Unsolicited Advice
During my first postpartum trip to the grocery store an older woman asked how old my baby was. Her response made me uncomfortable. "You're taking her out already?!" with eyebrows raised. I only shrugged, suddenly uncertain. Was I a bad mom for taking my infant to the store with me? I had read seven whole books on childcare and took a class, but no one ever mentioned a truly correct age at which a baby may travel. I didn't even consider that it could be dangerous. I needed groceries and I wasn't going to leave my baby at home! "You're taking her out already?" Well, yes, as you can see...
Different people have different opinions about every aspect of infant care. For instance, parents who are more afraid of germs will keep their babies home more. Most of the unsolicited advice I have received reflects the fears of other people. I have been told to be careful in so many ways, such as how I hold her, to watch her neck, watch her arms. But such comments only make me more awkward. When my baby and I are alone we can gracefully listen to each other's needs. When there are other people involved it is too confusing and difficult to find that peaceful balance.
Sometimes a friend, family member or stranger will offer to translate my baby's needs for me. This is something that I, as a mother, can find insulting. I don't mean to be defensive, but this particular baby and I have spent nine months together before she was even born, and every moment since then. No one can know her better than I. Maybe your child made a certain gesture when filling his diaper, but I know mine is just stretching. "She's hungry," I'm told, but I know she's only comforting herself with her fingers; she just finished eating right before you got here. "She's cold," I am told, but I just took off a layer because she was hot.
Scary Stories
Before my baby was born I didn't notice so many stories of child abduction, neglect and murder. But the media is full of it, and now some people think that I would be especially interested to know these stories, and how unsafe the world can be. Hearing the latest crime against a child in our society, it becomes hard to trust anyone.
"It takes a village to raise a child", but our networks are so complex and spread out that face-to-face interactions are almost unnecessary. Many of my baby's clothes and toys were made by people with manufacturing jobs far away whose faces I've never seen. I can't count all of the people who were involved in the making and distributing of a single one of my baby's diapers. It would be possible to order everything we need online and never see another person. However, I like to bring my baby into public. It seems to make people happy to see a person so brand new.
Seeing a new mother with her baby might inspire you to cross the heavy personal boundaries of a fearful society. Please do say hello. Thank the new mother for helping to continue the human race. Wish her luck. But, please don't scare her with horror stories, and be sure any advice you wish to give is presented with the non-judgmental kindness a new mother needs.
Published by Amanda Farrell
In a cabin in the Connecticut woods with my little family. View profile
- How to Handle Unsolicited Parenting AdviceTired of hearing unwanted parenting advice? Try these tips to handle it gracefully.
Post-Partum Depression: What 'Not' to Say to a New Mom with the 'Baby Bl...Post-partum depression and baby blues affect not only new parents, but also the extended family, leaving them unsure what to say or do. If you know a new mom coping with the blu...- The Worst Things to Say to a Kid About DivorceThe worst things you can say to your kids during your divorce and some better options to help them through it.
- What to Say to and Do for Those Who Are Caretakers for Seriously Ill Loved OnesYou may wish to assist a friend who is a caretaker but don't know how to help. Here are several things anyone can do.
- What NOT to Say to an Expectant MomSilly and inappropriate comments you should avoid saying to a mother to be.
- How to Handle Unsolicited Advice About Parenting and Pregnancy
- Unsolicited Advice for Those About to Enter College
- Unsolicited Advice for College Freshmen
- Some Unsolicited Advice to the Republicans
- Unsolicited Advice for the New Parent
- Dealing with Unsolicited Parenting Advice
- Handling Unsolicited Comments on the Job





3 Comments
Post a CommentBWAH HA HA!
This is great! However, being on the OTHER side, I just as much hate the 'You don't understand because you're not a parent' especially when that comment precedes something stupid like "you only SAY you won't beat your kids, but you don't understand because you don't have your own"...
That was probably on your slightly longer list of what not to say to a new mother...huh? oops, sorry. ^_^
New mother's are often touchy about their new responsibilities and worries :)
I agree - if people cannot say encouraging things, they should not say anything at all! cheers :)