Useless Baby Items that Only First-Time Parents Buy

Jane Elle
Yesterday I helped a friend shop for his daughter's baby shower. It's her first baby. You know how I could tell? Her baby shower registry list.

First-time parents will, of course, make plenty of rookie mistakes. First-time parents will freak out every time their baby so much as whimpers and will often think that a runny nose requires a three a.m. emergency room visit. There are some parenting lessons that you just have to learn on your own, but there are some lessons that you can take from me, Experienced Parent.

A single visit to Babies 'R Us will fill the first-time parent-to-be with overwhelming anxiety. What is all of this stuff? Do I need it? I must. It's here! Even the most intelligent, marketing-savvy adults will forget that baby products are an industry like any other, and that advertising companies prey on parents' desire to provide their child with the safest and highest-quality products available, to the tune of billions annually.

With that in mind, Lesson One: You don't need even half of the crap on your baby shower registry.

Take a deep breath, sit down, and rest assured that you don't need any of the following:

1. Steam Sterilizer. At about $50, this is one of the most useless baby products ever. You might as well grab a $50 bill and light it on fire. Sure, you want your baby's bottles and pacifiers to be clean, but do they need to be steam sterilized? Um, no. Have a dishwasher? How about a sink, Palmolive, and a hot water heater? Then you're just fine. Take that $50 and buy a $3 bottle brush. Spend the remaining $47 on heavily caffeinated beverages- something you'll actually need.

2. Infant carseat. You know those carrier carseats that you can unlatch from the base and use to carry the baby? Huge waste of money (not to mention painfully heavy to carry). Depending on how quickly your baby grows, they'll be out of an infant carseat in a matter of months. Instead of buying an infant carseat (the inexpensive ones are around $70), buy the regular carseat that you're going to have to buy anyway in a few months. Take that $70 you almost blew and apply it toward getting the safest, most highly-rated carseat you can find. Just make sure that the weight limit is such that it's safe for a newborn.

3. Highchair. They make really neat highchairs these days, I know. But I'm here to tell you that they're more of a pain than they're worth. First, they're bulky. Even in the most generously-sized kitchens or dining rooms, highchairs take up a lot of space (especially since highchair manufacturers realized that kids would stop tipping over in them if they expanded the base of the chairs). Second, they keep your child at an awkward height if your child eats with you at family meals. Most highchairs will have your child at a whole 'nother level than everyone else at the table. Finally, they're expensive. The inexpensive highchairs begin in the $70 range, and the price increases exponentially from there. Instead, seat your child at the table with everyone else, for about $20. The chair-mount booster seats are mostly in the $20 range and have removable and dishwasher-safe trays, as well as the safety belts that highchairs have. Booster seats take up much less space and are a snap to clean. Take that extra $50 and use it to buy cleaning wipes. Another item you'll actually need.

4. Diaper pails or Diaper Genies. They don't keep the smell any better contained than regular trash cans- trust me. A regular diaper pail costs about $15 (not too much more than the cost of a regular trash can with a lid), and like most trash cans, it more or less keeps the diaper stench in- until you open the lid. Same with the Diaper Genie- but the Diaper Genie costs about $25, and the bag refills cost about $6 per refill cartridge. And the Diaper Genie isn't a piece of cake to use- lots of unnecessary effort and expense, many will tell you. Instead, do what my daycare does: use the plastic grocery bags you paid nothing for, put each dirty diaper in one, tie it off, and drop it in the regular trash can. Take out your trash at least once daily. This works surprisingly well, and you won't have to deal with cleaning out an absolutely wretchedly stinky diaper pail, ever. But if you really want to ensure that no diaper smell lingers in your home, keep a bag or pail outside the back door of your house and toss dirty diapers directly into it. Note: this advice applies to disposable diapers, not cloth. If you tie a messed cloth diaper in a plastic bag for later laundering, remember that you will eventually have to open the bag. Ick.

