The Controversy of Columbus Day

Stephanie Burkhart
Christopher Columbus was born in Genoa, Italy in 1451 and at the age of fourteen became a sailor. He made sea voyages for Portugal to Iceland and Guinea, but when the king of Portugal declined to provide support to him so he could find the East Indies, Columbus sought out Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand of Spain.

The Spanish monarchs gave him the backing he was looking for. On August 2, 1492, Columbus set out for the East Indies with the Nina, Pinta, and Santa Maria, his three ships. On October 12, 1492, Columbus spied several islands, landing on what is the present day Bahamas.

On December 25, 1492, the Santa Maria sank off the coast of Haiti. Columbus departed for Spain on January 16, 1493, and arrived on March 4, 1493.

While Columbus did not see mainland North America, what he did do is conclusively prove the world was round, and he brought about the interaction of Europeans with the Native American people.

Columbus Day is meant to commemorate the day Christopher Columbus arrived in the new world, October 12th. In the United States, San Francisco boasts the oldest celebration of Columbus Day dating back to 1869. In 1907, Colorado was the first state to recognize Columbus Day. In 1937, at the request of the Knights of Columbus, (named after Columbus) President Franklin Roosevelt made Columbus Day a federal holiday to be celebrated on October 12th. Since 1971, the holiday has been celebrated on the second Monday in October. Currently, most banks, post offices, governments, and schools honor the holiday, but businesses and the stock exchange stay open.

In Latin America, Columbus Day is known as "Dia de la Raza," (day of the race) and it's meant to commemorate the first encounter of Europeans and Native Americans.

So why has the holiday run into controversy as of late? Columbus didn't discover the Americas. While it was because of him that Europeans and Native Americans began to interact, it was the Vikings who explored the North American coast 500 years before him. Not only that, the question of whether one can discover an inhabited island has been raised as well. While the discovery of the Americas was a positive one for the Europeans, most Native Americans suffered from it.

Columbus Day is not celebrated in Minnesota, and in South Dakota, October 12th is officially a state holiday known as "Native American Day." In Nevada, Columbus Day is not a legal holiday, but a day of observance where schools, state, city, and county government offices are open for business.

Published by Stephanie Burkhart

Stephanie Burkhart (who also writes under the pen name SG Cardin) grew up in Manchester, New Hampshire. She served in the military from 1986-1997. She currently works as a 911 Dispatcher for LAPD.   View profile

South Dakota, Minnesota, and Nevada do not officially celebrate "Columbus Day."

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Adrian Zupp 10/11/2010

    In the name of equal rights, shouldn't we have a holiday for ALL mass murderers?

    See my blog post on Columbus Day:
    http://adrianzupp.blogspot.com/2010/10/shouldnt-we-celebrate-charles-manson.html

    Take care,
    Adrian Zupp

  • shadow pup 1/22/2010

    no he is my dog dounut

  • comander 1/22/2010

    who is timmy your boyfreind

  • shadow pup 1/22/2010

    aaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh boring please kill me im in drama school
    Timmy

  • Bump!!!!!!!!!!! 11/28/2008

    I like this artical but why does it have such a low rating?

  • lucio the great 11/28/2008

    hey this is a great website

  • Your name 11/10/2008

    Hey guys

  • Your name 11/10/2008

    HEllo??

  • Your name 11/10/2008

    HAHAHAHAHA

  • Bethany From NJ 10/7/2008

    Wow this is such crap! Are you serious next i'll read the holocaust didn't happen and Hitler and the Nazi's were just a social group that was exsclusive! We all know he was not the firs to come here "to the New World", but he sure know how to enslave a destroy cultures!

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.