Top 5 Reasons Steroids in Major League Baseball are OK

Ryan Norris
We've heard every argument imaginable for the elimination of steroids in Major League Baseball. The speculation over possible steroid users in America's favorite past time has been rampant. The U.S. Congress has even stepped in on behalf of MLB to put a stop to steroid usage. But let's suppose for a moment that steroid usage could have good qualities or for once not actually be the reason for our displeasure with baseball's current state. The top five reasons steroids aren't baseball's problem are:

5. Baseball needs stars. Steroids make better players in some regard, so why can't Major League Baseball embrace that and use it to its advantage? With football taking over as sport of favor in America, the MLB needs star power to attract more fans. After the baseball labor strike in the mid-1990's, America was reluctant to return to the sport deemed to be "America's favorite past-time." The Summer of 1998 was a remarkable chase for Roger Maris' single season homerun record of 62, which undoubtedly renewed our love for baseball. But some conjecture that without steroids the Summer of 1998 wouldn't have been possible. But why shouldn't we embrace the cause of one of baseball's greatest stretch instead of viewing it as a negative. Some may argue that the Summer of 1998 was artificial, yet something was so real and captivating about the experience and we should relish the greatness of those moments instead of scrutinizing them.

4. Shorter fences are the reason for increased power numbers. The general public has a consensus that steroids are the reason for the increase in power numbers. But is that really the case? Any knowledgeable fan should be able to determine for themselves that the shorter fences in the new generation of ballparks are the reason for the balloon in power statistics. One of baseball's most famed ballparks the Polo Grounds, which had a short porch in leftfield, had one of the largest outfield areas ever because of its 483 ft. centerfield wall. Also, baseball has expanded to areas such as Denver, Colorado where the ball flies farther due to the mile-high atmosphere. Coors Field in Denver is single-handedly increasing the numbers in the National League. So it's easy to blame steroids for the increased power numbers, but take a look elsewhere first.

3. Baseball players have always been cheaters. Steroids aren't the first form of "cheating" in baseball, and they won't be the last. The earliest forms of cheating bring to mind the infamous 1919 Chicago Black Sox scandal with Shoeless Joe Jackson. Baseball is a game of winning at any cost. Cheaters have long since prospered and been accepted. Who's to say that the Yankees didn't pay opposing pitchers to lob fat pitches down the middle to Babe Ruth? That most likely didn't happen but if it had, wouldn't that be just as bad as the steroids scandals these days. Baseball is a game where stealing signs is considered gamesmanship, so why shouldn't steroids just be considered to be the same. If some cheating is acceptable, all cheating is acceptable.

2. Less injuries is a good thing. If there is one fact about steroids, it's that recovery time for those taking steroids is significantly decreased. So if the best aspect of steroids is decreased recovery time, why are we complaining? Who doesn't want to see your favorite player out on the diamond every night? No one likes to see their favorite player "on the shelf" for long periods of time. Take for instance Ken Griffey Jr. who has spent the better part of the latter half of his career on the disabled list. Junior was once poised to take on the massive homerun record of Hank Aaron, but injuries have long since derailed that bid. Had steroids been used for medical reasons in his case, we may well have seen the greatest player ever.

1. Strength doesn't equal bat speed. Steroids are rumored to increase strength and homerun power, but could this be a myth? Any one who has ever hit a homerun, whether it be at the Little League level, the high school level, or even the professional level, knows that homerun power doesn't come from brute strength alone. Bat speed is the essential element to the power stroke. Most players have the necessary hand-eye coordination to hit a baseball, but yet most don't hit for power. For example, Seattle Mariners outfielder Ichiro Suzuki is a master at putting the ball in play, who has more hits than anyone in the MLB over the past five seasons, yet his power numbers aren't significant. On the other hand, some of the greatest power hitters of all time have also topped the strikeout lists. The sole reason for homeruns is bat speed, not brute strength, so can steroids really help hitters that much? If we conclude that bat speed is the necessary component to a homerun, then the answer is probably not.

Published by Ryan Norris

I enjoy sports and simply cannot get enough. I constantly share and debate opinions on all matters. I write articles to express those same debates in a more diverse forum.  View profile

  • Bat speed is everything, not strength added by steroids.
  • Steroids reduce recovery time, which means your favorite player can play more.
  • Smaller ballparks are to blame for increased power statistics.
The 2006 book Game of Shadows claims that current homefun king Barry Bonds has used performance enhancing drugs.

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Edward Olson6/29/2011

    I appreciate the intellectual exercise here, but you neglect to address the strongest argument against steroids. Namely, they are incredibly destructive to the human body and mind. No athlete should feel they have to harm their health to be competitive. This is especially true for the male adolescent. His brain's capacity for risk assessment has not fully developed; he feels indestructible.

    Also, your argument about bat speed is misinformed. Steroids don't just increase brute strength; they also increase speed and the firing of fast twitch muscles. A major factor in Bonds' historic numbers.

    Still, look @ where we draw a line between what's considered ok performance enhancement & "cheating." Living at altitude increases the blood's capacity to carry oxygen, a great benefit to endurance athletes. No one says living @ altitude is cheating, but what about sleeping in a tent that simulates the low oxygen of high altitude? If that's OK, how ab

  • you suck10/10/2010

    your an idoit. your last paragraph makes you just sound retarded, you prove your self wrong.
    "For example, Seattle Mariners outfielder Ichiro Suzuki is a master at putting the ball in play, who has more hits than anyone in the MLB over the past five seasons, yet his power numbers aren’t significant. On the other hand, some of the greatest power hitters of all time have also topped the strikeout lists. The sole reason for homeruns is bat speed, not brute strength, so can steroids really help hitters that much? If we conclude that bat speed is the necessary component to a homerun, then the answer is probably not."
    if the sole componet to hitting home runs is bat speed then why doesnt ichiro have more then 40 in his whole ten year span in the mlb? exactly, hes not on steroids. how about you write a story on how bad ryan norris sucks about writing sports stories.

  • Ryan Norris2/11/2009

    I'm glad to see that someone who can't even post their name can defuse my whole argument by simply stating "your an idiot" (which should actually be written as "You're an idiot." Now who's the idiot?

    Once again, for the record, this was simply an exercise to see if justifying steroids was possible and actually I don't think the arguments are all that bad.

  • .2/11/2009

    your an idiot

  • dazedkraut11/22/2007


    Clearly, you are the prototype sportswriter- you dabble in everything, and don't really know much about anything.

  • Ryan Norris11/22/2007

    For the record, this was just an exercise in argument to see if justification could actually be done. And also for the record dazedkraut, I have played for an extended period of time and actually still play so that nixes your whole argument. Try again.

  • dazedkraut11/22/2007

    Probably you have never played the game of baseball for any length of time, and if you had- you would realize the value of steroids as far as helping the recovery process. It is a grinding game, it simply wears a player out physically. Batspeed is the key, but steroids do enable the muscles which increase batspeed (forearms, wrists, and most importantly- the hips, the hips are where real power is generated. If you stop muscle atrophy (as steroids do) you you increase productivity.

  • bb4/24/2007

    i use and there is nothing wrong with that!

  • bb4/24/2007

    there awesome

  • JBAILEY1/12/2007

    I REMEMBER LISTENING TO A PROSTITUTE JUSTIFY HER EXISTENCE BY EQUATING SOCIAL ACCEPTANCE TO MONEY. WE CANNOT LET OUR YOUTH JEAPORDIZE THEIR WELL-BEING FOR ENTERTAINMENT PURPOSES. PLEASE LET US NOT BECOME CARNIVAL FREAKS.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.