The Monster Mask

Timothy Handel Murders Mother of His Children

Michele Starkey

On Wednesday evening, my husband passed several State Police vehicles and a backhoe in a parking lot just up the road. At first glance, he recalls thinking it was odd that the NY State Police would be using earth-moving equipment. We wouldn't discover until the next morning that they were working on a tip from a neighbor that something was amiss in a quiet neighborhood about 3 miles from my home in New Windsor.

New York State Police dug up the body of a 27-year-old who had been reported missing from Lancaster, Pennsylvania just a few weeks earlier. The shallow grave was in the backyard of a home that her estranged boyfriend and the father of her children had been staying at.

Timothy Handel, 39, was arrested and arraigned for the murder of Kathleen (Katie) Connolly. He is being held in Orange County jail until the grand jury can begin hearing the case on Tuesday.

Take a good look at Handel here. He looks like an ordinary fellow without any telltale signs that he could be a murderer. He grew up in New Windsor and even owned a landscaping business locally. Something went terribly wrong along the way and the monster that lurked inside of him robbed Katie's life and stole the young mother away from her two young girls, aged 2 and 3. I hate to imagine that they witnessed the crime. We may never know for sure and the children are safely tucked away with family members and out of the media spotlight.

I drove past Riley Road this morning on my way to a news assignment and paused briefly at the intersection. I wondered whether anyone on that road will ever forget what happened there.

I know I will remember Katie every time we pass Riley Road on our way to church. I will be thinking of her little girls and the man who murdered their mother.

Sources:

http://www.whptv.com/news/local/story/UPDATE-A-neighbor-speaks-about-the-missing/Np16Zxbkv0a48o08-DL8eQ.cspx

http://www.midhudsonnews.com/News/2011/August/05/Handel_arr-05Aug11.html

http://www.riverreporteronline.com/content/14/2011/08/04/state-police-montgomery-arrest-new-windsor-man-murder

Published by Michele Starkey

Optimist who enjoys writing, laughing and spreading good news. If I have but one life to live, I hope to make mine memorable. My epitaph will read: she lived, she loved, she left.  View profile

58 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Dale L Dupont8/13/2011

    Sad. If we could turn all these monsters green for a day how many shades would there be? Thought provoking.

  • rama devi (Nina Marshall)8/11/2011

    Poignant.

  • Michelle Wilhelm8/11/2011

    Yikes.

  • Linda M. McCloud8/9/2011

    Sad

  • Sherri Granato8/9/2011

    Excellent reporting on a horrible crime. Very sad.

  • Drew Taylor8/9/2011

    Very sad.

  • Delicia Powers8/9/2011

    Very sad...

  • Mike Powers8/9/2011

    An outstanding report as always. Thanks!

  • T L Wilson8/8/2011

    What a sad thing.

  • Carol Slater8/8/2011

    I feel for those little girls. It is just a reminder that we really do not know what someone else is capable of.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.