Three Serious Problems with the Current Educational System
A Gifted Students Take on the Problems Associated with the Current Structure and Ideals of Our Educational System in the United States
One critical problem with the current system is the focus. The goal of secondary school is to prepare college bound students for college on the intellectual level and to get other students ready to be place directly into the work force. Based on the school districts actions, most would think the goal of high school is to keep students busy. The normal school day is 6 hours. I'd say I only am being educated for around 2 hours. Teachers spend far too much time assigning busy work. Work that requires no real thought, and teaches no real lesson. Most teachers will say that they do not assign busy work; well then what is this 2 page long worksheet that is being collected once class ends although we are having a test in the near future. Shouldn't my grade on this upcoming test convey enough to my teacher that I know the content? Yes, it should.
Another imperative problem that needs addressing is homework. Yes, homework is unnecessary. Why? If I am assigned to read 10 pages of text, then answer some review questions, what does it prove? That I am indeed able to copy answers and definitions word for word from a text directly in front of me? The student should be in charge of how much reviewing he has to do. If I take two 100-point tests and I get a 90 average on those two, then I get 0 out of 100 possible homework points, I will then end up with a 60% average. I didn't do homework because I felt I knew the content well enough as it was that I didn't need to review and do homework. Why if I prove on 2 separate occasions that I know 90% of the content taught do I have to prove that I can copy answers from my friends before class? Is it right for a student who has proved to the teacher several times that he knows 90% of the content to end up with a failing grade? The answer is no, it is not right. The system needs to be corrected.
Yet another crucial problem is the current attendance laws. If I can go to school 4 out of every 5 days of school and still be passing all my classes, then why are the numbers of absences I am able to have controlled? I understand that possibly the school district is trying to instill a sense of commitment to the students, maybe preparing them for work in later life. However if I complete everything my boss asks me to do in less then the time I have to do it, then why must I stay? Its like if you're asked to help the boss do inventory, but you are so good at it that you do a good job, in 4/5 of the time allotted. Would the boss not let you leave early if that is all this required of you? The answer is he clearly would, and the school district needs to realize things like this. They need to stop treating high school students (especially 18 year old seniors, who even in the legal sense are adults) like children that need babysitting.
These are just three of the more vital problems with the educational system. They all basically rely around student performance. If it's not necessary then why have it? If a student is intelligent enough to pass a test without doing class work or homework then why are they necessary. A similar problem arises during midterms and finals. I am one of those kids who finish a test in like 1/4th of the time allotted. I finish a midterm in 30 minutes, however I am forced to stay in my seat doing nothing for another hour before I am allowed to leave. I am essentially being held hostage. If I can tell the proctor upon completing the test in 30 minutes that I have done this test to my fullest potential and that no amount of time sitting and pondering will make me change any of my answers or add anything to them they why can't I leave early? The U.S. School system has become a terrible place. I, am academically talented student (as rated by my IQ scores from 7th grade), have roughly a "C" average for my GPA. If they could somehow find my test GPA it is damn near 4.0. Now doesn't that say something? That I have the intelligence and knowledge to get basically an "A" average on all my tests, and thus have proved that I know 90% of the content ever taught to me. However, due to the fact I didn't feel it necessary to do feeble and useless homework and class work that I felt would in no way enrich me, I now have a "C" average. It's not right. Apparently the school is telling me I am stupid (by giving me a 2.5 GPA) despite the fact that I proved I know roughly 90% of all content taught to me. The solution: it's simple. Nothing but tests, serious projects, and essays should be required. The student is intelligent enough to choose for himself how much he studies, how much he reviews and how many practice problems he needs to do in order to achieve a satisfactory grade. There is no such thing as a poor test taker, just a poor student. The test is the ultimate way to decipher based on a student's performance how much of the information preached they have mentally obtained. A single quarter of school should consist of maybe 5 tests, thus to give no one test too much power. Is it necessary to give homework every night to try and get your students to practice 30 questions when perhaps this one particular student needs no practice whatsoever in order to achieve a satisfactory grade on the upcoming test? No it is not necessary and thus should be eliminated from the curriculum. Over the past 4 years I have done something I believe to be quit remarkable, I have never studied for a test, not one test (this includes midterms and finals). I have never done homework at home. Any and all academic work (besides major projects and major essays) I have completed during school hours. That includes this very essay. This is how school should be. School should not be a take home job, it should be like a job where you punch the clock when you get there and you punch it when you leave and never bring your work home with you. I understand that not all people would be able to deal with this kind of schooling, but I assure there are many besides me who could. We currently attend a school where people get kicked out of honors for "behavior" reasons (these students with behavior problems never got 1 detention or any type of disciplinary action) despite the fact they have a B+ average in the class (mind you, the minimum grade required to stay in honors track is B-). The very same school where people get rejected from moving into honors because it is "full". Shouldn't the student body decide how many people are in the honors track? If the honors track is "full" then perhaps we need more honors teachers, or less low track ones. Now what does this mean about me? That I have above average intelligence? That I have poor work ethic? Some teachers may say so; I say that I actually have a superior work ethic and that I just get work done in a fraction of the time most need. If asked many of my peers, the ones that know me, will tell you I will be highly successful in life. Some have told me they believe I will be a millionaire. Now would they think this about someone who has poor work ethic? That doesn't follow directions? That doesn't complete all assignments? No, they believe this because I have justification for every decision I make and because I am right.
