The Right Age: Dating and Maturity

Are 23-year-old Guys Too Young for 22-year-old Women?

Shalwah Evans
My friend J is going to be 24 at the end of this month. I told him that sometimes I forget that he is so young, then he says or does something silly that brings me right back. To put this in perspective, this conversation happened over AIM, which doesn't always allow you to really capture the emotion of ones words. So naturally his reaction to my statement was somewhere between confusion and possibly offense (couldn't tell, AIM). I explained to him that he is so much more mature than most 23-year-old guys. Most 22-year-old women would not want to date a 23-year-old guy because of their maturity level. I could see myself dating J, or someone with his maturity level, even if he was 23. Although he thanked me and took it as a compliment, like a true Aries, he still had to express his disagreement with my latter statement. He said, "I'll agree that they might want different things in a relationship, but I don't know if it's true that the guy isn't mature enough for the woman." Then he told me that I should do a column on it, so that he could dispute it. If I know J as well as I think I do, I know that no matter what I wrote he'd find something to dispute, even if it was one statement that was totally removed from the point of the entire article. Although I lovingly invite J's argumentative nature, and sort of enjoy our friendly endless bouts, he can't argue with the opinions of his peers. Actually, he will, but he'll be wrong.

So I asked the experts-well not experts-but men and women in their twenties from all over the country: Are 23-year-old men too young for 22-year-old women to date?

"It's on a person to person basis. I agree that women do mature faster [than men] but it depends on the person. You could have a 22-year-old woman who acts like she's 17," Ryan, 23, Yonkers NY.

"I think that like a lot of things in life, it all depends on each individual's maturity level. I would like to wish that older men are better for younger women because they are more independent, secure of themselves, mature, and as an added perk they should have more money in the bank to lavish on their young mistresses. But this could also be the case for a 24 year old guy. Hence it all depends on the person. I just don't think that it is as simple as saying someone is this age thus they act like this. But here I am as a 24 year old girl dating a 27 year old guy and I am not sure if he really has all the qualities of an older man that I just mentioned. Sometimes I feel more mature than him-or maybe just more confused," Bridget, 24, Omaha NE.

"Generally no [22 year-old-women shouldn't date 23-year-old men]. There might be an odd chance that you find a mature guy. But in general, it's a bad idea. I wouldn't do it." Kia, 23, Roselle Park NJ.

"Age is just a number, of course, but when it comes to dating there is one fundamental fact about women. The majority of women mature faster than guys, regardless of how adamantly we may argue against it. However, I will attest that if genuine interest is [there], the age is as irrelevant as their prior suitors." James Baldwin III, 27, Columbus OH.

"We all know that women mature faster than men and a 23-year-old man is simply not mature enough to date a 22-year-old woman. I suppose there could be exceptions to that rule. But 99.99% of the time, it's not going to work." Kelly, 26, Bronx NY

Published by Shalwah Evans

Born and raised in Brooklyn, Shalwah Evans grew up in a household where children were taught to speak honestly and openly about what was going on in the world. And to this day she does just that. No matter...  View profile

  • Age is an important factor in compatibility for many women.
  • Most men agree that maturity level depends on the individual.
  • No one knows the right age of compatibility for men and women.
All the women asked for comments for this article are dating, or have recently dated a man that was at least 2 years older than them.

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • clear headed7/26/2010

    older women of average or above intelligence have no business dating a man that is younger than them. Men definately take longer to mature than women. Only in rare cases do these relationships last.

  • mayflowers12/4/2009

    Yeah, I think that men and women aren't too horribly different. So, it could just depend on the person's own maturity-not gender. But it does seem like girls want relationships much sooner than boys do. However, girls do grow faster physically than boys, even up to 2 or 3 years.

  • joe6/13/2009

    So a 23 year old male should date a 18 year old girl? lol, idiots. I want to go to the mall tomorrow.Ya about that, I have a meeting on the west coast tomorrow for corporate. But can we go out tonight? Yeah but you can't drink untill 3 years from now.

  • Shalwah Evans9/14/2008

    Congrats! I should only hope that I'll be able to keep up with the younger boys when I'm in my forties. Kudos to you girl! I'm just a little scared about the 30 years younger--wouldn't that make them 17?

  • Nicole9/13/2008

    I am going to be 47 in November. I like to date 20-30 years younger.

  • Angel.W2/20/2008

    A young woman should date a man her age, that way they can experience life together. It's kindof hard to experience new things with an older man, who has already experienced most things with his ex's. Young women date men your age , so you can enjoy your life.

  • TJ7/2/2007

    This post is hopelessly overgeneralized. The author's very premise is completely off base, as she presupposes that one's age necessarily dictates how "mature" they are, and that women "always" mature faster than men. Both of these presuppositions are incredibly simplistic, and do a major disservice to both men and women alike. So, the very question "Are 23 year old guys too young for 22 year old women" is just flawed and presumptuous from the outset. It's simply a bad question that will inevitably lead only to bad answers.

  • Najma6/10/2007

    Who says in this day and age women need to date men a certain age? I know 26 year old guys more mature than some fifty year olds..and people can be mature in some ways and immature in others.

  • Nicole, 24, BX5/30/2006

    I honestly believe that a 23 year old "boy" a.k.a "young buck" is too young for a 22 year female. It is all about the maturity level. It has been proven, scientifically, that men are mentally delayed by about 5 years:) Although there are always exceptions to every rule, I think overall women need to date men at least 3-5 yrs older than them to feel mentally fulfilled, and sometimes physically fulfilled.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.