5. Baby bath. Sure, they're only $20, but do you really need one? No. Your baby will be small enough to fit in the baby bath (usually made for babies who aren't yet sitting) for only a few months. Add to that the facts that they're uncomfortable for the parent to use (lots of crouching and stooping) and bulky to store, and they become more trouble than they're worth. What's the time, money, and back-saving alternative? Your kitchen sink. If you have one of those extendable spray hoses, well, you're just extra lucky. Indulge in the age-old tradition of sink bathing- it requires a clean sink, a towel or two for padding if your baby isn't sitting yet, and the usual baby-cleaning accessories. Your back will thank you for bathing baby in the sink, and clean-up is a snap. Take that $20 and buy another memory stick for your digital camera, because there's nothing cuter than a picture of a baby taking a bath in a kitchen sink.

There will be plenty of items that your baby will need in bulk that you'll have to spend plenty of money on- so do yourself a favor and skip the above items. The baby products industry won't collapse, I swear.

14 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Amy8/26/2009

    I have to remark that I disagree with the infant carseat one. You can only skip the infant carseat IF your delivering hospital says it's ok. A lot of hospitals now will NOT let you take your baby home unless he/she is being placed in an infant carseat instead of a larger convertible carseat. Mine won't allow it, I know that. Check with your hospital before purchasing!

  • Trina Council8/26/2009

    We got a baby tub from my mom. Yes, it was $25 and I plan on using it at our kitchen table. The reason is, we live in a 100-year old house in a basement apartment and our kitchen sink, bathroom sink, and tub either aren't big enough or have too much grime ingrained into the grout for me to feel comfortable using for the baby.

  • Brad Hart12/26/2008

    new is the problem with many first timers, especially if they are a resentful middle or youngest child who got everything they ever had as hand-me downs.

    Some of the items like the infant car seat and baby bath aren't useless if you can get cheap or free. We spent $10.00 on an infant car seat buying it from a friend who had bought it from a friend who had got it from a friend. We could have got it for free if she wasn't considering giving it to a different friend who was also pregnant.

    If you have a goodwill or other donation stocked store you can regularly get a baby bath for less than $5.00. I don't have a dishwasher and since sleep and baby means doing enough dishes to eat on for a single meal or when ever you have time, it is convenient to have the bath, especially in the first week or two when you need to keep the cord out of the water. After that point it is put the baby in the sink or bath/shower with you just to make sure you can get a moment to clean up too. If yo

  • Brandi Brown11/22/2008

    Great piece...could relate...although, will say I loved my highchair and was lucky enough to have people give me 2 of the portable boosters...so I had best of both worlds...and the carseat...ok, the one thing that I can say in defense of that, it was the one thing that helped my baby girl sleep when she was congested...my pediatrician told me to put that in her crib and make sure it was secure so that her head stayed elevated...worked like a charm and we all got some sleep...

  • Jackie L.2/15/2008

    Dr., I remember family vacations where we spent two weeks without a seatbelt in the family station wagon. Miraculously, we too survived. Those days are over, though.

  • DrDevience2/15/2008

    But ya know what? We didn't even have car seata available when I had kids... Gee. I wonder how they ever survived.... (/snark)

  • DrDevience2/15/2008

    HA! Excellent article. Just excellent!

  • Jackie L.2/14/2008

    Oh, totally, Kathleen! Lots of first-time parents want everything new... hopefully they wise up to the benefits of handmedowns and secondhand purchases quickly. Babies can be crazy expensive. Breastfeeding and cloth diapering take away the biggest expenses; paring down the rest is easy.

  • Kathleen McDade2/14/2008

    GREAT article. I would like to add, however -- if you still think you need or want some of these items, BUY USED, or even get 'em free. I have a diaper pail that was given to me free by a co-worker, and had a baby bath that cost only a few bucks. I LOVE our booster seat instead of a high chair -- I highly recommend this as well.

  • Jackie L.2/14/2008

    So true, Lindsey. Hey, Jeanne! Great to see you!

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.