What Would You Really Do?

How Would You React in Ethical Situations?

K. Jai Estes
Primetime, the ABC News magazine-style show, has been airing a series called, What Would You Do? It places unsuspecting people in ethical situations and examines how they react. Primetime creates the scenarios using actors and sometimes, enlists the help of the unsuspected target's friends. Some of the ethical situations they encounter include a homeless man being attacked by a gang of thugs, and a healthy person parking in a disabled parking spot.

It's a fascinating series not only to see how these people react, but also, you can't help but place yourself in the same situations wondering how you would react.

Here are some scenarios Primetime has not covered as of yet. What would YOU really do in these situations?

Parking Lot Man
A man leaves an electronics store, and he is headed to the parking lot. He wanders seemingly aimlessly up, down and across the parking lot aisles. As he walks, he looks around, and he appears to be glancing in some of the cars he passes.You witness this as you sit outside the store waiting for your spouse.

Do you...
a. Calmly approach the man and ask if he needs help locating his car?
b. Inform the electronic store's security of the wandering man in their parking lot?
c. Call 911 to report suspicious activity?
d. Do nothing and leave?

Other Questions:
Would you react differently if the man were elderly?
Would you react differently if it were a woman?
Would you react differently if it were a teenage boy?

Demanding Patient
You are in your doctor's very busy waiting room. You have been waiting 45 minutes past your scheduled appointment time. A patient who just arrives approaches the receptionist and demands she be seen immediately. The receptionist honors the patient's request, and the woman is whisked to examining room.

Do you?
a. Approach the receptionist and calmly demand answers to the woman being immediately seen by the doctor?
b. Engage the other waiting patients and demand answers as a group?
c. Demand to be the next to see the doctor?
d. Sit patiently until the receptionist calls you?
e. Leave the office and find a new doctor?

Other Questions:
Would you react differently if you knew the demanding woman had a true medical emergency?
Would you react differently if the woman were demanding the doctor immediately see her child?
Would react differently if it were a man demanding care?

Bad Boss
You seem to have good relationship with your boss. He hasn't given you any reason to think otherwise. He personally praises your work, and says you are a great employee. A few days later, your coworkers begin acting differently towards you. They are not as friendly as they were, and they try to avoid you at all costs. You cautiously confront your coworkers questioning why their attitude towards you has changed? They relay stories the boss has been telling about you. Of course, the stories are false and personally detrimental to your reputation.

Do you...
a. Quit your job?
b. Confront your boss demanding answers to his deplorable actions?
c. Ignore the situation?

Other Questions:
Would you react differently if your boss were female?
Would you react differently if your boss were a family member or personal friend?

We encounter ethical situations everyday, but how many of us are truly aware of them? Maybe we should make ourselves more aware of them and take action. What that action may be is up to you. Hopefully, it will be morally and ethically correct. Our world needs more good.

Published by K. Jai Estes

Freelance writer and poet.  View profile

12 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Genie Walker5/23/2008

    Interesting topic! I'm really too busy thinking about what I would do in each situation to write much in my comment. Great job!

  • Donna Porter3/19/2008

    Timely topic and well done.

  • SAIKAT KUMAR DUTTA3/13/2008

    very interesting askings, great job as always.

  • K. Jai Estes3/5/2008

    Thanks everyone! I'm really enjoying the comments/reactions you have written. Tremendous job!

  • Charlie K3/5/2008

    With regard to the last question, I would definitely confront the son-of-a-gun and make him or her make a public apology. If it were a family member? Well, I think I could find a way to handle that behind the scenes but I'd still confront the issue and demand an apology. This situation has actually happened to me and believe me I got my apology in front of the entire staff.

  • Charlie K3/5/2008

    OOOOH, ethics can pigeon hole us every time. With the parking lot guy, I'd ask if I could help him find his car because I'm forever misplacing mine and I'd assume he had done the same. I realize that is naieve but it is who I am. I would certainly be more comfortable if it was a woman or an elderly man, but I'd likely do A anyway. The exception might be if it was a teenage boy. It would depend on his demeanor (not his dress or color). With the second question, I would probably do D and might consider the last half of E if I could. However, of course, if the patient butting in had a real emergency (be it a man or a woman) I would not have a problem with it at all. As far as it being on behalf of a child, that would depend how ill the child looked. Again, if it were an emergency, I'd have no problem. However, if the kid was basically healthy, I think he or she needs to wait just like anyone else. With regard to the last question, I would definitely confront the son-of-a-gun and make him

  • K. Ray3/5/2008

    Excellent topic and questions. As far as the man in the parking lot - I'd probably ignore him. If the man is able-bodied and can't find his car, he should report it stolen. If the man was elderly or appeared disabled, I'd ask if he needed help. With the doctor's office situation, I woudn't do anything. I would wonder, but I'd probably assume the person had an emergency. I'm generally a very patient person. As far as the work situation, I'd be very hurt, and I'd talk to the boss in private and ask what was going on. If I had to I'd take it up with someone higher up, and I'd make it clear that's what I was going to do if the problem wasn't corrected.

  • Monique Finley3/5/2008

    Questions like these make us think. The problem is the difference between how we think we would react and the reality of how we do react. Nicely written,

  • mimpi3/4/2008

    I am not demanding and would wait until my turn comes (if of course it's systematic) and on other occasions, when it demands, I would raise my voice no matter what......great article - just loved it!! Thanks.

  • Chris M. Carmichael3/4/2008

    This is very interesting! great article :-)

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.