The Simpsons Beat South Park's Scientology Episode for Best Animated Series

Timothy Sexton
The Simpsons is television's longest running sitcom in history, but has never won an Emmy for Best Comedy. However, as of last night The Simpsons have won nine Emmy awards for Best Animated Series. Number nine was especially interesting as the show was poised against South Park's controversial Scientology episode that made fun of Tom Cruise. At the time it aired, Cruise still had enough clout in Hollywood to get the show pulled. After his bizarre behavior regarding his girlfriend's pregnancy, his misinformed opinions regarding the effectiveness of psychiatry and anti-depressants, and worst of all, the underperformance of Mission Impossible III, Tom Cruise is no longer quite the golden child he once was. Although certainly not experiencing the free fall that Mel Gibson is experiencing, one must doubt that simply a word from Cruise would be enough to get an episode of a television show pulled at this stage.

Al Jean, longtime Simpsons producer who accepted the award for the show last night, acknowledged the controversy when he said, "This is what happens when you don't mock Scientology." He should know. Or so goes the rumor. It has been floating around that Nancy Cartwright, the voice of Bart Simpson and a Scientologist herself, refused to read a line that, well, mocked Scientology.

The episode that earned The Simpsons their Emmy award was The Seemingly Never-Ending Story, an innovative episode that featured flashbacks within flashbacks within flashbacks. The episode featured the kind of intricate development that you don't get in shows such as Friends, Will & Grace, Ally McBeal or Everybody Loves Raymond. Each of which won a Best Comedy Emmy award the same year that The Simpsons was aired, but was never even nominated.

Published by Timothy Sexton - Featured Contributor in Arts & Entertainment

Timothy Sexton was named this site's very first Writer of the Year. Today he has several columns on Yahoo Movies and a weekly column on The Simpsons on Yahoo TV. He has published over 8,000 articles coverin...   View profile

5 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Anonymous 4/18/2008

    Fuck Scientology
    It Will Crash And Burn
    All The Innocent People Who Have Died

    Scientologist should be a shamed of there selves

  • jerald 8/21/2006

    Well done Timothy, but I think the scientology story was better. They don't look at the whole years work. Just the shows summited. If you missed the show you can see it and the other scientology shows at http://www.scientomogy.com/

  • jerald 8/21/2006

    Hi Kevin, Tom Cruise's claim that he knew the history of psychiatry is silly. He is aware of how scintology thinks about it, but if he knew any of the science of it he never would have said what he did. I noticed you listed scientology sites so I will list one also. I will also list the critic's site so everyone can see and decide for themselfs. scientology.com, xenu.net and xenutv.com

  • Kevin Owen 8/21/2006

    Timothy Sexton Wrote "his misinformed opinions regarding the effectiveness of psychiatry and anti-depressants"

    I wouldn't agree that Tom Cruise's comments on Psychiatry were mis-informed.

    The on-line Videos below may help understand why Tom Cruise speaks out about the dangerous treatments of psychiatry

    Psychiatrists admit No Science No Cures Video [4mins] http://cchr.org/uploads/video/no_science.wmv

    The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual:(DSM): A Psychiatric Hoax Video http://cchr.org/uploads/video/broadbandDSM.wmv

    Psychs False Diagnoses Online Video http://www.freedommag.tv/shows/FM-PsychsFalseDiagnoses11.wmv

    KevinOwen@rehabilitatenz.co.nz
    http://www.rehabilitatenz.co.nz

  • Matthew Lubin 8/21/2006

    I'm sorry I missed that. I'm even more sorry that I don't get any of the new episodes of Simpsons here in China. Out of all the things I could possibly miss, that is the most important.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.