica Biel, Kevin James and Mike Greenberg. Why? The actors have a movie heavily promoted by the network, while ESPN2 tanked with Cold Pizza and really needs the Mike and Mike simulcast to create numbers, while competing with repeats produced by their chest-bumping colleagues on the mothership. None of them have anything real to add to the competition, which itself isn't real anyway.

Before we realize it, ESPN will abandon scores, highlights and games like MTV has exchanged videos for reality TV. We'll get 24 hours of World Series of Poker, Celebrity Softball and Stuart Scott hosting the ESPN incarnation of Cribs.

Better hope your cable company adds NFL Network real soon.

Published by Dan Borrello

Sports talk show host and freelance writer from Rochester, N.Y. Hope you enjoy my diatribes. They're even better when read with a Snickers.  View profile

15 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Tim Devaney7/26/2007

    Respectfully, I think you're just too afraid of change. I mean I'm not a big change guy myself, but SportsCenter is still as great as it used to be - it's interesting the first time through and boring after that. I haven't noticed a lot of change, but I don't think it is that much worse.

  • Bruce Sarte7/24/2007

    Nicely done, I've been "off" SportsCenter for a while now.. used to be addicted to it!

  • Raul Qaye7/24/2007

    Awesome article! I completely agree :)

  • Dan Borrello7/23/2007

    (CONT. FROM BELOW) ESPN has no rival in sports coverage, so people go there because they have no other choices.

    ESPN has TV contracts with every major sports league, except for the NHL, so they have the ability to cover each of these with in-depth reporting. Nobody is saying ESPN is a bad network. People are saying, however, that SportsCenter has lost its focus and caters to the lowest common denominator.

  • Lindell7/23/2007

    Good work!

  • Dan Borrello7/23/2007

    In response to frabab15, not every cable network or cable package includes ESPNEWS, whereas EVERY cable company carries ESPN. Local sports affiliates for the Fox Sports Network don't necessarily cover national stories in markets where local sports is most important. In fact, they may not even cover entire leagues. For example, try being a Canadian looking for NHL highlights on your local news in Houston, TX. It's not going to happen.

    Then there are some regions (western New York) where Fox doesn't offer a regional sports network.

    SportsCenter wins ratings by default. It's not just the flagship show for ESPN, but for ALL sports networks. And since it airs at 6 pm, 11 pm, 1 am, 2 am and the entire morning after, it's convenient and easy for all sports fans to find no matter their schedules. ESPN is as recognizable a product for sports as Coke and McDonalds are for cola or fast food. The difference is those products have distinguishable competitors like Pepsi and Burger King. ESPN h

  • Dmitri7/23/2007

    The "Who's Now" section on Sportscenter reminds me of an old bit on the "Simpsons" where Homer and Carl and Lenny were at Moe's arguing over "Johnny Mathis in his prime or Diet Pepsi?"

  • ivylily7/23/2007

    Do you still have your own sports talk show in Rochester?

  • frabab157/23/2007

    If it's so bad, then why do more people watch it than any other sports program?????

  • William Pinn7/23/2007

    Well, ESPN does stand for "Every Sport--Party Night."

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.