In many cultures methods of parenting and disciplining a child vary. On January 11th, a book titled, "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mom," by Amy Chua, came out, sharing her story as a mother regarding parenting and discipline methods, raising her two daughters, Lulu and Sophia. Public discussion is rampant regarding this Asian mother and her seemingly extreme conservative methods. For example, her daughters were not allowed sleepovers or play dates and were often verbally berated into performing at their best. Nothing less was ever accepted. The Asian culture tends to hold a more traditional and stricter mode in parenting and disciplining children. Amy Chua is married to Jed Rubenfeld, a Yale Law school professor, who has stated he doesn't totally agree with his wife's methods, but allowed her to set the rules. Amy Chua's parenting and disciplining styles are being questioned on whether they cross the line into blatant child abuse.
In November of 2010, Dr. Phil had a mother named Jessica Beagley on his show. Jessica Beagley is a mother of six children who lives in Alaska and contacted Dr. Phil, confessing she can't handle parenting and disciplining her children. In a video she is seen disciplining her seven year old adoptive son by overbearingly berating him face to face, pouring hot sauce in his mouth and administering an ice cold shower, all while the young child is screaming. Her husband is a police officer. Jessica Beagley is now being investigated for allegations of child abuse. Was she an out of control mother and does she deserve jail time for her parenting and disciplining methods?
Sadly and despicably a Floridian mother named Julie Schenecker shot her sixteen year old daughter and thirteen year old son, confessing she shot them because she was tired of her children talking back with mouthy mouths. Julie Schenecker was arrested and sent to a hospital from jail because of an unknown emotional problem. Julie's husband was overseas serving in the military, and was called him for his children's funeral. An out of control mother due to stress, drugs or alcohol, we don't know. Is Julie Schenecker a mother who lost all sense of boundaries in disciplining and parenting? It still doesn't excuse her horrific behavior.
There are parents who believe parenting skills mean catering to your children's every whim without any discipline or rules. Can this be producing a generation of spoiled adults who believe the world should be handed to them? Today there are more out of control children, and children who are living in dysfunctional homes. It's not known whether these children's behaviors are becoming worst because of our generation being more lax in parenting and disciplining skills. There are also more stressed, exhausted parents and sadly more abusive parents.
I don't have the answer on the perfect parenting and disciplining method. I was raised within a family culture believing you, "spare the rod and spoil the child." Belts and straps were used to discipline, I wear the welts today. For my parenting and disciplining method, I didn't follow my family's idea and my children turned out great. "Time Outs," is what the television personality, Jo from the ABC, "The Supernanny," believes. She turns dysfunctional parenting and disciplining skills around.
Tiger Mom or Octomom? What is the correct parenting and disciplining method? I do believe it should always start and end with love.
You can read Time Magazine's interview with Amy Chua about her parenting and disciplining style at the following link.
http://healthland.time.com/2011/01/11/chinese-vs-western-mothers-q-a-with-amy-chua/
You can view the You Tube video of Jessica Beagley describing and showing her parenting and disciplining style at the following link.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gkYIjQceoRs&feature=player_embedded
ABC News video on Julie Schenecker's story is at link below.
Published by Claire Luna-Pinsker
I'm an author and writer, retired pediatric nurse, mother and wife, educated in the school of life. I started writing stories using spelling words in elementary school. My teacher's encouragement helped deve... View profile
- How to Deal with Your Angry ChildAre you feeling frustrated and stressed because you're not sure how to deal with your angry child? Does it seem that no matter what you do your child still reacts in anger? If so you're not alone.
How-to Make Consequence and Reward JarsHow-to implement a peaceful parenting discipline and reward system that will encourage children to make good choices and be accountable for their behavior.- Young to School Age Children: How to Create and Use a Behavior ChartThis is an article for parents who want their kids to behave more acceptable more of the time. This article will teach parents how to make a behavior chart, how to use it consistently, and how it will work!
Single Parents: How to Help Your Child Set GoalsCreating good habits in your children takes more than just discipline. Find out how to help your child set goals which will help them for the rest of their lives.
How to Raise ChildrenHow to lay up strong foundation to our children.
- Modern Views on Child Discipline: Is Spanking Still Okay?
- "Tiger Mother" Model of Parenting Falls Prey to Flawed Assumptions
- "Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother" Depicts Emotional Child Abuse
- Effective Parenting Through Appropriate Discipline Techniques
- Do You Believe in Your Children More Than Anyone Else and More Than They Believe i...
- Are Chinese Mothers Better?
- 10 Steps: How to Parent Tweens





8 Comments
Post a CommentI think parenting tecniques vary between children. But I also believe many parents are "parenting" less and less these days (this includes teaching manners). Good article!
We always had respect for our parents and we were never "beat" but we were afraid to let either of them down. Respect, love, encouragement - these are powerful tools in discipline. Cheers ;)
Role modeling worked for me
My father occasionally disciplined my brothers and me with his belt. I'd never call it a beating, because it was just one swipe, and I knew it hurt him at least as much as it did us; well, at least me. I think that where that goes wrong is when the parent lashes out in anger & frustration; and can end up doing the child real harm.
I think the answer is to get help. The parents need to seek it when they realize they are out of control. Also, they should seek it for the child when they become uncontrollable.
My dad had a short cut to child psychology...it was called "the belt." It cut down on the expense of office visits!
I saw The View today...there was a Mother (if you could call her that) that was punishing her adopted son by putting tabasco sauce on his tongue...and giving him an ice cold shower...I wouldn't go that far and I'm sure MOST wouldn't but I do feel now the parents are not quite dissaplining children as they should because there is no respect much anymore and family loyalities...I have it in my family...no respect and love for family...I was brought up different...:-)
I read that article about Amy Chua. It was a rather interesting take on parenting. I did not agree with most of her tactics. My parents were firm disciplinarians and used the rod when necessary. We turned out to be responsible individuals and respectful to our fellow man.
My kids turned out great, too, with nary a belt or beating. Great article!