Ten Reasons Why You Shouldn't Buy Best Buy's Rhapsody Music Service

Best Buy's Attempt at the Music Downloading Scene

Matt

Best Buy partnered up with a service called Rhapsody that allows you to download music and burn it to a CD. It uses an application with a built in radio player so you can browse their selection, select only the songs you want, and then create a custom CD. This sounds good, but something convenient like this just results in a lot of problems. I used to work at a Best Buy retail store and was given the opportunity to sample this service and try it out on my own. I'm a huge fan of both music and technology, so I decided to give it a shot. I shortly found out after a month and a half of service that this piece of dung was another failed attempt at a good idea. Allow me to explain to you ten reasons why you shouldn't buy Best Buy's Rhapsody service:

Cost - Rhapsody costs $10 a month plus $0.79 to download and burn a song to a CD. Most music downloading services will do either one or the other, but Rhapsody charges you both for the service and the ability to download a song.

Selection
- The selection is very mediocre. You won't find any rare songs with this service. It's mostly popular bands, and the music available is only from recently released albums. A difficult challenge for these music services is getting the license to distribute the music from artists, and that in return makes the selection a lot worse. I've tried browsing for popular bands that I knew released more than 10 albums and maybe 4-5 of them are available. I can't complain too much, but there are many other competing services out there that offer much more for a lot less.

Bulky - The application itself is bulky and sometimes slow. If you have a slower system with limited hardware capabilities, you won't be able to listen to the music that you are paying $10 a month to listen to using their built in player. It's also extremely buggy.

Artists' Compensation - Artists make very little with their content on Rhapsody. Rumors of as little as a single cent per song are awarded to the artists who are trying to survive in this tough industry.

DRM (Digital Rights Management) - In theory, it's a good idea, but in reality it's very limiting and makes any service that uses it frowned upon by loyal music fans.

Customer Service - Slow and barely responsive. I had problems downloading a few songs and when I sent them a few nasty e-mails, they responded once and never solved the problem.

Owned By Real - Not exactly the greatest company to manage a music downloading service. Everything they make is slow and a pain to setup. No offense to Real, but they need to make something that doesn't take strenuous effort to setup.

Music Disappears - If you see a song you like available one day, there's a chance it might disappear tomorrow. Some bands decide to pull their music from the service randomly. Annoying, yet understandable… considering the service…

Burning CDs - Burning a song to a CD is very challenging when it creates errors, disconnects and sometimes fails to play after a successful burn.

Spam - Not surprising in this day in age, but I received a lot of spam mail after signing up with this service. It's not very reassuring when you trust all your billing information with a company that doesn't seem to protect it in a proper manner. That was a mistake!

When I first discovered Rhapsody, I thought it had a lot of potential. Best Buy made a good move in pushing the online market for music, since online piracy has been a problem lately. However, their service is poor, and definitely not worth the charges. I'd rather stick with a service like iTunes or any other music downloading service that provides a lot more for a much greater value.

Published by Matt

developer, writer, traveler, athlete, marketer  View profile

  • Don't Settle for $10 a month
  • 79 cents a song isn't as great as it sounds
  • Find something else to get your music
Try out allofmp3.com instead - It's DRM free, you can choose the quality you want, and it's A LOT cheaper

16 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Bob11/21/2010

    Comment written in 2006... Achient history... way different now.

  • Anonymous2/26/2009

    I used to have this service, in attempting to cancel I was on hold 3hrs. Thats insane. The hope is you give up and keep paying. I liked the service when I had it, but won't go back because of this tactic

  • Queen Shabazz9/21/2008

    The service is fine up until you try to cancel. I have had the service for 6 months now and really dont use it enough to keep. When I was finally able to cancel the service. The songs on my MP3 player stopped playing. What is up with that?

  • steve6/6/2008

    Reading some of these comments, I'd say a lot of you out there are technically inept; hence the need for this Rapsody service.

  • Jazzmine12/23/2007

    yall is crazy it show did work 4 me

  • spruitt11/29/2007

    I been using rhapsody for a couple of years now and love it. Yes; sometimes i can't find some of the old songs i like but i do find most of them. I have no problems with the software and/or downloads. I like the fact that i can create my own playlist, pay for only the tracks i like from a specific album and burn the cd. I've other services in the past but this one; in my opinion, is the best.

  • Jim9/11/2007

    I have been using Rhapsody for over 3 years, and it is an excellent value. The service is not perfect, but it is very good. I never pay the $.79 per song, because I simply record the music to a wave file as it is playing back on Rhapsody and then use my own software to make cds. I have found the selection to be amazing, covering all types of music from now back to many decades ago. The customer service has also been quick and helpful. I recommend Rhapsody to everyone. I pay a flat $13 a month and have access to virtually every song ever recorded.

  • Katherine7/22/2007

    Very dissatisfied with service which is why I did a search to see if others were having the same problem. I got a gift card and it won't work. Called tech support and still won't work. I'm planning on trading it in for itunes soon.

  • mark foster4/13/2007

    I've been a VERY satisfied Rhapsody customer since the fall of 2005. While there are some groups I wish would release content (Finger Eleven, for one) it hasn't killed my experience at all. I've been able to fid some smaller bands, like The Davenports, and track down some songs I'v ben looking for for a while now. Is it the greatest service ever? Probably not... but, then, not everything can be perfect. People have just as many complains about iTunes, I'm sure.

  • Dave Geller3/21/2007

    Hmmm... software arbitrarily cut off my post .
    Part II (Part I follows)

    7. Owned by real - not only are they a blue company but they now support Rhapsody on Linux! The ONLY real alternative to music subscription services using Microsoft technology (or iTunes).
    8. Music Disappears - true but it rarely happens and if you consider the 9.95/able to listen to anything anytime and the download service as separate, just buy what you really like and it's not a problem.
    9. Burning CD's - works for me, maybe you should try the newer player
    10. Spam - I specifically signed up my account with Real as realspam@mydomain.com. I've NEVER received a spam at that email address.

    11. Music channels that you set up that play a constant stream of varied music according to your taste settings.

    Maybe you should give Rhapsody another try? Or not, your choice but I think it's awesome - enough to spend 15 minutes writing a reply. With the unlimited ability to listen to anything you want at anytim

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.