My name is Joseph Norton and I urge for educational system reform.
Published by Michael Holt
Married 23 year old, just graduated college with a BBA in Economics and I am moving to Eugene Oregon to find a home with my wife! View profile
- System of a Down Breaks Through with Another Hypnotizing Album! HypnotizeSystem Of A Down is back again with their latest release Hypnotize debuting at number one on the billboard 200! This is the second album in a two-album set that interlock musically and artistically.
- Will the No Child Left Behind Act Solve Problems with Our Education System?As our economy changes, is our educational system changing with it? Is the No Child Left Behind Act a detriment to our public educational system? Some say it is and some say the federal government needs out of education.
- Buying Guide: Philips HeartStart Home Defibrillator SystemWith the increase of heart disease and heart attack-related injury, you may need extra measures to ensure heart safety. The Philips HeartStart Home Defibrillator System is the first over-the-counter system that may h...
- Students Being Called for Active DutyAll twenty-nine ECSU students who enlisted for active duty have been called out to serve our country in the war against terrorism.
- For Home Security, Get an Alarm System!An alarm system can save you property and your life
- Female Circumcision in the United States
- An Evolving Democracy: The United States
- An Overview of the Non Profit Sector in the United States
- Great Inventions Courtesy of the United States Government
- An Analysis of the United States Oil Policy and OPEC
- A Patriot's History of the United States
- Human Body's Circulatory System




48 Comments
Post a CommentI am a senior in high school, and though it may seem like I’m agreeing only because I’m a lazy kid who wants to do nothing all the time, that assumption is wrong. I agree whole heartedly with every point you've made and I understand where you’re coming from. I think our education system needs to find a way to fit the needs of the individual student rather than group all of them as one type of student. And as far as your grammatical errors that everyone felt the need to point out, it's not that big of a deal, we're human, we make mistakes. Every person who remarked on your errors has made errors at some point in their lives, don’t let their negativity get to you and don’t let your opinions waiver, they are great!
I am at school right now, I feel time is being wasted
i disagree
i would say the education in your country is too much regulated. why not a student have a free choice to learn what he/she likes and the regulator just give a cognitive test to issue a diploma for them. in this internet era who need to waste money and time to go some school procedure. in the east many parents still think that education is a home affair and not rely too much on teacher. and believe me in the east somebody can be rich without too much schooling. hope you understand my english.
your story give me much wonder - truly - never think that i did happened in usa - well, i thought it was a free country
treating a gifted brain and a non-gifted brain in the same basket (or rule) is surely un-natural, un-productive as well - it is like forcing someone left-handed to eat with his right hand
i myself lately helping high-school students here as a tutor for a living - some students are smart - some are dumb - some are just ignorant - but of course i would not treat them the same treatment to know math - physics - chemistry - some of them are just happy to pass what their teachers need - after all as a tutor i have to make everybody happy
i think your comments on usa education is rather self-centered - however i see you had some points - my country education always following your system - figuring that your system is great - i am stressing on system rather than individual achievement
if i had to say something - i would say your education is too much regulated -
The educational system in the U.S. does need a lot of reforming. I just graduated a charter high school that I attended for two years of my high school career. This article does have serious flaws, but at least the author is speaking out. We need reform and we need it fast. I don't care about the U. S. losing it's pace with the other countries, as politicians worry about. I worry about the kids that are growing up in a system that holds them back, because others cannot be "left behind." I worry about the kids that will never fully acknowledge their potential because of teachers that just put in movies. (My Spanish class was a lot of Disney movies in Spanish, my World History was History Channel documentaries, etc.) We need schools that stray away from the normal and teach with innovative methods. A one-size-fits-all system will not work for a 21st century population. But it is not just the teacher's responsibility. It starts with the parent's of this nation an
You listed the problems with education as "busywork", "homework", and "attendance".
Wow buddy get a clue. If you want the education system to prepare you the workforce, I'd say they are doing a great job. Guess what, 99% of time spent at work is busy work. If you don't show up, you don't get paid. And guess what you get to do when you get home? Pay bills, fill out job applications, and compute your tax bill. (Sounds like homework to me!)
Get a clue, or go back to special ed!
I see your point, but not all student are as intelligent as you say you are, Some don't have your drive. Also since you sound like smart person, sometimes you need to just "play the game" so to speak. You sound kind of lazy to me. just because you don't need to do all that work doesn't mean someother student don't. also you could have just done the extra work I need all the work you say you didn't.
a simple solution to make education less complicated A mother who brings together the proper ingredients and work with them in the right way is successful in bakilg a good cake.Stop blaming the teachers .The problem is our young people don't have the proper ingredients to grasp their attention and focus an the task at hand.for more information visit learning http learning simplified .net
I agree that the education system needs to be reformed, but you offer very little persuasion. Your best idea was your first idea. Your other ideas are poorly presented and seem extremely self-centered.
On a side note, kudos to those who commented about the author's poor grammar while at the same time being unable to capitalize your sentences or show proper grammar. What happened to 'lead by example'? I smell anonymous hypocrites...