The Good, the Bad, and the Drunk: A Users Guide to Rum

Lidon Pearce
Have you ever found yourself out on the high seas craving a nice drink of rum and then when someone passes the bottle your way and you take that long swig you've been waiting for you're punched in the teeth with some bastard's poor excuse for rum that tastes more like gasoline? Well, maybe not, but regardless every seafaring scallywag or land wobblers should take it upon himself to learn how to distinguish a good rum from something that is only suitable for use as lighter fluid. Whether your profession takes you out on the seven seas or you're more likely to be entertaining men and women with suits and briefcases it is vital you are armed with the right knowledge in choosing good rum.

Let us start with the standard by which all rims are measured, trusty old Captain Morgan. Captain Morgan is one of the few types of liquor any good collection should always stay stocked with. It is the most widely known rum through out the seven seas and easily mixed with Coca-Cola or can be served on the rocks. Typically not as smooth as most rum it is best served with coke and a dash of grenadine. Its wide circulation and modest price at just under $20 a bottle make it a favorite for any sailor. Captain Morgan also offers its Private Stock which for a few dollars more it is a great investment. Its taste is a little more smoother and rich making it more enjoyable on the rocks. Private Stock also comes in a very decorative and convenient bottle; I use my empties for collecting loose change and housing my own home-brewed rum. Captain Morgan has also introduced a new flavor Tattoo, which is a darker rum that has a sweet taste and is excellent with coke. Whenever in doubt Captain Morgan is a most honorable choice and at around $20 a bottle for most varieties you won't have to go digging into your buried treasure.

Next stop on our rum crusade, Planters Gold:Pyrat XO Reserve and the immortal Pyrat Cask 23. Pyrat XO is rum so exquisite that once you have tasted it you will never go back to drinking rum and coke. Its aroma and taste are only matched by its remarkable smoothness. While most rums are a delight to drink Pyrat XO will make you wont to quit your day job and go off sailing with the first band of misfits you come across. It is also quite affordable at just under $30 a bottle and is packaged very nicely. Pyrat XO is a little harder to find than Captain Morgan's but any reputable liquor store should stock it. Serve this rum at your next get together and your guest will think you are a true rum connoisseur and are shelling out top dollar. Now should you decide you want to try a top dollar for rum then look no further then Pyrat Cask 23. This rum is so good that Blackbeard himself would have emptied out the gold in his treasure chest to make room for this beauty. The rum is arguably the most smooth of not just rum but perhaps any liquors I have had the pleasure of drinking. Pyrat Cask 23 is blended from some of the finest rums known to the world and is presented in a hand blown glass bottle and comes with its own cedar chest which you will need because at just over $300 dollars a bottle you will wont to bury in your backyard. Planters Gold by far leads the pack in rum quality and I highly recommend the XO Reserve giving my full pirate approval.

The following rums are ones that won't let down and are sure to please even the most salty of pirates. Jack Tar Superior is a very noble choice for any rum drinker, but beware it is definitely rum and you wont find anything fruity are sweet here, just plain old good quality rum. Barbancourt makes some very fine amber rum available in an 8 year variety and 15 year variety. Another very affordable and popular rum is Appleton V/X. This rum is greatly priced and much suited for the everyday drinker who has to balance quality and taste. At under $30 a bottle and a rating of 88 out 100 this is an excellent choice. The selection is endless and with luck and a little exploration any can discover a great tasting treasure.

For lack of time and mostly for the fact my bottle is about empty I will run through a few rums best to stay clear of. Monarch and Bacardi rum are to only be purchased in pure desperation and I recommend using the cheapest soda around to mix with and don't even bother with ice. Sailor Jerry offers a Captain Morgan like rum that lacks a little in flavor and taste, but it is decent with a splash of cola and is quite affordable. A tricky rum is Mount Gay Sugar Cane Rum; while I believe it to taste more of the gasoline sort,others I know have found it quite enjoyable, either way use extreme caution. Mount Gay does offer very good rum with Mount Gay Extra Old but it almost always has to be purchased via the internet or special ordered. In general anything that is under $20 and is not marked with the label of Captain Morgan is definitely a drink at your own risk.

Smooth sailing and following winds for ya and always remember to have ample supply of the finest rum, because you never know what island you might find yourself on.

Published by Lidon Pearce

I live with my beautiful wife and son in the state of Washington. Author of "Misadventures of the Rumonauts" and "The Rumonaut Manifesto"  View profile

4 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Havana Club1/3/2011

    The best rum is Havana Club, which is made in Cuba. All the varities are good, but I especially like the Gold. Being a cuban product, it is not allowed to be sold or imported into the US. We get Bacardi instead...what a shame.

  • Nok7/30/2010

    Really? Captain Morgan is your go to Rum? How tragic.

  • Dixie Davis11/7/2007

    My only memory of rum in my little peebrain was in my younger college aged party hearty days. I went to a river party and drank what had to have been the swill and gasoline tasting variety of the rum world, most likely bacardi's. Anyhow, I got quite drunk and on the way home in my boyfriend's VW Minibus I stuck my head out the window to puke up the nasty swill I had drank liberally and not only got the car next to us, but also the side of the VW Minibus were plastered with the unsightly mess. The next morning I felt like someone had beat me liberally with the ugly stick, but even worse than that was that the rum I puked up took all of the paint off the side of the VW Minibus where I puked all over it when my body had the good sense to reject the hideousness of my stomach contents. Now, that's just a bad sign when you puke up booze and it is so corrosive it removes paint down to the metal. It's no wonder I have never had the nerve to try rum again and it sends a deep, dark shiver d

  • Joshua Clements-Sampson6/14/2007

    Any rum flavored with fruits like coconut or pinneapple are also sure crowd pleasers, especially the ladies. Mix either with Coke and the fruitiness and Coke can disguise even the cheapest fruity rum. By the way, as your attorney I advise trying rum with Pepsi. I know it is supposed to be "rum and coke," but damn if Pepsi doesn't cover the taste of a cheap rum better than Coke. Give 'er a try and decide for yourself if I'm full of crap or not. Cheers!

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.