Why You Should Not Put Your Child in Daycare

Ten Reasons Why Preschool is Not all it's Cracked Up to Be

Michelle Smith
Many women and men are forced to put their children in daycare due to the necessary fact that both parents must work to support the family. If corners can somehow be cut or unnecessary bills eliminated during this important stage of your child's life, I strongly support having one parent stay at home with their young ones.

There are many reasons why this is so, some proven by research and others proven by the backlash felt years after some of these kids grew up. Some I have seen and learned through personal experience as a teacher. Here are just a few to consider before enrolling your child in a daycare preschool environment.

1. Research proves many children reared in daycare become more defiant when older. Although negative behaviors will certainly occur during the age while your child is enrolled, this is usually typical of a growing child. What child doesn't question or defy authority at some point? The issue arises when research has proven that many daycare reared children grew up to become much more defiant in their 5th and 6th grade years of school. The study compared all of the children reported by teachers as having negative qualities such as bragging, lying, cheating, destruction of property, cruelty and an overall sense of disobedience for authority and their peers. Unsure of why this occurs, one can speculate. In today's times it is very difficult and sometimes against school policy to properly discipline a child immediately after the behavior has occurred. Waiting to be reprimanded by their parents when they get home just doesn't do the trick, and these negative behaviors are reinforced.

2. Is your preschooler really "smarter" than his or her homebound peers or just developmentally ahead? What may seem like genius observations and exclamations from your 3 year old may simply be a product of spending so much time with a variety of adults and a large group of children. In fact, studies have shown that although the vocabulary of preschool children is higher than others, most all children catch up to the same level in grade school. What may seem like pure amazement to your natural sense of parental pride may merely be an external factor that is pushing your child's development ahead of the predominate set of norms for the age group.

3. Children may develop a negative self-image at an early age and also be forced to endure "survival of the fittest" type behaviors. Let's face it, not all of the children in classes of 20 or more kids are going to be taught proper manners by their parents. Rude and inappropriate play skills may be a shock to your child who has thus far been taught sharing and respect. They will either always be giving in to the child who's parent's rely only on the daycare to raise their children or turn a leaf by learning to "survive" and mimic those inappropriate skills. Your child may not develop a voice to express him or herself when needed and becomes an early target for future low self-esteem issues, as well as trust and loyalty issues with peers.

4. If your child has been at home with you for the first few years, there may significant separation anxiety that could be avoided until a more appropriate age level. There's a reason why grade school starts when it does, folks. Separation anxiety can be a very powerful and hurtful experience for your child as I have personally seen in my experience. "Oh, they'll get over it", you may say. But maybe they won't. Maybe they will hold it against you and develop issues of distrust without either of you even realizing it until years later when your child ends up in therapy rehashing her poor unfortunate childhood. Okay, maybe I'm being a little over dramatic here, but the fact remains that psychological patterns are developed at a very young age when the brain is fresh and new. Is that something you want your child to learn at such a young age?

5. Your choice of specific daycare may be detrimental to your child's development without you ever knowing it. A high priced private academic preschool may seem ideal, but way out of your budget. When you enroll your child in ANY daycare setting, do you really ever know what goes on when you're not there? You may be given the impression your child is being taught and learning academic and relevant social skills, but are they really? Are they learning from an adult or learning from being with a group of similar peers who are all in this crazy thing called daycare together? Recently in my neighborhood a 3-year-old girl drowned in a swimming pool at the home based daycare she belonged to. I'm sure her parents thought they were giving her a well protected, nurturing environment compared to a commercial setting daycare. What do you think they are thinking about now?

6. Considering that most of the general public is religious and understanding that procreation is a natural process we are born to do, if you must put all of your kids in daycare from birth on, 7am until 6pm, WHY BOTHER HAVING ANY KIDS AT ALL? Better yet, after the first, why continue to have more? There is nothing more special than the birth of a child, so why lose that by putting them in daycare? Why let someone else have the joy of hearing their first word or watching them take their first step? If your reasons are not monetary necessity you should spend time reflecting on this and going over the pros and cons with your spouse or partner.

7. Children in daycare have been clinically proven to get four times as sick as children who stay at home. There are millions of microbes everywhere in a daycare Even a clean looking one contains millions of these evil little bacteria just waiting to get at your child, since microbes are invisible to the eye. Microbes are responsible for many common illnesses such as the flu, a common cold or a stomach virus. Other dominant daycare illnesses include ringworm and conjunctivitis. Both are potentially harmless but contagious. Hand, Foot and Mouth disease as well as chicken pox, scarlet fever (from strep throat) and Fifth disease are other illnesses I have witnessed numerous times. Not only are these unnecessarily unpleasant for your child but can cause you to lose days from work. Particulates in the air containing dust and industrial chemicals are another problem, especially for allergy and asthma sufferers.

8. Your kid's teacher may be sweet and nice, but is she knowledgeable and experienced? Is she patient and willing to work with you? Does he or he have significant lessons to share with you and enrich your child's love of learning? Many daycare teachers do not yet possess their Bachelor's degrees due to the low wages they receive. Many are also very young and inexperienced, unable to correctly diagnose your child's developmental needs and possible problems. In today's times when Autism effects every 1 in 150 children born in America, an educated teacher is imperative for first time parents. Many parents also look to the teacher to tell them what they should be reinforcing at home. An uneducated teacher may be setting your child's goals either too low or too high. Either way they're causing an imbalance in the core needs of your child.

9. Not all daycares provide the love and attention young growing children desperately need. Although the caregivers may be warm and friendly, they have 19 or so other children to look after. Every time your child feels like he or she needs a hug or word of encouragement they may be let down. Sure it's the parent's job to give children this type of attention, but what type of psychological stereotypes of others are you helping to set up here? Maybe your child is smart enough to question why they don't get what they need, but internalize it. Or maybe they begin to act out. Maybe still they bottle it up and save it for years later as studies have proven.

