The book begins with the traditional birthing methods and traditions of the Hmong people. One of the most important traditions is burying the placenta. The placenta is to be buried in a spot under the homes dirt floor so when the person dies its soul can travel back to the placenta. Lia was the fourteenth child born to the Lees'. She was their only child born in the United States. She was born in a modern hospital in California's Central Valley, where many Hmong refugees have resettled. Lia's placenta was incinerated.
The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down shows how parents are the same with the same feelings no matter what their traditions and beliefs are. They still love their children and want the best for them.
This is a very interesting book, often on the required reading list of many schools. You will learn of Hmong traditions and how they conflict with American traditions. It shows how the differences are complicated because of the understanding of each others beliefs. The language barrier is a very big part of many of the problems encountered.
I like this book and consider it a very good read, especially if you want to learn something as you and are ready for some deep thinking. It is not a quick and easy book to read but well worth the time.
Published by Sheryl Jester
I believe in the power of positive thinking. I'm a mother of 5, all grown, and I've 3 grandchildren that I spoil. Life is full of joy and I am here to live it. I am an explorer, a reader, a writer, a think... View profile
When Introverts and Extroverts Fall in Love with Each otherWhen an introvert and an extrovert become romantic partners, personality differences and lifestyle preferences can sometimes create frustration. Avoid problems by being aware of...- Eating Disorder Treatments in CaliforniaAn eating disorder can have life threatening complications. Professional treatment is essential for long-tern recovery. Find information about eating disorder treatments in California.
- You Live and You LearnThere are many questions in life that don't seem to have any answers. It seems as though the only real way to find answers to these questions is through firsthand experiences. But what do you do when the answer you ge...
- King Hospital in L.A. May CloseState regulators in southern California have decided to start the process to revoke the license of Martin Luther King Jr.-Harbor Hospital. King has had a tarnished reputation for such issues as failing federal inspect...
Famous People Born in CaliforniaRead about the success that California babies have accomplished, as adults. From Joe DiMaggio to Robert Frost, they all led (and lead) amazing lives full of accomplishment.
- A review of The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down by Anne Fadiman: The Hmong Fo...
- The Perils of Pack Reporting
- How to Start a Book Group & Book Group Discussion Tips
- Anne Fadiman's Tale Examines Cultural Differences Through Medical Philosophy
- "Slain in the Spirit": Spiritual Rapture or Social Conditioning?
- Paying Your Own Medicare Part B Premium in California
- Healthy Families: A Low-Cost Insurance Program in California




6 Comments
Post a CommentSounds like a very emotional read. I can't imagine having 14 kids!
That sounds interesting but sounds very deep. Sounds like a book you'd go back and re-read a part to get the real meaning.
Yes, understanding and misunderstanding other's traditions and beliefs do not happen easily. Understanding is almost harder than misunderstanding. Sometimes we think we understand, yet as you mention our language barrier causes just that...a barrier. It is important to keep asking, listening, learning. This sounds like a very interesting book Sheryl.
Interesting review.
Very interesting. Please excuse me if I'm not around a lot lately - I'm having a series of bad disk flare ups in my back, and must sit at computer only to do whatever articles I can, so can't spend a lot of time doing comments.
What a weird concept, burying the placenta. How do people dream these things up? Yet, they'll say other people are nuts... Ah well.