Stay Away from the Kite Runner

Frank V.
I'm just about to finish reading the blockbuster novel, The Kite Runner. I don't usually read anything that's fiction because I don't like books that play with my emotions just for the hell of it. I'll usually stick to non-fiction or fiction based on actual events. After hearing so much about this particular book, and having an interest in the events occurring in Afghanistan, I decided to take a chance. Well, all I can say is this is a very well written book if you are into VC Andrews or if you watch soap operas. Otherwise there is nothing fabulous about it. Ridden with clichés and absurd plot twists, right up to the classic: my dead best friend was my brother and I never knew, it's nothing more than a story written by a surgeon who claims it's fiction. I personally find it very hard to believe that this is a work of fiction. With a lead character that is so unlikable maybe the author is ashamed to admit that it's him. I want to hear true stories of his life in Afghanistan, not a supposedly made up one that is simply written to make the reader go "Oh my, I was never expecting that." Number one rule of writing, Do Not Play The Reader Like They Are Dumb. It's a shame because a lot of people are probably looking at this book as a history lesson, when there are so many better, TRUE stories out there of this land and it's culture. Do a little research and find the stories that matter, and don't pick up trash that passes off as culture. Now let me get back to finishing up the last chapter. I can't wait to see how little Sohrab turns out.

Published by Frank V.

I'm an extremely cynical person and I found that writing is great for ranting. So here I am! I like to be funny too, sometimes.  View profile

2 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Rose Schaut1/18/2009

    I'm an English teacher who teaches The Kite Runner to my students. I am disappointed to read your comments regarding a novel that, albiet as clearly fiction, has opened my students eyes beyond the United States of America. While you may find the lead character unlikeable, you may want to consider that the horrid decision he makes in Chapter 7, to not come to the rescue of Hassan, was a decision made by a frightened 12 year old boy. It is Amir as a man who is given the chance to right this past wrong, and who finally has the courage and maturity to do so. Perhaps your past is unscathed; perhaps there is nothing in your past that you regret. But for me, the author, and the hundreds of students I have discussed this novel with, it touches a part of us that is unfortunately, a reality of most people's lifes. As for what you imply is a sappy ending? Read it again. There is a heck of a lot of pain in this novel that is based on real, historical horrors taking place all over the world.

  • Audrey M. Brown3/18/2008

    I haven't read it, but it's good to hear someone with a contrary opinion to the populus. Must just be the setting that has everyone screaming, "relevant!"

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.