The family was on their way to the hospital where they had been told that Moats' mother-in-law was near death and that they should get their ASAP. Since the incident happened so close to the hospital Ryan made the decision to let the officer follow him at a slow speed into the hospital parking lot so his wife and other family members could get to her mother's bedside.
The tragic incident that followed was all caught on the police car's surveillance camera. The officer had some harsh words for Moats and when his wife attempted to exit the car the officer pulled a gun on her and ordered her back into the car. This all happened after Moats had explained that his mother-in-law was on her death bed and that they really needed to get to her side. The officer proceeded to verbally bash Moats and to write him a ticket, which was immediately rescinded once the police chief had looked at the tape from the camera. The chief also offered an apology to the family and placed the officer, Robert Powell, on administrative leave.
What happens next is the subject of this article. There will be many who rush to judgment on what should happen to the officer. Both racism and profiling have been mentioned in several newscasts and articles, since the officer is white. If he is found liable for damages to the family, or for profiling he should pay. That is where this story really begins.
A person takes a test, passes a physical, goes through a background check that shows nothing in their past that would prevent them from entering into the police academy. Then they go through a rigorous training program and then they pass that, maybe with flying colors, maybe with just good enough grades to pass, never the less they pass their training. Now that they are a police officer, although usually in most places they are required to train with a more experienced officer before getting their own car. Could a bad apple get through that system? Absolutely. Bad apples get through every system all the time. Take a look at what our CEOs have done and are doing to this nation's economy. They are not all bad but the bad ones will always get the media attention.
That is the case with Officer Robert Powell of the Plano Police Department. His actions as deplorable as they were, are all we will read about for the next several days, weeks and months. Sadly enough, the hundreds of thousands of good officers that put their lives on the line every day will take the biggest hit for one officer's actions. Are their any other bad ones that slipped through the cracks out there? More than likely and they will not all be white officers. Profiling is and always will be a problem, just as it is a problem in our elementary schools, middle schools, high schools and colleges. Just as it is a problem in our churches and synagogues. Racism is not just a police problem; it is a problem that should be policed in our homes, our schools and our churches.
The intention of this article is not to pass judgment on Officer Powell because, as incriminating as the evidence is against him, this could be an isolated incident in a career that can be chalked up to... having a real bad day. A day nonetheless that he should be punished for but that should not necessarily have to identify his entire career. People do make mistakes and he obviously made a huge one in judgment. If this is an isolated case for him, then punish him and hopefully he will learn from it and be a better person as a result. His superiors on the force and his fellow officers know if this is in his nature or not. They should have the ultimate say as to his future with the police department. However, if it is found that he violated Ryan Moats and his family's civil rights and that crime prevents him from serving on the force, then so be it and maybe then, someone else will learn from Officer Powell's mistake.
This situation is a lemon and lemonade needs to be made from it. One way to do that is not to cast dispersion on all police officers and not make this any larger than what it actually is. One cop who made a real bad decision at a real unfortunate time. If it was any more than that (racism), let it go through proper channels and be dealt with accordingly. Racism is a crime that should be punished and the punishment should be strong enough to serve as a deterrent. The police chief has already come out in strong opposition to what the Moats family was put through and has apologized to the family first, and then to the entire community for the officer's actions. Whether they can accept the apology or not at this point in time is strictly up to the Moats' family, as they had to endure the mistreatment and experience the loss of a family member.
In no way should this article be taken as defending one misguided police officer. However, in a time where our country is experiencing more crime than ever before, largely as the result of decisions made by our misguided CEO's and our misguided politicians, we need to all pull together. Our communities and our cities, pulling together with our police officers. Our schools with our families and our families with our churches and synagogues. We are a country that proudly proclaims, "In God We Trust." God wants that we all love each other and respect each other. Maybe this would be a good time to do just that.
Published by Frank Bacus
A church leader for 20+ years. A 30 year music industry veteran. Booked, promoted, managed and/or produced some of the biggest names in the industry including Oscar, Grammy winners. A H.S. baseball head coac... View profile
- Bad Tacoma Top Cop, David BrameA commentary on rouge cops.
