Violence in Videogames on the Verge of Going Too Far

After ESRB 'Adults Only' Tag - and British Band of - Rockstar's 'Manhunt 2', Changes in Industry Must Be Assessed

Jeffrey Davis
When Rockstar Games first released the sadistic, edge-of-your-seat videogame horror experience of the original Manhunt, things were just barely acceptable for people to accept the game and it's brutal premise. With September 11, 2001 three years past in the minds of most people and critics of videogame gore and violence rife with anger towards such extremes in interactive material, it's no surprise that the game was kicked out of so many places in the world, perhaps most notably in Austrailia.

But after the Virginia Tech massacre, such sadism in videogames is no longer acceptable no matter where you live. Incidents like this, combined with even those nonlethal ones involving Mel Gibson, Paris Hilton and Don Imus, bring such glorified extremes into an entirely diferent reality where they are just not excusable anymore - much less even tolerable.

So it comes to pass that the British vote to outright forbid release of the even-more-violent Manhunt 2, and the ESRB here in the 'States esentially does the same thing by slapping an Adults Only sticker on the game - making it essentially illegal to buy the game even in the American marketplace due to retailer rules that practically forbid sales of such erotic material off of any videogame shelf! Clearly, it is evident that violence in modern videogames has gone way too far - and this it's about time somebody draws the line on what is acceptable in videogames.

Now I'm not saying we must ban violence outright on this or any other entertainment media. That would be siding to a suicidal extent with such lunatics as Jack Thompson who clearly I don't give a [expletive] about. After all, violence works in many other forms of entertainment and nobody complains about what goes into movies, television shows, etc. because limits have already been placed on those formats with some success. For example, you won't find anyone playing reruns of Jackass or The Sopranos on CBS because the FCC would have Les Moonves' head if they did. But these shows can be safely shown on TNT or USA, or in some cases on essentially free-rein, pay-per-view services like HBO, because those channels play exclusively of subscription-based cable and satellite services. Likewise, radio stations operated by Clear Channel can no longer run Opie and Anthony shows without running afoul of decency limits, but XM and Sirius (read: per-fee satellite radio providers) don't have this problem. So why not apply a similar principle to videogames?

After all, someone has to draw the line somewhere. And if the ESRB cannot at least make this kind of efort, then everything in the videogame industry will end up with an overhaul that is much worse than that, kind of like that of foriegn countries that specifically forbid ratings to such sadistic games as Manhunt and it's sequel. Adn if that ever comes to pass, then our basic American principles of free speech and free reign are soon to be lost as well... and then we'll all end up in a draconian society much like that of China or the former Soviet Union. And if that ever comes to pas, it will be too late to save our national identity and the principle of freedom will be dead forever.

And that's a scary thought.

Published by Jeffrey Davis

Jeffrey Davis is a technology enthusiast with experiences in website design, videogame platforms, online trends and general computing topics.  View profile

3 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Marilyn Mueller6/24/2007

    I have and will continue to read Jeffrey Davis' articles as they are to the point on what
    is going on in a world most of us know little. He shares his extended knowledge and insight
    of the truth. Jeffrey opens our eyes to understanding the reality of the true intentions
    of those who profit at the expense of our children. Jeffrey is a man of integrity. Thank you
    Jeffrey for all you are doing. You are truly appreciated, YOU MAKE A DIFFERENCE!

  • E. Tucker6/21/2007

    Helpful to parents with children. I do think that video games should have ratings as far as violent & sexual content are concerned. Jeffrey is fair in his assessment of video game violence, etc.

  • Jeffrey Davis6/20/2007

    Update 7/20/2007 8:05PM-CDT: I should note at this point that, as the fallout continues from the incident that sparked this editorial, it has come to my attention that Manhunt 2 is on the verge of being outright cancelled, and with good reason: No respectable videogame company, whether Sony OR Nintendo, wants to have a game with an Adults Only rating on their systems AT ALL! And from what I have heard since writing this article, both companies anounced their intent to cancel their support for the game as is under the current situation due to their policies of not allowing games with this rating on their systems, period. As a result, this esentially starts the countdown to Rockstar's potential cancellation of Manhunt 2 in its entirety if the game cannot be changed at this point. See the following URL: http://biz.gamedaily.com/industry/news/?id=16580

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.