The Differences Between Puppy Mills and Professional Kennels

What You Should Know About Puppy Mills Versus Professional Breeders

Chris M. Carmichael
You've probably heard the term Puppy Mill and have seen the video footage of dogs in cramped and filthy cages. But, along with inhumane living conditions, there are other differences between puppy mills versus professional kennels. This article explains the many differences between those who run puppy mills and those who are professional, responsible, breeders.

The biggest differences between professional, responsible breeders and owners of puppy mills are attitude and purpose.

Owners of puppy mills are in it to make money. Profit is their priority and one way that puppy mill operators increase their profit is by running the operation cheaply. Dogs are confined to cages or small runs and suffer from overcrowding and/or long-term confinement. Dogs in puppy mills do not receive all the veterinary care they need because vet care is costly, especially for the larger number of dogs a typical mill has, and most veterinarians will report a puppy mill.

Responsible dog breeders, on the other hand, are not just breeding dogs for money. They want to promote positive characteristics in certain dog breeds. They do make money selling the puppies, but it is a much different situation and the attitude is very different from puppy mills.

Breeders spend money on proper veterinary care. They take good care of the dogs because they care about them, and because they know that animals used for breeding must be well cared for if they are to produce the best litters. Breeders do profit from selling the pups but, after veterinary costs, food costs (breeders are selective about food they feed their dogs) and other costs, they don't profit as much as one might think.

Responsible, professional breeders love dogs and, therefore, take good care of them. They provide proper housing and allow visits to their home. Breeders do not keep dogs in unsanitary conditions or cages with bare-wire flooring or other unsuitable flooring that could injure the dog's paws.

Professional dog breeders are knowledgeable about special needs of the breeds they raise. Also, they are more than willing to discuss the dogs and show the dogs and their facility because they enjoy what they do and they enjoy discussing the breed. The AKC encourages people to visit a breeder's home to meet the dogs and the owner before buying a puppy. Blindly buying a puppy is never endorsed or encouraged.

Responsible breeders know that mental health of an animal is important. Dogs kept in small cages go "stir crazy" and are unhealthy mentally and physically. Breeders will allow playtime-- and they know that all dogs, including small dogs such as Pomeranians, need room to move.

Pet stores and puppy mills

Pets of Bel Air, an upscale pet store in Bel Air, California, recently came under fire when The Humane Society of the United States alleged the puppies at the store came from puppy mills. Investigators from the HSUS had traced puppies sold at the pet store to several puppy mills. Pets of Bel Air had told customers that the dogs came from private breeders. It is unfortunate that anyone seeking to buy a puppy should not trust the word of a pet store--but that seems to be the reality much of the time.

Unless a pet store can give you the name and real address of the breeder so that you can speak with the breeder and inspect the home or kennel, do not buy a dog from a pet store. When you buy a dog from a pet store without checking the true origin of the dog, you might be putting money in the pockets of puppy mill operators.

An exception to this is stores such as Pet Smart. Pet Smart, in Kansas and other areas, allows rescue organizations (here the organizations are PALS animal rescue and the Kansas Humane Society) to place pets up for adoption in the stores. These are often rescued pets or pets that have been relinquished by an owner to a shelter. They have received veterinary care and are current on shots.

Puppy mills still exist because they continue to be profitable. In the long run, the way to stop puppy mills is to impact their profitability. The way to do this is to only adopt from shelters, rescue organizations, or from responsible breeders.

Published by Chris M. Carmichael

Chris M. Carmichael writes on a wide range of topics and has a broad range of interests (and experience), including Screenwriting, Acting, Forensic Science, Pets, Martial Arts and Abnormal Psychology. Chris...  View profile

16 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Anne12/18/2011

    I am so sorry I have ran across so many puppy Mills In My Line of Business
    I am a small And I do Stress Very Small Scale Breeder and when I am asked by someone if they may use one of my Studs to breed one of there dogs I will tell them I need to make a appointment to come and view the home and I need to know the intention of the breeding then they have to take there female to my vet for a in-depth exam and then I will Welcome her into my home to be bred on the OK from my Vet
    I have 3 Studs Very Small Toy Breeds and then 2 Females per stud
    I do not cage my dogs EVER and the boys do wear Belly bands
    They have the run of my home and they are my babies and I will NEVER EVER EVER sell a puppy for a holiday gift
    I have been doing this for 30 some odd years now and I feed the best food Possible recommended by a few different Vets
    I just think it is such a shame to watch these shows on Animal Planet when the Animal Control is called to help a dog, horse, kitty, any little animal that did not ask to be here on this earth and they are being treated so Horribly by Us humans
    Shame On us who do we think we are to mistreat these poor helpless animals who while on there death bed will still muster up the energy to wag there tail to show us how much they love us
    Just Unbelievable
    I will do anything and everything I can to help anyone who tries to Legitimately Save a animal In Need
    Many Blessings to all who have the same beliefs as I

  • The Cat Knows More Than You12/17/2011

    Adopt! Don't Shop!

  • Rena Sherwood2/15/2010

    Puppy mills -- profesional dog breeders -- both contribute to homeless pets. We need to get rid of purebreds. If you want a dog -- ADOPT!

  • Glenn Massie1/29/2010

    Buying a puppy without problems is harder than most people think. Finding a responsible and knowledgeable breeder is very difficult.
    Please download and read, "How To Buy A Puppy" before you consider parting with your money. It is free @ www.howtobuyapuppy.net

  • libby1/17/2010

    Of corse, the person whose "pet" had a litter should by all means sell their puppies to a pet shop! Fluffy needs to earn her way after all. And most importantly, since the "pet" owner isn't a "breeder" they will best know the details to look for in selecting a mate for their pet, and for that matter their expertise will guide them in their non-breeding program; have I got that right? Come on. Responsible "pet" owners neuter or spay their pets, and leave the selection of suitable, healthy, standard conforming, animals to professional breeders.

  • Phyllis Cunningham4/5/2008

    Last spring there was a dog auction for a local "breeder". I swear I wanted to take home every dog they had. I opted out of any. But, an aquaintence of mine wasn't so lucky. She bought an adorable dog with so many issues (I think caused by the "stir crazy" effect) that she was ill equipped to deal with them. So sad.

  • PHILLIP2/5/2008

    Awesome article on an important issue. "Puppy mills" are horrible. Buy always from a shelter or a very reputable breeder.

  • Chris M. Carmichael1/3/2008

    That is wonderful, Rebecca! Thanks for the comments

  • Rebecca Livermore1/3/2008

    We adopted our dog from a rat terrier rescue place. I would definitely do that again. They did not even cash our check till 30 days after we adopted him, and even then, only after they came to see how we were getting along. They didn't want the dog with a family that he was not compatible with. I appreciated the care they put into making sure the dog would be well cared for. He came from an abusive home, but he is a very welcome part of our family now!

  • Dee1/2/2008

    Puppy Mills should be banned. I think most pet store malls get theirs from puppy mills. Great article

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.