The Black Dahlia: A Laborious Film

Nathan R. Hale
If you waited until The Black Dahlia was out on DVD to decide to see it, you made the right choice. This laborious film noir is long and convoluted, and given today's theatre prices, it would have made me an unhappy camper thinking about whether or not I had gotten my money's worth.

Director Brian De Palma's vision of James Elloroy's murder mystery novel is clearly artistic, and the all-star cast (Josh Hartnett, Scarlett Johansson, Hilary Swank) obviously makes a great effort. But like so many other books-turned-film, the story seems to loose something in the transition from manuscript to celluloid.

While atmospherically brilliant, parts of this film will leave you dazed, and possibly confused at the end. It's not a too terrible choice for a rental, though, since there are compelling parts to the narrative, and a pretty cool twist at the end.

B-

Published by Nathan R. Hale

Composer, writer, and sci-fi fan Nathan Hale was born in the USA, but spent his childhood abroad in Africa and Europe. He enjoys lending a global perspective to all his creative efforts, including freelance...  View profile

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.