Why Bad Hires Harm More Than Your Bottom Line

Marcia Robinson

Who has not heard the horror stories about the great applicant who turned out to be a really bad hire? No matter how tight the screening process, there are always some applicants who make it through the process with flying colors and who later turn out to be a bad fit for the organization. Bad hires come in many forms. It could be the person who has the skills, and is just not a good fit for the organization's culture. It could be someone whose skills are just not up to the assignments. In fact, it could be any one thing or any combination of factors. Before you think that a bad hire can only harm your company's bottom line; think again.

Bad hires can lower employee morale

Imagine an employee with all the right skills, but the wrong attitude? The old adage or one bad apple spoiling the whole bunch can become a reality in your company if a bad hire comes in with a rotten attitude. In some cases where the bad hire has the ear of the manager, which happens, the rest of the team might have to suffer, while the new employee gets his or her way. Before long company morale suffers. Although it is still possible to keep productivity up while morale goes down, managers should be aware of the potential impact on morale when they make bad hires.

Bad hires can ruin your reputation as a manager

A bad hires can kill a manager's reputation over night. In some cases managers recognize the bad hiring decision early and take steps to minimize the cost to company in terms of recruiting, benefits and training costs. Sometimes it is not so easy to correct a bad hiring decision and the manager who made the hiring decision could be on the hook for a long time. The hiring manager could lose respect and trust of both colleagues and higher level managers. Getting input on hiring decisions is one way to lower the risk of any one manager having all the responsibility for bringing a bad hire on board.

Published by Marcia Robinson

Marcia has been writing about work, employment, careers, education, entrepreneurship and related political issues for thirteen years. She has a strong commitment to supporting the personal and professional...  View profile

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Cathy A Montville11/18/2011

    Interesting article. It's funny... as a business owner, I've had so-so people turn out to be great employees. On the flip side, some people, who I thought would be terrific, were a huge disappointment. Also, my husband and I do all the hiring... so if one of us makes a bad call, we never let the other one live it down! :)

  • Delicia Powers11/15/2011

    Well said Marica

  • Laura Cone11/13/2011

    super

  • Harriet Steinberg11/12/2011

    This is so true. It's ashame it exists.

  • Lodie Quezada11/12/2011

    Excellent article.

  • Carol Rucker11/12/2011

    Great info. Thank goodness I don't supervise anybody but myself these days.

  • Karen LoBello11/12/2011

    Sometimes 'bad hires' can be elevated to success with more input and support from administration.

  • Michele Starkey11/12/2011

    "Bad hires" are just one of the reasons that many companies have the 60-day probation periods these days! cheers :)

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.