#5- Time After Time. The original song was sung by Cyndi Lauper in 1983 and the cover was done by the band Quietdrive in 2006. Lauper is a new wave/pop artist, while QuietDrive is known as a rock/alternative rock band. The cover version is different than the original, but it is done really well and takes nothing away from the classic 80's song. Click here to hear the cover version.
#4- Personal Jesus. The original was sung by the quintessential 80's electro pop/new wave band, Depeche Mode. The 1989 song was inspired by the book written by Priscilla Presley called, "Elvis and Me". It has been covered by many artists, but my pick for the best genre-crossing cover goes to Marilyn Manson and his 2004 gothic rock/metal version of Personal Jesus. Click here for Manson's version of the song.
#3- 99 Red Balloons. Original version performed in German in 1983 and English in 1984 by German pop singer Nena. The cover song was done by a ska/punk band called GoldFinger. This is one of the best genre-crossing covers I've ever heard. They sing most of it in English, but throw in a few lyrics in German as well, and it really works. GoldFinger covered the song in 2000 and you can click here to hear their version of 99 Red Balloons.
#2- Careless Whispers . The original was by Wham featuring George Michael in 1984. Wham was a pop/disco band, while the band that covered the song in 2009, Seether, is a South African alternative metal band. Seether remade the song as a joke, and the "joke" turned into the song that put them on the map in America. It is an excellent genre-crossing cover version of Careless Whispers, still slow, but very different than the original. Hear it by clicking here.
#1- Nothing Compares 2 U. The original song was just a B-side song by R&B pop star Prince in 1985. I loved the original but most people never heard it. Then, in 1990 a young singer named Sinead O'Connor made the song a #1 hit. O'Connor sang her alternative rock/ folk version of Nothing Compares 2 U and became an overnight sensation. It is still my favorite genre-crossing cover song of all time. I do suggest that if you have not heard Prince's version, you click here, because it's pretty darn good too!
Published by Sherri Thornhill
I am a retired Police Officer and a professional freelance writer. I enjoy writing about a variety of topics. In addition to Yahoo Voices, I write for Examiner.com as the National Generation X Examiner, the... View profile
- The Top 5 Genre-Crossing Cover SongsCover songs, many times a watered down, castrated version of the original. Occasionally a song jumps across genres and a new version is born that respects the original but adds something new. Here is my list of the to...
- Cover Songs that Blow the Original AwayClassic cover songs that blow the original versions away.
The Greatest Cover Songs Found in YouTube VideosVideos of the best cover songs of the past 25 years, including a Cowboy Junkies cover of The Velvet Underground. - 4 Coffee House Cover Songs that No One Should Ever Do AgainHere's a look at four cover songs that have been bastardized by inept singers and coffeehouse crooners, and should never be covered again under any circumstances.
- A Few Cover Songs that Work Despite ThemselvesA short look at a few cover songs that are radically different than their original versions, and why they work despite the radical changes
- Top 5 Genre Crossing Cover Songs
- Top 10 70's Cover Songs
- Top 10 Cover Songs: Covering the Original
- Top Ten Cover Songs of All Time
- Top Ten Rock Cover Songs
- Best Cover Songs by a Rock Band
- The Playlist: Cover Songs





11 Comments
Post a CommentFun list here! I love a good cover.
Great list, Sherri!!
I'll have to check them out:)
Oh, yeah, I know that group Meredith is talking about too! I love them! They titled the song, "We're in an American Band" as "We're in a Parody Band" and their "Play that Funny Music" is a take on "Play that Funky Music". But they do a mean Led Zepplin and Mick Jagger too.
If you want to hear a group that can sound like any top group ever recorded, check out the Apologetix group and their Paradise Demo. They change the words and title but the music is identical...and their voices match those of the lead singers for whatever song they are singing!
nice list!
Love this topic Sherri! Good choices, too!
The 1980's produced some good music -- enjoyed this piece and learned a lot, too!
There's nothing like the original.
I had no idea that Prince first recorded 'Nothing Compares' ~ I cannot imagine enjoying it without Sinead O'Connor's voice! Thanks for sharing all these tune remakes! Fun musical memories all around.