This thought-provoking question was posted by a student studying the classics. The character in question was featured in several Greek tragedies including plays by Sophocles and Euripides.
Antigone: Antigone is the inbred daughter of Odysseus and his mother Jocasta, and the sister to Polynices and Eteocles. When her brother Polynices is killed while engaged in the dishonorable pursuit of over-throwing the other brother Eteocles, the new king Creon denies Polynices the honor of a proper burial.
The conflict of the play emerges when Antigone expresses her wish to bury Polynices with a proper ceremony.
Odysseus is dead at this point, the great blind prophet has left the scene and the new guy, Creon, now sits on his throne. Creon denies Antigone's request for a proper burial ceremony on the grounds that Polynices does not deserve the honor. Creon is exceedingly scrupulous and feels that his scruples and the scruples of the people won't allow for such a burial. It would be bad politcs and bad form.
Antigone pleads and begs and threatens and is not given her way, so she kills herself. Her lover, the son of the king, also kills himself.
The facts of Polynices's dishonor are debatable and his bloodline is indeed noble. Antigone feels she was wrongly denied. She feels also that her brother is wrongly denied. Antigone is denied justice because the new king insists on his scruples.
The lack of respect by the new king is the enactment of Antigone's injustice but it is not necessarily the root of it. She and her brother were born into misfortune, quite literally, through no fault of their own. And so to be denied justice, denied mercy, and to have done nothing wrong to deserve the treatment she receives, for Antigone is too much to accept.
She rebels and kills herself. This, as the play imparts, is her fate. She can do nothing but rebel against an unjust king and make known the wounds she and her family have suffered.
*
What figure from the 20th century or in today's world can match this scenario? Who has been denied justice and forced to beg at the knees of the king for something that should be a common right? Whose plea has been rejected by the powers-that-be in his or her time of need?
Who is today's Antigone?
*
The response I posted on "Yahoo! Answers" was Pat Tillman's mother. She is today's Antigone.
Pat Tillman was a professional football player in the NFL who felt it was his duty to enlist in the US armed services. Tillman turned down a reported $3.6 million dollar contract offer from his team, the Arizona Cardinals, to enlist in the army.
He was killed in Iraq in 2004 by friendly fire.
The United States government has officially refused to admit that Pat Tillman was killed by friendly fire, despite the constant and unceasing attempts of Mrs. Tillman to evoke the admission. She tirelessly campaigned for years toward that end - for justice, for truth, for the proper respect for her son's death.
It was not until 2007 that US military personnel released reports stating that Pat Tillman was "suspected" of being killed by friendly fire.
*
What do you think is the best answer to the question: Who is today's Antigone?
sources:
Published by Eric Martin
Eric Martin is an artist and writer. Look for more of his work in The Stone Hobo, the Antelope Valley Anthology, The Open Doors Poetry Zine, Failure of Theory, Euclid's Negatives and on stage. He is an owner... View profile
- Ruth and Antigone: A Different Kind of HeroConcrete examples of why a hero doesn't always have to be the strongest man who rises up to cut off the head of a people's oppressor. A hero can act on what they think is right, no matter the circumstances, thus posi...
- The Hero: A Reshaping of the WordToday's culture portrays the typical hero as some buff guy taking on an army by himself and coming out victorious. I think heroes should not be defined by how powerful they can become, but by their will to sacrifice...
- How to Increase Your Social Networking Obsession with Yahoo AnswersYahoo! Answers welcomes thousands of questions in various lifestyle categories, bringing forth a new dimension in social networking.
5 Reasons to Use Yahoo Answers for Your Income Tax QuestionsYahoo Answers can be very useful in finding answers to your income tax questions. Now that the income tax season has started, Yahoo Answers is a quick and cost effective way to...- Yahoo Answers - the Newest Internet AddictionYahoo Answers is my most recent internet addiction, and is quite an interesting concept. Some ask, some answer, and everyone gets rewarded by a point system. Odd? Maybe, but it's catching on...
- Antigone by Sophocles: The Perfect Hegelian Tragedy
- Thoughts of Antigone, the Greek Tragedy Play
- Dispute Over Burial of James Brown Finally Resolved
- Antigone: How Does Her Dilemma Compare in Today's Society?
- The Crisis of Devotion in Antigone
- Sophocles Rhetoric Justification of Antigone
- Essay on Antigone





2 Comments
Post a CommentYou are correct, Kate. I realized this mental bubble/mistake after the article had gone up.
Many apologies to anyone who was confused by that snafu.
Antigone is the daughter of Oedipus, not Odysseus.