The Worst Science Fiction and Fantasy Television Shows of All Time

John J. Joex
With every best-of list, a worst-of list has to follow. I have compiled my best-of Science Fiction and Fantasy television on the Axiom's edge site along with my Top 10 list. So with the cream of the crop covered, now it is time to look at the bottom-feeders.

While you definitely face challenges in compiling a list of the best Science Fiction and Fantasy television series, amassing the worst examples of the genre presents an even more precarious endeavor. While some might disagree if you throw a show like Land of the Lost onto a best-of list, they can easily dismiss it as a matter of taste or simply an issue of not seeing eye-to-eye. However, relegate one of their cherished shows to the worst-of list and you have a fight on your hands. People get attached to a show for various reasons. Perhaps it brings back good memories, perhaps it was their first foray into the genre, or perhaps they just like it, no matter the quality. There is no accounting for taste, and if somebody likes a show, you had better not disrespect it.

With this in mind, I am still going forward with the list while also knowing full well that some of the shows on my worst-of list are on many others' best-of list. And I admit there are probably several shows that are not on this list that should be like The Man from Atlantis, Manimal, Automan, etc., but it's been a while since I have seen any of these so I will hold off until I get a chance to revisit them. In the meantime, here's the list presented in reverse order from least worst to worst. Feel free to ravage it and present your own. (Go to the Axiom's edge site for my full survey of the best and worst of Science Fiction and Fantasy television.)

7. Space: 1999 (1975) - This re-imagining of the Star Trek format from former Supermarionation guru Gerry Anderson threw science out the window as it attempted to make grandiose, self-important statements. By the second season it had devolved into little more than threadbare plots that presented some excuse for an alien menace to run amok on Moonbase Alpha.

6. Wonder Woman (1975) - This combination of cleavage and mind-numbing stories probably set back the Women's movement a decade or two.

5. Battlestar Galactica (197 - This series could have revitalized the Science Fiction and Fantasy genre on television the way Star Wars did for the big screen. Instead, we got hackneyed scripts delivering "family-friendly", grandiose statements with cute kids and cuddly robots thrown in for good measure.

4. Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea (1964) - Started out as a high-tech espionage thriller then quickly devolved into the crew of the Seaview vs. such absurdities as werewolves, evil leprechauns, lobster men, and killer toys.

3. Buck Rogers in the 25th Century (1979) - It started out as a tongue-in-check romp then did a 180 and decided that it had something serious to say. Lesson of the day: if you have bad scripts, it's much better not to take yourself too seriously.

2. Galactica: 1980 (1980) - ABC decided they made a mistake pulling the plug on Battlestar Galactica and quickly attempted to reboot the series. Then they discarded the few redeeming qualities of the original and turned the sequel into a mindless kid's show. Even fans of the original Galactica are hard-pressed to come to this one's defense.

1. Lost in Space (1965) - This bombastic, camp romp embodied the worst excesses of the Science Fiction and Fantasy genre and the television medium in general. Do I even need to mention the giant, talking carrot episode to convince you that this show deserves its place on this list?

Other shows considered for the list

Published by John J. Joex

Author. Fan of Science Fiction and Fantasy television. Fan of food.  View profile

2 Comments

Post a Comment
  • StuOz9/13/2009

    Voyage to the Bottom of the Sea and Lost In Space were more screen comic strips than sci-fi or fantasy. Granted Voyage/Sea season one had some full on sci-fi - "The Sky Is Falling", etc - but the bulk of the series, the colour seasons, were more rooted in up-dating Republic movie serials for the tv screen, complete with a cliff-hanger before each ad-break. Voyage/Sea and Lost In Space are some of the greatest hours of tv ever made!

  • Will N. Stape9/17/2008

    As a writer for Star Trek: The Next Generation & Deep Space Nine, I'm glad my shows didn't make the list - WHEW! ; ) As for Space: 1999, I'll agree it wasn't great, & it devolved by season two, however Catherine Schell as Maya - in both performance & overall character was a fine addition. They just ditched everything remotely good to focus on her & took away her Psychon "mystique" in ways. Also - especially in the first season - Space:1999 at times felt like a Hammer Horror movie. Spooky sets with scary lighting & creatures - certainly isn't hard core sci-fi - but the departure at times worked - but it never truly found a groove. In Europe - for many reasons of course - the show is much more respected.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.