Thousands of Individuals and City of New Orleans to Sue Army Engineers Over Levee Breaks

Lawsuits Claim the Corps of Engineers was Negligent and Responsible for Destruction After Katrina

Eric Fleming
President George Bush visited the Gulf Coast on Thursday, touring rebuilt homes in a neighborhood still devastated by Hurricanes Katrina and Rita. He then met with area mayors at the Biloxi City Hall. This is President Bush's 14th visit to the Mississippi coast since the hurricane 18 months ago, an average of slightly less than once per month. His visit came on the same day that thousands of private citizens, and the city of New Orleans, sued the Army Corps of Engineers, which was responsible for building and maintaining the system of levees surrounding New Orleans. The suit claims it was negligence on the part of the Corps that ultimately let to the massive destruction the city has seen.

The city's lawsuit was not timed to coincide with Bush's visit, according to New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin's spokesman, Jerry Ross. "We did not time the announcement of our filing of form SF-95 to coincide with anything," he said late Thursday to the Times-Picayune. "There were absolutely no motives connected to the timing of the announcement."

Also giving notice of intent to sue were two utilities companies, Entergy New Orleans, the city's electrical utility, which is seeking $655 million in damages, and the New Orleans Sewerage & Water Board, which put in a claim of about $460 million, said a spokesmen for the agencies.

"I fully understand that there are frustrations, and I want to know the frustrations," Bush said at a lunch with local and state officials regarding the rebuilding effort. "To the extend we can help, we'll help." He added that the "federal government's role has been to write checks," and that the state government's duty is "to expedite the federal money to the local folks. I told the people that I would work with Congress to write a $110 billion check for the people of Louisiana and Mississippi, and that check has been written."

State and local officials, moreso in Louisiana than in Mississippi, have been harshly criticized for not transferring federal money to local homeowners more expediently. Of the initial $110 billion set aside for rebuilding, roughly $86 billion has been reserved for specific purposes, but only $53 billion has actually been spent.

"There is money in the pipeline," President Bush said. "If it is stuck because of unnecessary bureaucracies, our responsibility at the federal, state and local level is to unstick it."

President Bush said that one purpose of his visit was "to tell the people here in the gulf Coast that we still think about them in Washington." This may have been a response to some, like Louisiana Democrat Mary Landrieu, who thought it was a "glaring omission," that President Bush did not mention the recovery in his January 23rd State Of The Union address.

In Mississippi, President Bush met with Nellie Partridge, 84, who sat on her Long Beach porch awaiting the president's arrival.

"What a pleasure, one of my favorite people," she said as President Bush arrived. Partridge lives in one of roughly a half dozen homes that have been rebuilt with federal grand and loan money.

That sentiment would likely not be mirrored by one of the thousands of private residents who also alerted the Corps of their intent to sue. So clogged around the Corps offices were the streets that at one point during the day, ten Corps employees, dressed in bright orange vests, were standing in front of the building, collecting forms. According to a Corps spokesman, they have received enough of the forms to fill an 8 x 10 room.

Sources:

www.nytimes.com/2007/03/02/washington/02bush.html
www.montereyherald.com/mld/montereyherald/news/nation/16814259.htm
www.nola.com/news/t-p/frontpage/index.ssf
www.nola.com/news/t-p/metro/index.ssf

Published by Eric Fleming - Featured Contributor in Technology

I've worn many work hats. I've worked as a choir director and piano instructor. I've worked in a computer lab and a bookstore. I've sold sheet music, band instruments and guitars. I have managed a Google...  View profile

6 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Eric Fleming3/2/2007

    Not sure if the comment system accepts links, but I'll try anyway...
    I found this article informative: http://www.nola.com/newslogs/tpupdates/index.ssf?/mtlogs/nola_tpupdates/archives/2006_08_25.html#176174

  • T.H.Pankey3/2/2007

    editing comment below to read-...and re-reading (your) comments...

  • T.H.Pankey3/2/2007

    In all fairness-after coming back and re-reading our comments, Rhonda and Eric I can see that each of you were trying to be as objective as possible. Therefore if you're actually interested, my advice is get better informed.

  • T.H.Pankey3/2/2007

    Rhonda you're right you certainly don't know enough deatils to assert very much of anything. And Eric, thank you for the write up but you need a lesson in history as it relates to the founding of this New Orleans and this country. News flash for you both the corps has everything to do with it.

  • Eric Fleming3/2/2007

    I definitely hear where you're coming from. Personally, I think it's a little crazy to live in drained swampland that's surrounded on all sides by water that needs to be held back. Doesn't seem like a safe place to live in my mind. And I'd have to do more research about the supposedly faulty levees, to tell you the truth. From everything I heard, a great deal of the initial flooding took place when the rush of water was too tall and just went right over the levees. But... I've also heard that the area stayed flooded so long because the levees failed to drain properly. So... got me. :-)

  • Rhonda J. Rains3/2/2007

    I'm not sure of all the details but if the City knew that the levees would not hold up to anything over a Cat 3 I believe it was and they had been warned many times by scientists, meteorologists and other experts and ignored it and didn't do anything to ensure a better system was built then how can they sue? The city government may very well be the ones who are responsible for this. I however do not know the details on who provided funding for the system etc so I can for sure make an absolute opinion on this matter. Was it the U.S. Government that was responsible for funding and ensuring it would hold up? And just imagine hurricane season is just around the corner again :(

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.