Ten Reasons Why You Should Not Buy Maybelline's Water-proof Liquid Eyeliner
Is it Really Water-proof?
#10 The dreadful application process
Having to draw a perfect line isn't an easy thing to do unless you are a professional drawer. This product has a tip that doesn't allow you to make a perfect line, you might make a thick line on one eye and on the other one a thin line.
#9 Is it worth the price?
Maybelline's waterproof liquid eyeliner goes for about $7.00. It is a pricey eyeliner and might not be worth every penny once you have it on and see the results. I would go for a different eyeliner that isn't too much and might be better than this one.
#8 Run, run from it!
When choosing a liquid eyeliner you want to make sure it doesn't run. If you ever sneeze or yawn and your eyes get watery you don't want the liner to smudge all over your face right? Wrong, this particular eyeliner does not live up to it's name. They say on their website "No smudges, smears, or runs" totally untrue. When I started using this product I had constant runs and smudges. When I was at work I had to go to the restroom every 10 minutes and make sure my face was clean from smears. If it rains beware! the liner will run all the way down to your cheeks.
#7 Mistake proof application
Well they say if you make a mistake while applying the liner on your eyes it can easily be fixed. The only way I could get the liner to disappear was with my daughters wipes. Even if you use some water and a towel it will not come out completely. Once you have made a mistake you have to wipe the whole thing off and start over.
#6 Long lasting
Sure its long lasting, the smears and the runs are, not the liner. The liner comes in a small bottle that has about .25 ml of the liquid,it is so small that it only lasts a little bit, and for the price it's not worth spending so much if you have to always run and buy another one so soon.
#5 Colors
It comes in 3 different colors : black, brown and Grey. Not much variety and the color isn't really dark if you choose black. To get a dark color you need to re-apply it over the first coat so you get a darker black.
#4 Maybelline
Maybe because it is a Maybelline brand many women automatically think it will be great, don't be fooled. Just because it is a well-known product doesn't mean it won't flop. I myself used this product for a month because I was too cheap to go out and by a different one. I have just recently upgraded to a much better liquid eyeliner and am glad I did.
#3 complaints
I myself am not the only person who has complained about this product. I have read reviews about it and have noticed that it is all similar to my complaints. If you want to know if a product is good before buying it make sure to read reviews,this is very helpful. I didn't think of checking out this particular product review and I wish I would have.
#2 Patches
When wearing this eyeliner for at least 3 hours I was getting black patches under my eyes. As I mentioned before it is very hard to take off, so be prepared with some wipes to clean it off.
#1 Overall
I give this product a 1 out of 5 score, I like the fact that it was a liquid eyeliner and that the small bottle was cute. Other than that everything else didn't seem to do it for me. I f you decide to try this product just be aware of what I mentioned in this article before you go out and buy it. There are many other liquid eyeliners that are really water-proof.
Published by Maricruz
mom to 3 beautiful girls View profile
- Ten Reasons Why You Should Not Buy Jonathan Product's Add Moisture Shampoo & Condi...Jonathan Antin may be getting famous for his haircuts on Bravo's "Blow Out," but he has a lot to learn about hair products. Jonathan Product leaves a lot to be desired, from the flimsy bottle to the sub-par formula w...
- Colon Cleansing Product Review: Clean N' Lean Phase Two - Super DetoxIf you are looking for a dietary supplement to help maintain the results obtained from your recent colon hydrotherapy, herbal colon cleansing, or as a regular cleansing product, then you may want to consider using Cle...
Product Review: Origins Spot RemoverA review of Origins top acne treatment gel. A surprising product experience from a company that is known for quality products for all kinds of skin types.
Product Review:Listerine Agent Cool Blue Plaque Detecting RinseWhat this product claims...and what it really does.- Febreze Fabric Refresher--The Miracle ProductFebreze fabric refresher has been a staple in my home now for as long as it has been on the market. Over time, I have discovered that the uses for this wonderful product stretch far beyond the listed uses.
- Product Review of Maybelline's Unstoppable Eyeliner
- L'Oreal True Match Liquid Foundation Review
- Lose Weight on a Restricted, Liquid Diet
- Product Naming Tips
- The Liquid Lounge in Nekoosa, Wisconsin: Review
- 10 Tips on Choosing a Product or Service to Sell
- 10 Tips on How to Price Your Product or Service
- Not worth the money
- Is not water-proof at all
- Not enough available in the bottle to last





10 Comments
Post a CommentI'm a full time wedding makeup artist. This eyeliner works amazingly well with all my clients. I use this product on myself as well and never had a problem. Only the matter of where and how you apply the product.
I could not agree more with this article! I don't know why the package is labeled "waterproof" when it is NOT! The tip is nice, but the product comes off so easily. Even the slightest wetness to my eyes makes the eyeliner come off, gets smudged, and just won't stay on. I am searching for a real waterproof eyeliner, even if I have to pay $30 or more for it. A good waterproof eyeliner is worth the price if it stays on. This product DOES NOT! I strongly urge anyone wanting a good waterproof eyeliner not to purchase Maybelline "Waterproof" eyeliner.
I personally love this eyeliner and know many women who also swear by it. It is sad to see that this article is one of the first few to appear on a search engine when looking up maybelline eyeliner. I feel this is only giving one side to the product...a bad side and no one is giving the good sides to it.
I love this eye liner it's the only one I would ever use.
I had the same problem with my eyeliner but it was because I had gotten one that was old I guess, because when I bought another one it worked great, maybe some aren't made well.. many items have mishaps
http://www.maybelline.com/Product/Eye/EyeLiner/lineworks-waterproof-liquid-eyeliner.htm
I use this and I love it. For a drug store eyeliner, I think it's great. It has a sponge applicator instead of a brush which is super easy to apply. It lasts a long time also. However, I don't use it because it works well being a waterproof liner. My roommate and I both love it and I know a lot of other girls who do too. It doesn't fade after hours of wear which is awesome.
All I can say is that I swim with this on and everyone is baffled how well my make-up stays on. The felt tip is actually easier to apply than a thin brush, and I take it off so easily with make-up removing facewash.
I had a bad reaction to Maybelline's waterproof liquid eyeliner! my eyelids came out in rashes! it was so painful and itchy =( if you have sensitive skin dont try this unless you want red eyelids...
btw, does anyone know a great brand of liquid eyeliner that doesnt smudge?
This is the only liner I use. I swear by it.
I have been using this product for a long time and I haven't really had any of the problems you are having. It did not run unless I rubbed my eyes by accident and I didn't find drawing the line so difficult either. The eyeliner comes out as dark as paint and the bottle lasts for 3-4 months. It could just be me but I thought it was actually pretty good eyeliner.