In the first section of the act, it is stated, "The President is authorized to establish military commissions under this chapter for offenses triable by military commission as provided in this chapter." In effect, the President is given the absolute power to determine who is and who is not an enemy combatant.
Further, the Act provides for the suspension of Habeas Corpus. Prisoners who are deemed enemy combatants can be held indefinitely without charges being prepared, or without a trial scheduled. The denial of due process is another step toward undermining the Constitution.
Step by step the Bush Administration has moved the country away from its core values. With the passage of this act, the citizens of the country are being held in the same light in which we hold our enemies. By retreating to tactics that have worked toward breaking down human rights advances, the President and its Congress have sidestepped progress.
In addition to suspending Habeas Corpus, the Act permits the use of coerced evidence in trials. After the Abu Ghraib controversy, the Guantanamo Bay allegations, and the torture debacle, one would think the Country has moved away from limiting the rights of its citizens and its enemies. By turning a blind eye to torture and accepting confessions that forcibly acquired, we have turned into the aggressor.
The act also retroactively pardons all past abuses and crimes of torture. This 'get of jail free' card gives maximum latitude to detainers and forgives crimes deemed unlawful and unethical by American and international standards. By provisioning for this pardon, Congress has set a precedent for the future of the war on terror.
Lastly, the Military Commissions Act allows the definition of torture to be decided by the chief executive. Therefore, the limitations regulations set by the Geneva Conference have been rendered a second priority. The legislation trumps all former acts that defined our obligations to prisoners, and instead paves a path for a more brutal, unethical system of jurisprudence.
With a new President and a new Congress, it is important to revisit this legislation. In order to remake our standing in the world, and effectively create international support for the elimination of extremism, we must set the standard for fair and just prosecution of our enemies.
Published by SDH
Sam Holder is a professional freelance writer. He has been published in The Tallahassee Democrat and The Association of Jewish Refugees Journal. When he is not writing he is devouring Hunter S. Thompson, eat... View profile
- The Military Commissions Act: A Torture LawThe Military Commissions Act of 2006 is unconstitutional and violates human rights.
The Military Commissions Act of 2007This article describes how the provisions of the Military Commissions Act grant the President dictatorial authority.- Amnesty International Pleads with Supreme Court to Uphold Prisoners' Rights to Hab..."The Supreme Court has twice delivered the message to the Bush administration that judicial review and civil liberties cannot be discarded."
- Habeas Corpus: Proving a Prisoner Has Been Unlawfully Detained in JailHave you ever wondered what a writ of habeas corpus is? Read on to learn more about this legal term.
- Habeas Corpus in the Criminal Court SystemHabeas Corpus is a highly debated topic in society. Habeas Corpus is a writ that calls into question whether a person whom is detained or imprisoned is being held lawfully or not.
- Habeas Corpus: Why You'll Miss it when It's Gone
- The Military Commissions Act Makes the Writ of Habeas Corpus a Thing of the Past
- Truth Behind the Military Commissions Act of 2006
- Habeas Corpus in the 21st Century
- Senate Judiciary Committee Votes to Restore Right of Habeas Corpus
- Ike Skelton (D-MO) Introduces Bill in House to Restore Habeas Corpus Rights
- We've Lost Our Right to Habeas Corpus Under the Present Administration



