"What Would Martin Say?"

Book Reveiw

Alyce Rocco
"What Would Martin Say" by Clarence B. Jones and Joel Engel was published in 2008. The Martin in question is Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. As a draft speech writer and adviser for King, Jones says he, at times, "literally put words" in King's mouth. When King sought out Jones, an attorney, for help on a thumped up tax evasion charge, Jones turned him down. Much to his wife's chagrin, Jones thought he was "too busy" to work for a cause larger than himself. King used a unique approach to change Jones' mind. Jones thought it was a "one and done" favor, but King was not done with him yet. The rest, as they say, is history.

Jones was inspired to write "What Would Martin Say" after visiting the National Civil Rights Museum in Memphis, Tennessee. April 4, 2008 marked the fortieth anniversary of King's assassination and Jones says "I've tried to interpret what contributions he would add to his singular legacy if he were alive today." He likens doing this to Christians who ponder "What would Jesus do?".

In Chapter one of this 215 book, Jones covers, "What Did Martin Say About Me?". This is where Dr. King sort of guilts Jones into helping him with the tax evasion charge. Jones tells of King reciting a Langston Hughes poem, "Mother to Son", which he shares with readers. The gist of the poem is that the mother's life was not always easy but she is still "climbing" and expects her son to do likewise. In today's troubled economy, the poem is quite inspirational.

Other chapters in the book deal with the quality of contemporary black leaders, illegal immigration, affirmative action, the war on terror and "What Would Martin Say?" to James Earl Ray. In each chapter, Jones takes readers for a walk in the past, explaining King's reasoning on yesterday's issues. He ends chapters saying what King might say today about those issues and ways to resolve them.

Jones (and Engel) say that readers may not agree, with the assumptions of how King would think, if he were alive today. I agreed with most of it, such as in the case of the "Jena 6". Martin would not approve of violence to right a wrong and would say "accept the punishment". I did not, however agree with what the authors said about that case, because I think some facts of the incidents were overlooked. An example of that would be repeating that the attack on Justin was "unprovoked", which was not true. It appeared Jones was simply repeating words he heard via main stream media, than doing research on the case.

Imagine being a teenager in 2007 U.S.A. and feeling you need to ask a principal's permission to sit under a tree on school property as well as passing by a "White's Only" sign predominately displayed on the town's Barber Shop window. It is easy to say "turn the other cheek", but being treated on a daily basis as inferior due solely to skin color, could invoke the same angry feelings as any teen in 1950s Jim Crow southern U.S.A. If King were alive today, I think he would have been in Jena protesting the "cruel and unusual punishment" and unequal justice meted out to black teens with no charges against a white 18 year old for his beating of the black teen simply for trying to attend a party he was invited to.

"What Would Martin Say?" was published by Harper Collins Publishers. It is available online at www.harpercollins.com and sells for $23.95 in the USA. A blurb on the back cover, by Roger Ailes, chairman and CEO of Fox News channel says "Clarence Jones Has written a book that every American should read." I would suggest that the book be required reading for students as young as of Junior High school age. There are invaluable history lessons in the book, as well as teachings for our youth to consider.

9 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Lori Gunn1/29/2011

    excellent :)

  • KaRi from LBweeklyOnline.com3/19/2009

    I can't believe I read this TODAY of all days; I hope you're in the know about KING tonight! Jemmie Sae Koo from Suja's office shared this at a recent East Village Arts District meeting below and lbcbn.com's website surfaced a listing when I googled it:

    Season for Non-Violence Presents "King"

    EVENT on March 19, 2009
    Contact: Rev. Dr. Kimberlee Woods, Executive Director, The Center Long Beach, 562-434-4455, kimw@centerlb.org

    What: A&E's documentary called 'King' narrated by Tom Brokaw. This film explores the legend and the reality of the Martin Luther King Jr.

    When: Thursday, March 19, 2009. Program begins at 6:00 PM.

    Where: The ArtTheatre,2025 E. 4th Street,Long Beach. Limited parking available behind the Center,Long Beachat 2017 E. 4th Street,Long Beach.

    Who:
    HonorableSujaLowenthal, Councilmember, Second District
    Honorable Dee Andrews, Councilmember, Sixth District
    NAACP Long Beach
    Antioch Missionary Church
    The Season for Nonviolence Long Beach Commit

  • Dahloan Hembree2/17/2009

    One wonders if Martin's untimely death slowed down the fight for race equality. WOnder what things would have been like if he had lived. If he could only be around to see our new President!

  • Steven West1/26/2009

    I'm sure that Martin Luther King, Jr. would have a lot to say about the War in Iraq, the unfair tax system, the reversals on civil right protections, the invasions of privacy, and a whole lot more.

  • Lori Piper1/21/2009

    loved this

  • Mary E. Coe1/20/2009

    I, also, believe that if MLK was here he would have been in Jena protesting the cruel and unusual punishment. Very well written. You did an excellent job with this piece.

  • Bridgitte Williams1/15/2009

    Wonderful book review and great article! Perfect timing! It is almost Martin Luther King Jr. Day! :-)Thanks for sharing this, I loved it!

  • Herstory1/15/2009

    Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. still had much to say indeed in his own time that still rings all too true today in discriminatory acts that should be ancient history - yet slap too many races, creeds, personal beliefs, and the sexes.

  • Alban Mehling1/15/2009

    ;-}}>

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.