Which American Idol Judge is the Most Popular Today?

Joe Dorish
Do you know which American Idol judge is the most popular? In order to answer that question I ran the names of all the American Idol judges through a number of Internet websites to see who is the most popular. I searched the names of the original three judges - Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson, the two judges who were just fired - Kara DioGuardi and Ellen DeGeneres and the two new judges - Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler.

The results clearly show that one of the judges is far more popular than any of the others. Could it be Simon Cowell?

Google AdWords Keyword Tool

Simon Cowell - 301,000

Paula Abdul - 135,000

Randy Jackson - 90,500

Kara DioGuardi - 135,000

Ellen DeGeneres - 450,000

Jennifer Lopez - 1.8 million

Steven Tyler - 110,000

The Google AdWords Keyword Tool tells users how often a name or word is searched monthly on a global basis. The results of running the American Idol judges through the tool reveals that by far Jennifer Lopez is the most searched for judge with 1.8 million global monthly searches. Not too surprising since J.Lo has both a movie and singing career.

The second highest total is for Ellen DeGeneres who has continually bombed every time she has gotten a prime time show including on American Idol. You are a comedian Ellen but were just about the least funny person on the show when you were on Idol.

The lowest total is for the one original judge left - Randy Jackson with just 90,500 global monthly searches.

Google Search Engine

Simon Cowell - 3.9 million results

Paula Abdul - 2.4 million results

Randy Jackson - 2 million results

Kara DioGuardi - 7 million results

Ellen DeGeneres - 7.5 million results

Jennifer Lopez - 11.9 million results

Steven Tyler - 2.1 million results

The results from running the judges names through the Google Search Engine also reveals that Jennifer Lopez generates the most results but not by as big a margin as from the global monthly searches. The surprise to me on this list is how many results Kara DioGuardi generates. I never heard of her before American Idol but her name is on over 120 music albums and her dad was a United States Congressman.

Once again the only remaining judge Randy Jackson has the lowest total at 2 million results just below new judge Steven Tyler. Tyler is a risky choice as a judge on a live TV show as I personally watched him collapse on-stage while performing with Aerosmith in Providence, Rhode Island in the 1980's.

YouTube

Simon Cowell - 59,000

Paula Abdul - 5,580

Randy Jackson - 66,700

Kara DioGuardi - 4,790

Ellen DeGeneres - 45,300

Jennifer Lopez - 240,000

Steven Tyler - 5,430

The results from the YouTube search reveal once again that Jennifer Lopez is the most popular. Kara DioGuardi has the fewest results even though she did record a video of herself singing and put it on YouTube and it has over 1.5 million hits. Steven Tyler has the second lowest total but the Aerosmith video from the song "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" has over 71 million hits.

The surprise on the YouTube results is Randy Jackson who has the second highest total behind J.Lo.

Which American Idol Judge is the Most Popular?

The answer is clearly Jennifer Lopez. Her name is the most searched for and turns up the most results from both Google and YouTube.

How did Simon Cowell end up? While not the most popular in any category by any means Simon Cowell is also not the least popular in any category by a wide margin. Cowell was always the star of American Idol and without him it is unlikely American Idol will survive even with the huge star power Jennifer Lopez brings.

Ironically American Idol is what made Simon Cowell a celebrity so unlike all the other judges Cowell owes almost all of his fame and Internet results to being on the show.

For more see:

Angelina Jolie vs Jennifer Aniston: Who is More Popular Today?

Justin Bieber vs Lady Gaga: Who is More Popular Today?

Katy Perry vs Lady Gaga: Who is More Popular Today?

Sources:

Google AdWords Keyword Tool

Google Search Engine

YouTube

Published by Joe Dorish

Joe Dorish is a writer who lives in the NYC area. He writes primarily about the things he is passionate about - sports, business, economics, weather and travel. He loves to drive and used to own a Limo compa...  View profile

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.