The Five Best Baseball Announcers of All Time

Darren Pare
I have been a baseball fan for more than 30 of the 38 years I have been on this planet. In my mind there is nothing better than spending a summer's evening either listening or watching a good baseball game. Baseball announcers used to be the voice of the city, but that doesn't seem to be the case anymore. Today's announcers seem more preoccupied with making up canned catchphrases, than describing the games they are covering. With that in mind we will take a nostalgic look back at the best announcers baseball has ever had.

5. Bob Uecker: A former back up catcher for six less than stellar major league seasons, Uecker has parlayed that into an impressive career as a broadcaster, actor, and pitchman. Uecker had a lifetime batting average of .200, but that only seems to have endeared him to the American public. Uecker has used a self deprecating style in the booth for 39 years of Milwaukee Brewers baseball. He has an easygoing nature and never takes the game too seriously. He received the Ford C. Frick Award in 2003 inducting him into the Baseball Hall of Fame.

4. Harry Kalas: The distinctive baritone voice of the Philadelphia Phillies, Kalas, passed away suddenly in 2009. He had been with the Phillies since 1971. He called two World Series championships for the Phillies. Kalas was known for his home run call of "outta here." He also was the voice of NFL Films for 31 years and did several Chunky Soup commercials. His most famous call was probably on Mike Schmidt's 500th career home run. "Swing and a long drive... there it is... No. 500, the career 500th home run for Michael Jack Schmidt." His style was plain and simple, not done to overshadow the game. He was inducted in the broadcaster's wing of the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2002.

3. Mel Allen: Although he was from the south, Birmingham, Alabama to be exact, Allen became known as the voice of the Yankees. He started broadcasting baseball in 1938 and, with some breaks in between, did so until 1985. For many Allen was known as the voice of the syndicated television This Week in Baseball, a job he held from the show's inception in 1977 until his death in 1996. His most famous saying was probably his call after a great play of "How about that." Allen is honored with a plaque at Yankee Stadium's Monument Park. He joined the Baseball Hall Of Fame in 1978, he and Red Barber were the first two broadcasters enshrined.

2. Ernie Harwell: As the voice of the Detroit Tigers, Harwell spent 42 years broadcasting for the team until he retired in 2002 at the age of 84. Listening to Harwell on the radio was like listening to a friend, you had the feeling he was just one of the guys. He told stories rather than bang you over the head with incessant numbers. The fans in Detroit loved Harwell so much that when the team replaced him in 1991 the outcry was so overwhelming that he was back a year later. Harwell entered the Hall of Fame in 1981. In 2009 he announced that he has inoperable cancer and probably had less than a year to live. As of this writing Harwell is still fighting the battle.

1. Vin Scully: The voice of the Dodgers for 60 years, Scully holds the record for longest consecutive tenure with one team. The most amazing part of Scully's career is now where he works without a color analyst. He has to fill in all the down time in a baseball game himself and does it seemingly effortlessly. Scully says that one of his favorite things to do is sit back and be quiet and let the crowd and the moment do the talking. This approach is brilliant and should be used more by many of today's talking heads. Scully was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1982.

So there you have it my list of the five greatest announcers of all time. I do want to add an honorable mention to long time Cardinals announcer Jack Buck. Now if only annoying announcers like John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman could learn from these guys and shape up, or better yet maybe they should just go away.

Published by Darren Pare - Featured Contributor in Sports

I am an author from Orono, Maine currently working on writing my second book and promoting my first one, 33 Summers. I am married and have two children. I am a freelance writer who has a passion for sports...  View profile

78 Comments

Post a Comment
  • D Schuster5/24/2012

    Thank you for finally saying John Sterling is the worst EVER! Loved the Scooter and "White" and Mercer. Loved Red Barber and Mel Allen. Vin is flawless and friendly. Harry has his fans. But Sterling!!! "AND the Yankees WIN, THE YANKEES WINnnnn!!! How gd obnoxious can you get. We owe Waldman for Yogi and George.

  • Matt5/17/2012

    We Braves fans dearly miss Skip Caray.

    "The bases are loaded, and (insert opposing manager's name here) probably wishes he was."

    If the Braves were losing badly: "Folks, as long as you patronize our sponsors, you may now turn off the TV and go walk the dog."

    Big-breasted girl shown on TV: "Two out here in the fifth inning."

    He was so entertaining.

  • Joe4/20/2012

    Loved the Scooter, but Red Barber was the best I've ever heard.

  • DJC1/16/2012

    Holy Cow, White! This guy missed the Scooter!

    Phil Rizzuto may not have been the most technically gifted commentator, but he certainly brought color to color commentary for a lot of Yankees fans for several decades. He was the John Madden of baseball, cause you never knew what he might say. And his play-by-play man, Bill White, was the Pat Summerall to the Scooter's Madden! Listening to a baseball game has never been the same since Rizzuto's retirement and passing.

  • ernie montgomery10/25/2011

    The best that I ever heard was Pee Wee Rease and Dizzy Dean calling a game together and in the 70's Ted Kubriac.( I hope I spelled his name right)

  • IRON MAN10/25/2011

    RED BARBER
    MEL ALLEN THE TWO BEST

  • Max10/7/2011

    That may be your favorite but not mine. I have been listening to games since 1940 and of course grew up listening to Harry Caray and he is my favorite. Vin Scully was great, still is. Harwell too. Gene Elston with the Astros was one of the best I ever heard. Joe Buck is one of the better announcers on TV in any sport in my opinion. I absolutely could not stand Howard Cosell. I listened to Dizzy Dean and Pee Wee Reese when they did the St. Louis games and although they could not be considered the best craftsmen, they were fun to listen to. At least they knew what they were talking about.

  • SaintTothEeVE9/8/2011

    Bill King, Lon Simmons & Russ Hodges. Bay Area sports fans know that these 3 were amongst the elite in their field.

    The ol' Diz tag teaming with Pee Wee was a hoot. Towards the end of a blowout Pee Wee would carry the game himself while Diz had a few and would start in with "Wabash Cannonball" in the background.

  • M8/13/2011

    How could you leave the singularly most colorful announcer of all time out of the top five...he was so colorful that local St. Louis English teachers deplored his speech ...DIZZY DEAN. And Red Barber with the bases FOB (full of Brooklyns) sitting in the catbird seat AND ENSHRINED IN THE HALL OF FAME as you noted in the blurb about Mel Allen.

  • Mike Fran8/12/2011

    what about curt gowdy? i can still hear him on the radio when i was in school, his great voice booming and resonating as he called those world series games in the late 60's.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.