Why Does Anyone Homeschool Anyway?

Lyn Lomasi
Why does anyone homeschool anyway? There are millions of reasons people choose to homeschool. Most do so for some educational aspect and some do so for religious purposes. Though the reasons generally run deeper than that. I can't tell you why everyone else homeschools, but I can tell you about our decision to homeschool and why we thought it was the best choice for our family.

When we made the choice to homeschool, there were several reasons. Let's start from the beginning, before homeschooling. Two of my daughters, then in kindergarten and second grade, were attending public school. Everything was fantastic. We had a great school and the kids were doing very well. In fact, they were ahead of their peers in most areas. But, then things changed and we ended up moving to a new neighborhood. That meant a new school for the kids.

At first, things seemed fine, but then my exceptionally bright girls started going downhill in school. I didn't understand because they knew the facts. In fact, they were ahead. Then, after my visit to the school, I understood. This school was far behind according to state standards and rather than catching the children up to the correct levels, they were just working with them at the low levels.

The school's strategy was not helpful for my kids. This may have worked for the majority in that area. They were used to this and may have needed this. My children did not fit into this equation. They had come from a school that was above state standards. The things that were being taught at this school were things my children had learned already 1 or 2 years prior. They were getting bored. After effortlessly asking the school to at least place them in a class that was comparable to their level, I grew weary.

At first, I decided to just work on new things with them every day after school and on the weekends. We began using textbooks for their correct levels that I had to purchase myself. We frequented libraries, museums, and other places that taught them interesting things. By the end of the school year, most of what they learned having come from me, I was fed up.

I decided to do homeschool, but something else happened first. The good school the kids went to before said they could return in the fall for the new school year. I was so happy and the kids were excited. Well, things went well for a while. In fact, they were great. The youngest was in first grade, but had to attend second grade for literacy and math because she was so far ahead. It was still easy for her, but what else could they do? She didn't get into the gifted classes (missed by one point), so they did what they could and they did an awesome job, considering.

With kids who didn't align with the averages, area schools did not seem to have an answer. The oldest was way ahead in reading, but had gotten a touch behind in math. The teachers tried their hardest to do what they could, but it just wasn't feasible what with so many other students to worry about. So, pondering over the issues at hand, I again considered homeschooling. This time we went with it. I informed the district, bought tons of materials, and awaited the day. I chose to let the kids complete the first semester and stay long enough to do the upcoming music concert. So, we started homeschool a couple weeks into the second semester.

Another contributing factor was social skills. In so many public schools, including the ones our children attended, children are not allowed to work together or communicate during assignments. In fact, they are punished for talking to one another. I find this appalling. When they get out into the working world, most companies need their employees to work together. If they don't learn this concept in school, where will they learn it?

Perhaps this is one of the reasons many employees don't get along. They were never taught this in school, so when they get to the workplace, they just have to learn by trial and error. I would prefer my child already had these skills, so it would be easier to adapt. When we do our lessons, all of the children work together. Sometimes I give the instructions. Sometimes it is an instructor at a museum, art class, study program, or special class instructor.

Whatever format we use, I make sure that children are encouraged to work together and to think about why and how to solve a problem, not just told to do it and do it quietly. To further enhance social skills, we are in public often. I am in no way insulting those who choose to use public school. It works for some people. It's just not right for us. As with any form of schooling, there are good schools and bad schools, good teachers and bad teachers, and ups and downs.

Another factor that weighed in on us homeschooling was the freedom my children would have in learning new things. My children love to learn, so they needed an environment where they would not be held back when they wanted to press forward. It seems as though the more knowledge they get, the more they want, so I wanted them to be able to get all the information they wanted. I believe children should be allowed to move ahead, rather than have to wait for the rest of the class to catch up. Sometimes my kids learn at the same pace as each other. Sometimes they don't. I assess each one individually and come up with a plan that works with that child.

I use a combination of state standards (which we're usually ahead of) and my child's interests and levels to come up with the appropriate lesson plans. I believe that all schools should use this plan. Teaching a child works much more effectively when they are encouraged to thrive, rather than restricted to a plan that caters to an "average" person based on statistics. No one should be looked at as average. We are all special in our own ways. When you place people in categories, it only feeds into stereotypical setbacks. If a child is ready to advance, that child should never be discouraged from doing so.

School should be a place where a child gets the maximum education that he/she needs with no limits to what can be accomplished. The setting will be different for different people, but the most important thing is that the child gets a good education.

More from Lyn:

How to Homeschool: Will Public Schools Provide You with the Curriculum?

Homeschool Tips: Coping with Sending Your Kids to Traditional School

How to Homeschool: Integrate Field Trips into Homeschool Lessons

Published by Lyn Lomasi - Featured Contributor in Lifestyle

Lyn's the Community Advocate at Yahoo! Contributor Network. Contact her with community issues & ideas. She's been contributing since 2007 and previously acted as a Community Guide. Read her tips for success...   View profile

8 Comments

Post a Comment
  • Lorena Richie 3/7/2011

    I was homeschooled for a few years. So was my brother and sister. My brother stayed homeschooled the longest (in fact, he is still homeschooled is his senior year). Each child has unique needs, some of which may require homeschooling.

  • Jeff Rogers 3/7/2011

    We homeschool because we travel all over the U.S.A. Plus, my kids are far more advanced than the public school in our area (Hawaii) and it would be a useless attempt to send them to P.S. 666. Also, I get to see my kids advance and I know where to challenge them.

  • Lynda Altman 3/7/2011

    good article

  • Lee Andrew Henderson 2/22/2008

    Wow, they weren't allowed to talk to other students or communicate. That is dumb. That sounds a lot like what our school called "alternative school" which was for the kids that were being punished, like solitary confinement except with text books.

  • Sheretta Edwards 3/31/2007

    In my opinion, your suggestion that the public school should assess each student individually and then create lesson plans for each is just not possible...or realistic. There'd have to be one teacher for each student...and because that, too, is not possible, homeschooling is your best alternative...then parents could assess their own child(ren) and cater to their own personal learning needs. Myself a public school teacher and mother to a 19-month-old, I know firsthand the limitations placed on teachers by principals, principals by administrators, administrators by tax payers, etc. This leads to an imperfect public educational system. Parents who feel that they could do a better job SHOULD...and that's called homeschooling. In fact, my personal desire is to be able to leave the workforce and begin homeschooling my son when he turns kindergarten age.

  • Sharon Van Gaskin 2/22/2007

    Thanks for the info! I homeschool too. Someone recently suggested I read "Government Nannies" which addresses the origins of institutionalized public schooling. I'm tracking down a copy now.

  • Heather B. 2/21/2007

    When has homeschooling ever been considered truancy? It's nothing new. People were homeschooling 20-30 years ago, and before public schools existed, all children were homeschooled. This was a really great article. I plan to homeschool my son when he is older. :)

  • Doreen Bradley Satter 2/21/2007

    Good article. It's so nice to see a parent so concerned and willing to work very hard for their children to get a good education. It is not easy, I know. Your children sound wonderful and I know they will go far because of your sacrifices and hard work. Good luck to you, supermommy!

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.