Top Ten Songs by Pink Floyd

Thanks, Pink Floyd, for Making This so Tough

L. Carter
Picking only 10 songs by Pink Floyd as "top" selections is a tough task. It's like picking only ten days of the year you want to eat ice cream. Clearly you need more choices.

For every Pink Floyd song you pick there are probably two or three great ones that you can't. The band wasn't in the habit of making radio-ready singles and stuffing the rest of their albums with filler. Each album is as much about the total package as the individual parts, so there are seldom any "throwaway" songs, regardless of your personal taste. Even if you don't like the style of a particular song, you can recognize its quality.

It's also tough to choose just 10 songs by Pink Floyd because their songs were so good on so many levels. It's a combination of the music, lyrics, and message that makes Pink Floyd's work so awe-inspiring.

Thad said, here are my top ten Pink Floyd songs, in no particular order:

Pigs (Three Different Ones)

This is classic Pink Floyd. A long, melodic journey, with themes that reoccur throughout the song, musically and otherwise, trippy effects, social commentary, and actual oinking that only adds to the thinly veiled metaphor. Off their 1977 album "Animals," this song is in very good company on that album.

Shine On You Crazy Diamond

Ominous, beautiful, heavenly, haunting, there aren't enough adjectives to describe this song. Off 1975's "Wish You Were Here," a group of songs reportedly dedicated to the group's original frontman, Syd Barrett, this is the kind of song that transports you to a place where petty problems don't exist. If you ever see this song performed live, it will wash you clean.

Echoes

23 minutes long, off of "Meddle," this is strange, stirring and suspenseful, defined as much by what is happening as what's about to.

Another Brick In the Wall, Part 2

For anyone who's even remotely a Pink Floyd fan this song likely needs no introduction. Off the concept album "The Wall" about a rock star's mental breakdown, this song is about his abuse at school as a child. Remember "If you don't eat your meat, then you can't have any pudding!! How can you have any pudding if you don't eat your meat??!" at the end of the song. This is definitely more rock than psychedelic.

*Tie Between "Young Lust" and "Have A Cigar"

Okay, I'm kind of cheating. But anyway. "Young Lust," also off "The Wall," is more of a rock number with a funk edge, melodic, classic Floyd. And it's about groupies. "Have A Cigar" is some weird, supercool psychedelic funk off "Wish You Were Here" about The Man, who is not cool at all. It features one of the greatest chord progressions of all time.

"Speak To Me/Breathe"

Pure brilliance, from throbbing beginning to calming end. This is the opening song on 1973's "Dark Side of the Moon," one of the best-selling albums of all time.

Comfortably Numb

Heavy, eerie, this is a great song. Also off "The Wall."

Us and Them

A brilliant song, not just because of the music, but because of the message. This is a commentary on the irrationality of war. Obviously it is still relevant today.

"Any Colour You Like"

Soothing. Like so many songs on "Dark Side of the Moon," psychedelic. But you don't have to be spaced out on four varieties of illegal substances to enjoy this song. In any state of mind, it'll improve your state of mind. This is also another great song to see performed live.

Wish You Were Here

This had to make the list, only because it's so popular and so recognizable, but doesn't have any of the failings of the typical pop hit - short but not formulaic, with the signature Pink Floyd lyricism .. "did you exchange a walk-on part in the war, for a lead role in a cage?" This is a beautiful, melancholy song, and if you ever see it in concert, you know everyone will be singing along.

Published by L. Carter

One of Associated Content's Top 1000 Content Producers in 2009 and 2010, LC writes for major print and online news media. She has published hundreds of articles, interviewed some of the most prominent fig...  View profile

  • For every Pink Floyd song you pick there are probably two or three great ones that you can't.
  • The band wasn't in the habit of making radio-ready singles and stuffing their albums with filler.
  • Each album is as much about the total package as the individual parts.
Many people believe there is a relationship between Pink Floyd's "Dark Side of the Moon" and the movie "Wizard of Oz." Supposedly if you start playing the album when the MGM lion roars for the third time, it syncs up rather eerily. I've never done it though, so I can't be sure.

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • jess5/6/2010

    i like this skater boy but i dont know if he likes me can somebody gove me hints if a skater boy or emo boy likes me??? thanks... from jess

  • Richard Carriero12/12/2009

    Shine On..is my favorite song ever. Pigs Three Different Ones is an excellent choice. Echoes (or Meddle) or vinyl is one of my most prized possessions. I would also throw in Mud Men, Astronomy Domine, If and Time. For those of you that would disparage the author for her preferences, you're elitist morons.

  • alissa11/10/2009

    if you really think comfortably numb is the best you dont no much about pink floyd! its a good song but come on its WAY over rated theres SO much better songs out there by pink floyd!!! really.. come on ....

  • Ali10/24/2009

    good list but wt abt "hey you" ?

  • Your name11/15/2008

    actually Comfortaby Numb is the best song

  • Alex Ceja1/6/2008

    I agree with the first comment "Hey You" should diffenently be on this list. It has great lyrics and an amazing guitar solo.

  • No Name :)9/6/2007

    Well.. it's a good top... but what about "hey you" my personal fav ....

  • Jonathan Joura8/3/2007

    I agree with all of the entries on your list with the exception of Young Lust. Never particularly cared for that number. Also you do Us and Them an injustice by claiming it is just about war. It really is an indictment of human nature as a whole, the class struggles between the haves and the have nots. And now that I'm thinking about it, I would substituteDogs for Pigs in this list. Just my two cents.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.