State of Wisconsin Orders Gas Station Owner to Raise Prices

State Claims Gasoline Prices Fall Below the Allowable Minimum Markup

R.E. Norton
The state of Wisconsin has ordered a service station owner to raise the station's gasoline prices. The owner of a BP service station in Merrill, Wisconsin had set out to help senior citizens and people who support youth sports programs by offering discounts on gasoline. But the state has claimed the discounts are illegal and ordered him to raise his gas prices.

Raj Bhandari is the owner of the Center City BP station in Merrill. The Associated Press reports Bhandari had offered a gasoline discount of two cents per gallon for senior citizens. He also offered a discount card allowing sports boosters a price break of three cents per gallon. One patron, Dale Van Camp tried to support the local youth hockey program by purchasing a fifty-dollar card. Van Camp said the card would have saved him about one hundred dollars per year on gasoline.

But the Wisconsin Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection has objected to the discounts. The state's Unfair Sales Act requires gas stations to sell gasoline for 9.2 percent more than the wholesale price. The AT & CP Department says Center City BP's discount offers violate the Unfair Sales Act.

Bhandari said that he received notice in April from the state auditor that the state would file a lawsuit against him if he does not raise gas prices. "In our case, it's cutting the state margin," he told the Wausau Daily Herald. He could be subject to a penalty for each gallon of discounted gas he has sold. If that happens a judge will determine the amount for Bhandari's fine. Van Camp said he has asked state representative Don Friske (R-Merrill) to consider amending the law. The change would allow locally owned stations to offer discounts that would benefit local schools.

Bhandari bought the Center City BP station a year ago. He said about ten percent of his customers had been using the discount cards. Bhandari has informed his customers the discounts have been discontinued. But he is concerned that raising prices will cause customers to believe he stopped offering the discounts to make more money for himself. Annette Stover, a clerk at Center City BP, said the station's employees have been doing their best to explain the change to those patrons who were using the discounts.

Published by R.E. Norton

I'm a 43 year old Midwest male - happily married with a 15 year old stepson and a three year-old little boy. My wife and I are very active in our church. My hobbies include reading, creative writing, music...  View profile

10 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Suebee8/13/2008

    Dictator - exactly .... thats why they are politicians. And G Dubbya is their king.

  • Straight outta merrill 12/3/2007

    ive been to that gas station several time and the guy who reported this was is my freidns dad lol

  • Jamie K. Wilson5/14/2007

    This is weird. I used to work at a Kroger regional office, and the gas guys were on the other side of my cube wall. I heard them calling to check on area prices all the time, but I never heard of them worrying that they'd hit a state minimum in any of the five states they served. I wonder if this is even constitutional.

  • Wes Laurie5/13/2007

    The laws of gas pricing get very tricky sometimes at the business level, especially when it comes to competition...

  • Jeff Musall5/13/2007

    While the regulatory glitch is regrettable, it is mostly a strawman. The real reasons have something to do with supply and demand-the manipulation of supply and demand, that is. It is no accident that gas prices have nearly tripled under the current administration. Think I'm wrong? If the next quartely announcement doesn't indicate new record profits for oil companies, I'll eat my shoes.

  • Chris Creech5/12/2007

    Supply and demand. If you lower the price, people that don't need it as badly are going to freak out and buy as much as they can, lowering supply and increasing demand, driving our prices and the prices for people who need it much more up. It is a shame that it had to happen, but that's how the system works.

  • Kat Mitschke5/12/2007

    It was nice to read that someone was trying to help seniors and youth groups out. To bad about the unfortunate out come.

  • Roselyn James5/11/2007

    That's insane.

  • Rebecca Livermore5/11/2007

    That's too bad!

  • Karen McCaghren5/11/2007

    Just unbelievable! Only in America, right?

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.