10. Your child is your first and most important priority. If you can do without weekend dinners out and other superfluous activities, then do so. It will surely be the best thing you could do for your child. Remember that not all effects are brought out right away, and you don't want to have to pay the price of dealing with your child's issues (and psychiatrist bills) later on in life.

Published by Michelle Smith

A native New Yorker who writes about anything whenever the mood strikes.  View profile

  • Your children are your first priority, whether your working or staying home puts them there.
  • Think about WHY your child is in preschool and research your answers.
  • Talk to your child extensively about his or her day at school to stay involved.
Only one day care slot in ten meets the definition of "high quality care" according to a study done by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.

21 Comments

Post a Comment
  • I ve done it only one way...Daycare12/19/2010

    I had two kids in daycare almost from day 1. While I thought it was good for them to socialize, I sure missed alot. I agree with the picking-up-bad-habits theory as well. If I could do it all over again, my kids would go into day care one year before school so they could acclimate. There are neighborhood kids, libraries and relatives for the kids to play with. Me and my kids might have loved each other a lot more had they been home with me or with grandma.

  • Angela7/13/2010

    You are not even a mother, so what point of view do you have on this subject. This is a badly written article, full of self opinions that you know nothing about. Plus this is not the 1950s anymore, have you noticed? This war working mom vs. stay-at-home mom has been going on for years. I don't think the parents are the problem. The United States government has always been lacking in this area, to create an environment that helps working families.

  • Guest5/19/2010

    -a Mother is.

  • Guest5/19/2010

    I've worked in early childcare for 7 years, and this article is very accurate to what I see daily. My boss does not want me to report when I've seen a first step, a first word, or many of the other "firsts" for fear of upsetting the parents. I am with these children more than their own parents (7a.m. to 6p.m.) and convincing yourself that you're not letting someone else raise your child is a joke. When people say they "can't afford" to not work, its primarily because they have an expensive house, two cars, and go on expensive vacations that needs to be payed for. Like one of the other posters, they're not even considering cutting corners and having less to stay home and raise their children. I realize that most of the commenters finding this article "rude" are the ones dumping their kids off in daycare 10 hours a day, so they're feeling a little ganged up on. Daycare and two cars and a big paycheck from your "career" is NOT the best option for your child, you staying at home and being

  • Rebecca4/1/2010

    Daycare providers are supposed to be trained professionals paid to watch the children at all times. It is much different than being a mother. There should be no down time for a daycare provider, no option to answer a phone for a second or grab a basket of laundry in lieu of watching the child. Under no circumstances is it an accident for a daycare provider to be so absent minded that a child is left behind unattended to drown in a pool.

  • SAHM too4/1/2010

    I forgot to add, I think the mention of the child who drowned at a home daycare was a low blow. I'm sure the parents and the daycare provider are all devestated. I know a little girl who drowned in her parents pool. Her mother is a SAHM. You think she hasn't asked herself why she didnt just put her precious little girl in daycare? You think she hasn't run 100 'what if' scenarios in her head?? Whats the moral of the story? Pools are dangerous. Parents and daycare providers alike should be extremely cautious.

  • SAHM too4/1/2010

    SAHM, I agree with your analogy. No doubt breast milk is better for baby than formula. As a mother who was not physically able to breastfeed, I was grateful for the option of formula, and I am happy and grateful that my children are healthy. And while I would have made a different choice if I could, I certainly have no room to look down at another mother who formula fed-- whatever her reasons. It's the same with daycare. Staying at home might be better, but it's not an option for everyone. And if a parent can raise a healthy, well adjusted child in daycare (they can-- despite the doomsday tone of the article, it happens all the time), why should they feel bad about that choice?

  • LeeAnne4/1/2010

    Seriously? The proper choice, according to this article is either be a SAHM or... not be a mother at all? If my mother had made that choice I WOULDNT BE HERE!! Glad she didn't read your article before she had me.

  • SAHM3/19/2010

    you know, i've heard all the excuses..."i can't afford to stay home, i have to go to school, i have to work..." blah blah blah. I totally agree with this article. It's like trying to tell people that formula is just as good for a baby as breast milk. Of course it isn't. Will it give you a healthy baby? Sure. Was it the best choice? Absolutely not. Same thing with daycare. Anyone who can, with a straight face, tell you that daycare is just as good as Mommy, is fooling themselves. We sacrifice a lot so I can stay home with our children. We don't go out to dinners, we only have one car. We have one, old tv and we don't have cable, we don't go on vacations, we don't send our clothes to the dry cleaners and we grow our own veggies in the summer. But our children know their parents. I don't think I'll ever regret knowing I was there for my kids, that I never missed one single minute of their achievements and I was responsible for their happiness and their well-being. I know people with their

  • Rebecca1/2/2010

    I am not a mother but an educated and experienced educator who has worked in both good preschools as well as bad ones, so I assure you my article is credible. They are not based on my own parenting skills as many of you seem to suggest. Even the very best schools more often than not bite off more than they can chew, I promise you this. Please read the article carefully to understand which of these environments I am referring to - unfortunately it is a cold, hard fact that there are more BAD "daycare" environments calling themselves schools than good ones that actually benefit your child. More often than not, the school needs to survive and enrolls more children than it can handle. More often than not the school hires unqualified teachers because the pay is lower than a traditional school environment where the educated teachers want to work. More often than not, the school can actually afford will not be nearly as good as the one you wish you could. While I am certain there are good pre

Displaying Comments
Next »

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.