Why Satellite Radio Will Beat FM

The Death of FM Radio is on Its Way

Phil Dotree
I wandered over the median while trying to find something listenable in Louisiana.

The last two hours had been filled with commercials, annoying DJs raised in the Gilbert Gottfried school of not annoying people, and radio friendly alt-rock that would make Phil Collins wince.

An oncoming car swerved out of my way and flashed its lights, honking angrily. That was it. This was getting dangerous, and I was getting tired. No more radio.

There's something desperately wrong with FM radio if I can't find a song or show that stops my scan button; I'd been driving for hours on a solo tour for an acoustic album I was trying to sell, and at one point my cigarette had even burned my fingers because I hadn't moved them from the dial for so long.

So, as soon as I reached the next town, I bought a satellite radio at the first Best Buy I saw.

FM radio has been a good friend to me in the past, but it's past its prime in a number of ways; there are thirteen minutes or more of commercials every hour, each song is thrust onto the air by a corporate bribe to a radio station head leaving independent music out in the cold, and the censorship was getting so bad that I started to notice words like "suicide" and-I swear to God - "Rock and Roll" being unnecessarily edited out for fear of an FCC fine. It was time to leave FM radio dying in the gutter and embrace a new medium.

Satellite radio has been gaining popularity for quite simply becoming what FM radio should have been for the last dozen or so years: a free-spirited place to listen to music and opinions, the material only censored by your own discretion, the channels vast and varied in their content. Satellite radio offers a steady signal nearly anywhere in the United States, which FM can't claim, and its audiences pay a monthly fee to keep commercials where they should be-far the hell away from music.

Since my switch to satellite radio, I haven't looked back in distaste at either the money I've spent or the old friend I've left behind. As Dylan said, the times they are a changin', Dylan who, by the way, has a show on satellite radio (XM, specifically).

The concept is simple and beautiful. You see, the satellite companies function by offering a product that not everyone will go for, similar to cable TV. The right wing conservative Christians aren't gonna be rushing out to hear Howard Stern on Sirius radio, nor will non-music fans spend the dough for a brand spankin' new XM radio receiver. With a small monthly charge, they can cater to the fans that FM radio used to have, and win their souls over in a more complete way than a technology based on advertising can offer.

The lack of government control makes for a free environment, which gives satellite radio that spontaneity that radio had at some point-when I was a kid, maybe, listening to KSHE95 on a hot summer day while laying next to a fan, hoping that the next song would be the one I'd waited all day to record onto my tape deck.

Finally, the friend was back. The big, bad control system was gone. It was like things used to be.

Technology is great for doubling back on itself; I can finally hear the radio again. All it took was some exclusivity. And, of course, my $12 a month.

FM radio is in its last throes because it's simply not interesting or entertaining in a large way anymore. As the advertising dollars dry up, we'll see something happen to FM that will echo AM's fate. And guess what? Nobody's going to really mourn.

Satellite radio's here to stay.

Published by Phil Dotree - Featured Contributor in Technology

Phil Dotree has written copy for numerous websites and news sites for five years. His articles have appeared on the Howard Stern Show, Fark, Digg.com, and more. Phil is currently working on a book about fr...  View profile

  • FM Radio is full of too many commercials to function.
  • The FCC's limitations have made free radio unlistenable.
  • Satellite radio's exclusivity allows it to function on a level that FM radio can't.
On average, FM radio has 13-14 minutes of commercials per hour, compared with 4-6 minutes on talk stations on satellite radio (most satellite music stations don't have commercials).

7 Comments

Post a Comment
  • L.A.H11/24/2006

    Great article, I've had Sirius for a year now and love it. Thank god for satellite radio and being able to listen to what I want "house/trance", without the corporate world (mainstream)shoving their music at me.

  • Paula Neal Mooney11/24/2006

    I love XM. I love this article. The first sentence cracked me up and I read all the way thru to the great end. And I've never listened to Sirius yet, but I'm hooked on XM's Spirit channel, as well as the 80s, 90s, Lucy, Ethel and other stations. They even play - gasp! - unsigned artists. You're correct, satellite is here to stay.

  • anonymous11/24/2006

    Don't mind commercials, don't like today's FM radio content, don't like to pay for radio.

    I'm a big internet radio fan, sorry, don't want to pay for radio, I spend enough money on CDs and vinyl already

  • Amy Brantley11/23/2006

    One word, commercials. Sirius is known for having commercial free channels, something XM used to have. Now XM just has a few channels that are commercial free. I like their choice of music, but I find myself having to constantly change channels to get away from the commercials. If I wanted commercials I'd listen to my local stations for free. Nothing wrong with the music though, when they actually play some.

  • J. Perez11/22/2006

    Amy Brantley: XM is by FAR superior to Sirius! The programing is o varied and I've heard so many new bands on XM (particularly in rock/alt-rock categories) that Sirius won't even Touch! Event the reception and "black" spots seem to be less frequent on XM than on Sirius. What do you find that's so bad about XM?

  • moeursalen11/22/2006

    Exactly right....I thought I was the type who would never buy satellite radio when it was first explained to me. Until I tried it. We're Sirius. And lots happier, especially when driving.

  • Amy Brantley11/22/2006

    I love satellite radio, I just wish I had went with Sirius instead of XM.

Displaying Comments

To comment, please sign in to your Yahoo! account, or sign up for a new account.