What NOT to Donate to Charity

Jill Davidson
When the subject of charity arises, we all want to believe we are doing our part, whether through donations of money or used clothing, furniture, toys, and other household goods. But are you really doing anyone any favors when you donate goods that are worn out or damaged beyond use?

If you are truly charitable, you won't dump all your junk at the door of the local thrift shop or Goodwill store. Giving something that should have been thrown away is not giving at all, but only puts a burden on the receiver to find a way to dispose of your junk.

As a volunteer at our local nonprofit thrift shop (which is run by the local fellowship of churches), I help sort through many bags and boxes of secondhand items. While many of the donations are in excellent shape or even brand new, we also receive many things, especially clothing, that go into the dumpster. The next time you make a donation to the thrift shop, please find another way to get rid of these items:

Torn or stained clothing. Depending on how badly soiled or torn they are, some clothing items are still suitable for donation. Guys will buy torn or stained jeans for work, and moms know that kids will eventually get their clothes stained, so these items will still sell. Jackets and other clothing with torn zippers aren't acceptable. A good rule of thumb is that if you wouldn't wear the item yourself or put it on your own family, it shouldn't be donated. Use ratty old clothes for cleaning rags instead.

Appliances and electronics that don't work. C'mon, is this really charity, giving away something that's useless? Find another way to get rid of it. Salvage the metal and sell it instead, or give it to someone who will. I don't take time to salvage metal myself, but I have an acquaintance who does. She takes my scrap metal and gives me half of whatever she gets for it. You can usually find ads by scrap metal dealers in the classified ads of the newspaper, or in the yellow pages.

Furniture that is badly damaged. If the piece needs major repair to be put in usuable condition, don't take it to the thrift store. If you don't want that old, ugly, broken thing in your house, do you think someone else does? Throw it on a bonfire.

Computers. Ask before donating computers and accessories. Schools and charities are thrilled to get computers that have up-to-date operating systems, but some computers are now dinosaurs and can be a burden on the receiver. Donate your old computer to a recycler or refurbisher instead.

True charity is giving of yourself. It doesn't hurt much to unload old possessions, but it can be difficult to part with things we love. This is the true test of charity (love) toward our fellow man. My challenge to you is to look in your closet, in your curio cabinet, or wherever your most beloved things are, and to pick one item to give from your heart. Donate it to charity, or give it to a friend or family member who has always admired your beloved treasure. Could you do it with a glad and grateful heart? If so, you know the true joy of giving!

Published by Jill Davidson

Ms. Davidson is self-employed as a secondhand merchant, crafter, and free-lance writer.  View profile

24 Comments

Post a Comment
  • J. E. Davidson3/17/2009

    It is true that some locations will send old clothes to textile recyclers. I suppose one should ask before hauling them to the local drop-off.

  • NJ3/17/2009

    Hmmmm...
    Our local Good Will's always told us that, aside from clothes that may qualify as medical waste or truly soiled, old cotton clothes were fabulous b/c they took all of the "scrap" cotton and sold it to recyclers. Is this NOT (or no longer) the case? I always gave them even the rattiest T-Shirts I had b/c of this...

  • Allene Newberg Bilodeau11/3/2008

    Amen, sister! When we drop items at the Salvation Army Store, I'm often appalled at the gross or filthy stuff left outside. But as you know from your thrift shop work, it's so cool to come across a great "find"! Excellent point that time can be the greatest gift of charity. This article needed to be written. Great job!

  • Janie Ellington10/27/2008

    Good points. A donation center is not a trash dump. I work in nonprofit and spend a lot of time dealing with things that we can't use.

  • Debbie Henthorn10/7/2008

    Jill...this is a great reminder! I am sickened on Monday mornings driving through my town looking at the piles of stuff stacked around the back door at our ISS store. People holding garage sales just take the leftovers there. They finally got people to quit leaving furniture (to sit in the rain overnight!) and appliances. My goal is to have enough money to make a donation earmarked for annual dumpster service so that ISS can use their funds for better purposes!

  • Sussy7/27/2008

    Amen!!

  • SFaloon7/22/2008

    This is such valuable information.

  • Kassidy Emmerson7/18/2008

    I'm with Charlene. Torn, stained and otherwise unfit clothing, and broken or inoperable items go in the dumpster. They do not go to Goodwill or the Salvation Army. Super read that people need to adhere to!

  • J. E. Davidson7/8/2008

    EWWWW, R.B! Soiled mattresses should be burned! Especially now that bedbugs are resurging!

  • Nikki7/7/2008

    What a great article! I'm not sure how I missed it.

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.