- 2007 NFL Season Preview - Houston TexansFrom the Super Bowl Champions to the team with the worst records, and everyone in-between, it's time to take the annual look into the 32 NFL Teams. It's time to separate the contenders and the pretenders and everyone...
- Florida Cop Dumps Quadriplegic, 7 Ohio Cops Strip Search WomanTwo alarming stories and videos of two arrests gone terribly wrong. How should citizens respond when police can not be trusted?
- Bad ApplesThe general public has always been respectful and at the same time fearful of the police. Here is my take on why it's worse today than ever before.
Ten Plus Uses for Lemon Essential OilI have always had an appreciation for natural remedies, naturals methods of disinfecting and cleaning, and all around have an appreciation of lemon essential oil.
- NFL: Can the Philadelphia Eagles Bounce Back from a Disaster 2005 Season?
- 2006 Might Be Eagles Quarterback Donovan McNabb's Best Season yet
- 2006 NFL Season Preview: Philadelphia Eagles
- 2006 Philadelphia Eagles Preview
- Lemon Oil is Not Just for Furniture
- Eagles Made Right Choice with Buckhalter
- Lemon Balm: Versatile and Healthful Herb




7 Comments
Post a CommentI dont think it was racism. The police was jut being a bully. I have got pulled over twice by two white dallas police officers and both times they let me go with out a ticket. They both were respectable after learning that I was a disable Vet. We can not let a bad apple represent the bunch.
I hope that the Moats family, and we as a society, will take this and learn from it. Perhaps some good training for all civil servants will come from this, making a positive from a negative. We must ALWAYS try to look for a better way to do things, and stop bashing. It was a power play but we don't have to do the same thing and become bitter and sad along the way. The obvious move would be to understand that Moats' situation was important, it was confirmed, it was grave and there was nothing more important pending. Training and compasion for our fellow human beings is the lesson here. Pls call for action..for a better way.
Can anyone give me there thoughts on this series of questions, please?
Was this apology written by a PR person? It certainly sounds like it - and if it was, then that just demonstrates that Robert Powell DOES NOT GET IT.
Also, it said that he is married with a kid. Does his wife know what sort of monster he is? If not, will someone please tell her? At this point, it is important that any support base he has be taken away. He's proven that he does not care about people - and would not help them at all.
There was a post that he lived in Carrolton. Has anyone started to put together teams to protest at his house? 24 hours a day? It's really apparent from that BS apology, written by a PR person - that he DOES NOT GET IT.
"I dont get why the office didnt just follow Ryan into the hospital so he could see his mom in her last momwnts of life."
Guessing that that isn't protocol (i.e. following a suspect, even for traffic violations, into anywhere).
At that moment, the officer had no proof of anything except for someone who went through a red light and multiple stop signs.
"Even when the guard begged the cop he said no. Even when he nurse begged the cop he said no. & the cop is suspended with pay so what is his consequence?"
At that point, unfortunately, the situation had escalated. Yes, at that point, the officer should have realized there was truth to what Motes was saying. Before that, it was simply Motes' word...a 'trust me.'
Do we know for a fact that had the officer immediately let Motes go, that he would have seen his Mother-In law before she passed away? Just curious.
At this point, the only unlawful act was that of Mote's running the red light and stop signs and not stopping. An
AS of the writing of this article there had been no release as to the discrepancy of his employment. The article however, really does not focus on where anyone works. The purpose of the article is well stated. The guy was wrong and should pay whatever his penalty and that maybe more focus could be placed on the good that is done by the vast majority of our officers. Where this officer worked was really not remotely the focus nor did that have any impact on the commentary.
I dont get why the office didnt just follow Ryan into the hospital so he could see his mom in her last momwnts of life. Then after ryan saw her pass, give ryan all the tickets he felt were neccesary. That way if Ryan did anything he'd have all the hospital staff as witnesses. Even when the guard begged the cop he said no. Even when he nurse begged the cop he said no.
& the cop is suspended with pay so what is his consequence?
The Plano Police Dep. has issued a statement that the officer was NOT one of theirs.
He is in the Dallas Police Dep. More research before publishing please.