One condition that pops out is the requirement that a person must speak the native language.
I don't think that speaking the language of the host country is out of line. I don't think it's criminal or even an outrageous request. It's now to the point that I feel as though I should learn several different languages to understand what's going on in my own country. Learning the language is a sign of respect.
No unskilled workers are allowed.
I'm not sure how "skilled" workers are determined, but what's wrong with requiring that an immigrant be productive? We in this country don't need more "corner posts", and a skill of sorts would be helpful to become gainfully employed. I don't see the problem with this one, especially since other countries seems to have plenty of unskilled workers of their own. So many in fact that they can afford to ship the excess here.
Immigrants will never have the right to vote, hold political office, collect welfare, food stamps, or government assistance of any kind, including health care, no matter how long they have been in Mexico.
This one seems reasonable. I know, I know, the argument is immigrants should be allowed to vote in local elections to have a say in how their tax dollars are spent. My counter argument is that there is a process here called citizenship. Immigrants want a vote? Become a citizen. Immigrants want government assistance? Get a job, pay taxes and become a citizen. Show some effort and some loyalty before you demand perks other people pay for.
Immigrants may not protest, demonstrate, wave a foreign flag, or organize politically.
This one is my own personal favorite. Viva Me-hee-co! Nothing ticks me off more than seeing a swarm of aliens demanding rights they don't have in their own country. If the people feel the need to protest our cruel and abusive human rights policies while wrapping themselves in the flag of their own beloved homeland, why the hell did they leave to come here?
Immigrants are the fabric of our nation, and have woven a myriad of proud ethnic values and traditions into it. But I, being the ignorant, unreasonable hard-ass I am, believe that along with "admission" into this country, there should also come an honest desire to "contribute" to rather than "take advantage of" all we have to offer. I'm tired of being thought of as a right wing radical because I expect more from those that come here than a list of demands. And to those who cry "But we are a nation of immigrants!" in defense of the poor huddled masses dehumanized by our unreasonable and cruel policies, I would ask, "What does that mean? Aren't most other countries also nations of immigrants?" That being the case, maybe we should take a lesson from them.
Source: http://msgboard.snopes.com/cgi-bin/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=print_topic;f=37;t=001077
Published by Nancy V Canfield
Retired retro who writes during television commercials. If you're the type of person who doesn't like to take life too seriously, then we'll get along just fine. My family says I'm overly opinionated and bos... View profile
Islam Vs. Nation of IslamThis article will give people a true understanding of both Islam and the Nation of Islam and how the two are not related.
What Ellis Island and the Statue of Liberty Means to MeWhat one symbol of freedom means to me. - Illegal Immigrants Are a ProblemIt's a sad thing that people want to be so considerate that they don't even want to admit illegal immigration is a problem. It's illegal.
- Immigration & XenophobiaI believe that Mexican immigration should be allowed to continue. If the United States is worried about the bifurcation of its culture, it should look to itself for solutions...
- The Immigration ControversySenate bill S. 2612 proposes reforms on immigration and border security.
- Illegal Immigrants Deserve Fair Treatment
- The Contributions of Immigrants to the United States
- We Are a Nation of Immigrants and the Healthcare Plan of Barack Obama
- United States as a Nation of Immigrants
- Why the Hyphenation of Nationalities Needs to End in the US
- Illegal Immigration as a Means to Be Above the Law of the Land
- An Immigrant's Daughter's Views on Undocumented Immigrants, Policies, and Fences




33 Comments
Post a CommentYou brought out some interesting points, Nancy. I have come across these points of view on a number of occasions since moving to America (I'm a legal Permanent Resident, having moved here legally to live with my American husband). I was not aware of the immigration laws of Mexico. That was quite enlightening. I can only speak from my own experience as a UK citizen living abroad. Us immigration laws are very stringent.
Sophie
Ha ha Patricia! So we agree I'm an ignorant hardass? LOL!
"But I, being the ignorant, unreasonable hard-ass I am, believe that along with "admission" into this country, there should also come an honest desire to "contribute" to rather than "take advantage of" all we have to offer." At last, a political point we agree on!
And a God Bless the USA thrown in. Amen. :-)
ps I am having a glass or two of fine wine and celebrating my 45th birthday today. My mom is reading over my shoulder and going "Hell yeah!" Hehe. I am very blessed. I love AC writers and trust me, Nancy, you are one of my favs. Always. We just cut the bd cake. Woohoo. Happy Labor day to all! Celebrating my bd AC style, so fine. Cheers.
Oh lord, you said a mouthful here. :-) :-x. Hehe. Enjoyed. Lmao at Snidley's comment.
Write on!
Great article. I know a couple who thought they could just cross the Canadian border and buy a house. What a rude surprise they were in for when they were refused entry into Canada and told you Americans think you can just come over here and get free health care. Conversely my own great grandfather walked to the USA from Canada in the late 1800s, learned English and became a citizen
Very nice... :o)
Nice job Nance. And Mexico complains about our piss poor immigration enforcement?
Points well taken Nancy!